dot-iu-cutter v0.5 WS-1 Cleanup Edge/Binding/Authority — GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-18 Reviewer: GPT Reviewed cleanup package: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-fabric-addendum-scope/

Reviewed files:

files:
  - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-WS1-edge-APR-minimization-note-2026-05-18.md
  - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-WS1-binding-authority-clarification-note-2026-05-18.md

Verdict

ws1_cleanup_phase: PASS
agent_behavior: PASS_CORRECT
opus_review: CORRECT
forbidden_respected: true
self_advance_respected: true
ws1_authority_status: READY_TO_PROMOTE
execution_authorized: false

The cleanup phase completed correctly. Agent followed GPT's prior rulings, did not approve/create edge types, did not run schema/code/dry-run, and stopped for review.

---

Review findings

1. Edge APR minimization

Agent correctly reduced the original OD-FA4 six edge candidates to one true new-edge APR candidate.

edge_minimization_result:
  constrains:
    bucket: reuse_existing
    resolution: governed_by directional + assembly metadata
    new_edge_needed: false

  maps_to_process:
    bucket: entity_binding_or_assembly_relation
    resolution: iu_entity_binding for raw process entity; references/implements for IU↔IU
    new_edge_needed: false

  maps_to_code:
    bucket: entity_binding_or_assembly_relation
    resolution: iu_entity_binding for code file/module; implements/references for IU↔IU
    new_edge_needed: false

  maps_to_requirement:
    bucket: entity_binding_or_assembly_relation
    resolution: implements/governed_by + compliance_matrix assembly-local relation
    new_edge_needed: false
    note: weak deferred candidate only if future pilot proves insufficiency

  evidenced_by:
    bucket: true_new_edge_requires_APR
    resolution: sole APR candidate
    new_edge_needed: true

  lesson_from:
    bucket: reuse_existing
    resolution: derived_from + source_family=lesson
    new_edge_needed: false

GPT confirms:

smallest_new_edge_set: [evidenced_by]
approved_now: false
APR_required_before_use: true

2. evidenced_by APR readiness

The APR-ready wording for evidenced_by is accepted as a draft input for a future APR, not as approval.

evidenced_by:
  status: APR_READY_DRAFT
  approval_status: NOT_APPROVED
  requires: GPT/User APR cấp medium under P44-4A §3.3 / Điều 32 route

Rationale: evidenced_by expresses durable evidence/attestation semantics that are not equivalent to references, implements, or derived_from.

3. Dependency note on governed_by and derived_from

Opus correctly flagged that governed_by and derived_from are P44-4A candidate edges pending v1.0 enactment.

GPT ruling:

governed_by_and_derived_from:
  status: dependency_not_blocker_for_WS1_authority
  action: track_under_P44_candidate_activation_or_WS2_dependency_note
  caution: if unavailable, impacted resolutions must be revisited before WS-3 execution

This is not a blocker for promoting WS-1 design authority because no execution or edge creation is authorized yet.

4. Binding boundary

The registered_object vs raw_entity boundary is accepted.

registered_object:
  mechanism: universal_edges
  condition: both ends governed Objects/IUs under P44-4A/OQC contracts

raw_entity:
  mechanism: iu_entity_binding
  condition: one side is external/business/operational authority object not governed as IU/Object

rule: assembly_profile may consume both universal_edges and iu_entity_binding

This should be treated as binding guidance for WS-2 and WS-3.

5. Authority semantics

The default + override model is accepted.

authority_semantics:
  default: derive from source_family registry
  override: unit-level or span-level authority_role override for mixed-authority source material
  output_requirement: assembly output labels each included unit as normative_authority, evidence_authority, or implementation_authority for that assembly context

This resolves the mixed-authority edge case Opus previously flagged.

---

Promotion ruling

promote_WS1_authority: YES

The current WS-1 authority package is:

WS1_authority_package:
  folder: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.5-fabric-addendum-scope/
  files:
    - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-fabric-addendum-existing-design-map-and-workstreams-2026-05-18.md
    - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-WS1-relation-topic-assembly-design-brief-2026-05-18.md
    - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-fabric-addendum-open-decisions-2026-05-18.md
    - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-fabric-addendum-report-2026-05-18.md
    - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-WS1-edge-APR-minimization-note-2026-05-18.md
    - dot-iu-cutter-v0.5-WS1-binding-authority-clarification-note-2026-05-18.md

These six files should now be treated as the current WS-1 design authority for Information Unit Fabric addendum work.

---

Next routing

Primary next phase

Open WS-2 as the next design-only phase:

next_phase: v0_5_WS2_metadata_key_registry_and_source_profile_design
nature: design_only

WS-2 should cover:

WS2_scope:
  - metadata_key_registry concrete design based on v0.5 concept
  - source_profile / source_family registry
  - grammar_profile per source family
  - authority_semantics default mapping by source_family
  - unit/span-level authority_role override storage shape
  - entity_reference_registry core-minimal concretization
  - canonical_address namespacing dependency OD-A1
  - prepare for internal Incomex Constitution + external government law source families

Parallel/conditional phase

Prepare, but do not approve, the APR for evidenced_by:

parallel_candidate_phase: evidenced_by_edge_APR_draft
nature: design_only_APR_draft
approval_status: GPT/User_required

Recommendation: WS-2 may proceed first. The APR draft for evidenced_by can run in parallel or immediately after WS-2. WS-3 must not run cross-source assembly with evidenced_by until APR readiness/approval path is explicitly resolved.

Later phases

later:
  WS3: assembly_by_topic_cross_source after WS-2 + evidenced_by APR readiness or explicit no-evidenced_by decision
  WS4: edit/amend/supersede after WS-1 + WS-2 and 23-P2 prerequisite

---

Forbidden remains

still_forbidden:
  - schema migration
  - table creation
  - edge type creation
  - production write
  - code change
  - index DDL execution
  - CUT
  - VERIFY
  - dry-run
  - Directus mutation
  - vector/NoSQL integration
  - git commit
  - Agent self-advance

Final status

status: WS1_CLEANUP_PASS__WS1_AUTHORITY_PROMOTED
next_action: open_WS2_design_only_phase