dot-iu-cutter v0.4 — Cutter-Agent Code Authoring GPT Initial Review

Date: 2026-05-16
Reviewer: GPT
File reviewed: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.4-code/dot-iu-cutter-v0.4-cutter-agent-code-authoring-report-2026-05-16.md
Scope: Initial code-authoring review. No runtime action authorized.

---

1. Initial Verdict

agent_report_status: ACCEPTED_AS_CONSISTENT
code_review_final_PASS: not_yet
reason: first_real_runtime_code_requires_evidence_package_or_direct_code_review
agent_revision_needed_now: false
evidence_package_required: true
production_action_allowed: false
credential_cycle_allowed: false
dry_run_allowed: false

The report is internally consistent and Opus review is plausible. However, because this is the first actual runtime code for the cutter agent, GPT does not issue a final code PASS from the report alone.

---

2. What Is Accepted Provisionally

repo: /opt/incomex/dot
package: /opt/incomex/dot/iu-cutter
commit: 689e53e
files_created: 16
tests_reported: 45/45 PASS
production_touch_reported: none
scope_reported: in_memory_only

---

3. Required Evidence Before Final Code PASS

Agent must produce a code review evidence package from the VPS SSOT repo. It should not modify runtime code.

Required evidence:

repo_state:
  - git_show_689e53e_stat
  - git_show_689e53e_name_status
  - git_status_short_scoped
  - confirmation_unrelated_WIP_not_staged_or_committed
file_tree:
  - find iu-cutter -maxdepth 3 -type f sorted
source_evidence:
  - cli.py full or essential snippets
  - db_adapter.py full or essential snippets
  - state_machine.py full or essential snippets
  - idempotency.py full or essential snippets
  - ledger.py full or essential snippets
  - phases.py full or essential snippets
  - canonicalization.py / signing.py safety markers
  - signal.py local/test-only contract
security_evidence:
  - ProductionDBAdapter refuses construction
  - cutter_ro/directus/workflow_admin/postgres cannot write
  - no DSN required
  - no secret printed
  - --production refused rc=2
  - no .env access
  - no DB client import or network connection in package
  - no Qdrant/Directus client import
behavior_evidence:
  - CLI demo output
  - unittest output 45/45
  - local py3.11 parity if available
  - examples of valid/forbidden transition tests
  - OD-6 test showing CUT leaves verifier_signature_id NULL
  - VERIFY owns verifier signature

---

4. Output Required

Create one evidence document:

knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.4-code/dot-iu-cutter-v0.4-cutter-agent-code-review-evidence-2026-05-16.md

Do not create new code revisions unless a defect is found. If a defect is found, STOP and report before fixing.

---

5. Status

ready_for_final_GPT_code_review_after_evidence: true
code_final_PASS_now: false