dot-iu-cutter v0.5 Automation Orchestrator Design Ready — GPT Ruling

Date: 2026-05-20 Reviewer / decision authority: GPT Reviewed package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-automation-orchestrator-design/

Verdict

automation_orchestrator_design: PASS
result: AUTOMATION_ORCHESTRATOR_DESIGN_READY
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
production_mutation: NONE
repo_mutation: NONE
current_repo_HEAD: 0a64a61
next_phase: O1_AUTHORING_ONLY
next_effort: medium_high_or_high

The v0.6 automation orchestrator design is accepted. The design correctly converts the proven v0.5 Constitution cut process into an operation-first, one-command workflow with survey-first, discover-first, no-user-artifact, hardcode-safe, batch-capable, fail-closed gates.

Accepted design facts

user_input_model:
  mandatory: cutter orchestrate cut --document-id <X>
  optional_flags: 3
  user_supplies_artifacts_or_secrets: false

state_machine:
  states: 14
  internal_gates: 11
  sovereign_gates: 3
  intervention_reduction: approximately_22_to_2_per_document

phases:
  count: 11
  source: reuse_v0_5_proven_modules
  MVP_lifecycle: draft_to_enacted_only

idempotency:
  layers:
    - sidecar
    - DB_UNIQUE
    - module_recorders
  constitution_pins_policy: per_run_RunContext_context_pins_not_module_constants

batch_mode:
  approvals: pre_batched_TTL_12h_consume_once
  queues:
    - error
    - quarantine
    - human_review
  serialized_phase: phase_6_global_across_lanes

Ruling

selected_next: O1_AUTHORING_ONLY
scope:
  - create orchestrator module skeletons
  - define contracts/interfaces/state objects
  - create test stubs and static tests
  - no production execution
  - no deploy/restart/push/tag
  - no production DB mutation
  - no full orchestrator live run

O1 should stay implementation-skeleton only. It can be medium-high/high because the architecture has already been designed; xhigh is only needed if the Agent must reopen the state machine, sovereign-gate model, batch semantics, or runtime deployment architecture.

Still forbidden

forbidden:
  - production mutation
  - deploy/restart
  - push/tag remote
  - live CUT/VERIFY/enact through orchestrator
  - source_document/source_version mutation
  - real crypto replacement
  - hardcoded secrets/runtime ids

Final status

status: AUTOMATION_DESIGN_CLOSED_PASS__O1_AUTHORING_ONLY_NEXT
next_action: run_orchestrator_O1_authoring_only_macro