dot-iu-cutter v0.4 — PG-backed Dry-run RERUN#4 SUCCESS GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-17 Reviewer: GPT Reviewed report: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.4-db-adapter-dry-run/dot-iu-cutter-v0.4-pg-backed-dry-run-RERUN4-SUCCESS-2026-05-17.md

Verdict

pg_backed_dry_run_rerun4: PASS
isolated_real_PostgreSQL_dry_run: PASS
code_commit_validated: e93424b5ff7fa5e4b8406131977ce4339cd0856a
happy_path_MARK_SWEEP_REVIEW_CUT_VERIFY: PASS
r3_15_row_baseline: PASS
negative_idempotency_delta0: PASS
dot_pair_signature_cross_reference: PASS
dot_lane_overlap_prevention: PASS
production_touched: false
production_CUT_VERIFY_allowed_now: false
deploy_allowed_now: false

Accepted Validation

validated:
  - RealPostgresAdapter_transaction_lifecycle_fix
  - LedgerWriter_schema_binding_to_deployed_schema
  - UUID_safe_CUT_VERIFY_signing_body
  - DOT_991_change_set_reference_only
  - DOT_992_verify_result_reference_only
  - deployed_dot_pair_signature_XOR_constraint
  - MARK_idempotency_PK_replay_no_insert
  - forbidden_write_denials_42501
  - transaction_rollback_atomicity
  - DELETE_TRUNCATE_refused
  - final_15_row_matrix_exact

Final happy-path row matrix:

decision_backlog_entry: 1
decision_backlog_history: 5
decision_backlog_dependency: 0
decision_backlog_sweep_log: 1
manifest_envelope: 1
manifest_unit_block: 1
review_decision: 1
dot_pair_signature: 2
cut_change_set: 1
cut_change_set_affected_row: 1
verify_result: 1
canonical_address_alias: 0
total: 15

Negative/idempotency result:

negatives_delta0: true
S8: PASS
S9: PASS_expected_42501_STOP
S10: PASS_replay_existing_entry_no_insert
S11: PASS_transaction_rollback_atomicity
S12: PASS_delete_truncate_refused

Safety / Hygiene Accepted

current_run_prod_dump_shredded_on_success: true
DR_container_removed_exact_name: true
DR_network_removed_exact_name: true
protected_envs_untouched: true
production_sysid_pre_post_unchanged: true
production_write: false
production_secret_read: false
secret_leak_absent: true
forbidden_SQL_absent: true
no_iucutter_code_change_during_rerun: true
git_status_iu_cutter_clean: true

Hardcode / Metadata-label Control

no_fixed_IP_DSN_password_vector_collection_introduced: true
config_from_dry_run_env_only: true
no_runtime_label_key_hardcoding: true
no_label_columns_added: true
no_label_registry_or_metadata_schema_change: true
SQL_SSOT_preserved: true
JSONB_not_hidden_authority: true
vector_NoSQL_untouched: true

Honest Note

The report identifies cosmetic stale keys in RESULT.json (fail_gate=G_HARNESS_NEG / fail_detail) due to merge behavior from previous runs. Authoritative signals indicate success: execution_status=SUCCESS, ORCH_EXIT=0, log says all gates pass, and gate booleans are true.

This does not block the dry-run PASS, but must be logged as a future harness hygiene item:

future_harness_hygiene:
  - reset_RESULT_json_per_run_or_write_fresh_file
  - avoid_merge_carryover_of_fail_gate_fail_detail

Gate Effect

pg_backed_dry_run: closed_PASS
v0_4_code_real_PG_dry_run_validation: complete
next_allowed_phase_options:
  - production_command_review_for_first_controlled_CUT_VERIFY_trial
  - pre_production_harness_hygiene_closeout
  - pre_scale_index_only_design_cycle
  - information_unit_label_registry_design_cycle

Recommended Next Route

GPT recommendation: do not jump straight to production. First author a short v0.4 PG-backed dry-run closeout + first production trial routing note covering:

routing_note_required:
  - summarize_PASS_evidence
  - define_if_first_production_trial_targets_one_noncritical_information_unit_or_sandbox_publication
  - define_command_review_requirements_for_production_CUT_VERIFY
  - carry_forward_harness_RESULT_json_hygiene_note
  - carry_forward_pre_scale_index_DDL_before_bulk_runs
  - carry_forward_label_metadata_registry_before_large_scale_labeling
  - forbid_bulk_cut_until_pre_scale_indexes_and_label_strategy_are_ready

Still Forbidden Without Separate Authorization

forbidden:
  - production_CUT_VERIFY
  - production_row_write
  - production_secret_read_outside_command_review
  - deploy_or_service_restart
  - bulk_cut_or_bulk_reclassification
  - index_DDL_without_separate_design
  - label_registry_schema_change_without_separate_design
  - vector_or_NoSQL_integration_without_separate_design

Status

ready_for_closeout_and_routing_note_prompt: true
agent_self_advance_to_production: prohibited