dot-iu-cutter v0.3 — Read-Observability Dry-Run Re-Run GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-16
Reviewer: GPT
Files reviewed: v0.3 dry-run re-run execution report, verification results, artefact index
Scope: Dry-run review only. No production execution authorized.

---

1. Verdict

v0_3_read_observability_dry_run_rerun_status: PASS_WITH_NOTES
agent_revision_needed: false
all_4_false_negatives_resolved: true
verification: ALL_PASS_VERIFY_FAIL_COUNT_0
rollback: PASS
production_touched: false
command_review_allowed_after_explicit_prompt: true
production_execution_allowed_now: false

The corrected harness is accepted. The dry-run re-run is clean enough to open the production command-review phase.

---

2. Confirmed Evidence

dry_run_env: pg-dryrun-v0.3-readobs-rerun-2026-05-16
sysid_distinct_from_production: true
DDL_sha256: 065ee6d3f1aac760715cb6cc1bc8aa243d680fa20128a3c05e2b679f318e3b04
rollback_sha256: 059f1dcf0154eac260a0b47c08c161ee45ecb7a8b60d634349da894d7e611a5c
harness_sha256: 5f9a30ab787f5f206d0391714cc0105eadf3600badaeba4cb61596bddef48dc4
DDL_execution: rc_0_single_transaction
rollback_execution: rc_0

---

3. Verification Accepted

role_cutter_ro:
  exists: true
  NOLOGIN: true
  NOSUPERUSER: true
  NOCREATEDB: true
  NOCREATEROLE: true
  NOREPLICATION: true
  NOBYPASSRLS: true
  memberships: 0
views:
  observe_views_count: 12
  cutter_ro_SELECT_on_views: 12
  cutter_ro_SELECT_on_base_tables: 0
  write_permissions: 0
columns:
  redacted_columns_present: 0
  visible_columns_total: 134
  viewdef_redaction_leak: 0
state:
  base_tables_count: 12
  base_PKs: 12
  base_FKs: 19
  base_rows: 0
  RLS_enabled: 0
  Directus_collections_unchanged: true
  Directus_permissions_unchanged: true

---

4. Accepted Note

N_1_public_schema_USAGE:
  accepted: true
  class: PostgreSQL_default_PUBLIC_USGAGE_note_only
  not_v0_3_introduced: true
  no_data_access_granted: true
  revoke_not_authorized: true
  carry_to_command_review: true

---

5. Rollback Accepted

rollback_guard_members: 0
rollback_guard_owns_deptype_o: 0
role_removed_post_rollback: true
views_removed_post_rollback: true
base_12_tables_intact: true
PK12_FK19_intact: true
RLS_unchanged: true
Directus_unchanged: true
env_torn_down: true
production_read_only_only: true

---

6. Gate Effect

ready_for_production_command_review_package: true
ready_for_production_execution_prompt: false

Agent may author the production command-review package next. It must not execute production commands.

---

7. Status

production_DDL_executed: false
production_GRANT_executed: false
Directus_changed: false
RLS_changed: false
CUT_VERIFY: false