dot-iu-cutter v0.2 — Structural Schema Completion GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-16
Reviewer: GPT
File reviewed: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.2-execution/dot-iu-cutter-v0.2-p0-6-p0-5-remainder-production-rerun-execution-report-2026-05-16.md
Scope: Production re-run execution review. No CUT, VERIFY, app/tooling integration, or further migration authorized.

---

1. Verdict

production_rerun_execution_status: PASS
v0_2_structural_schema_complete: true
agent_revision_needed: false
rollback_triggered: false
production_state: SAFE
collateral_change: false
scope_expansion: false
next_step: v0_2_closeout_and_handoff

The final v0.2 structural batch is accepted and ratified.

---

2. Confirmed Execution Results

DDL_revision_used: r2
DDL_sha256: 89652d5f1f22dad18b6dfeaf88dc77b3452e78a0f28cc79befa389af3025c4b0
r1_used: false
r3_created: false
fresh_backup_age_at_C06: 6_seconds
C_05_preflight: ALL_PASS
C_06_migration: SUCCESS_rc_0_COMMIT
C_07_corrected_verification: ALL_PASS
C_08_rollback: not_triggered
production_sysid_unchanged: true

The harness fix is accepted. C-07 now uses structural FK comparison from catalog data rather than fragile pg_get_constraintdef string matching.

---

3. Final Production State

cutter_governance_table_count: 12
new_final_batch_tables:
  review_decision:
    rows: 0
  decision_backlog_history:
    rows: 0
  decision_backlog_dependency:
    rows: 0
  decision_backlog_sweep_log:
    rows: 0
FK_count_on_new_tables: 7

Expected live table set:

v0_1:
  - decision_backlog_entry
  - dot_pair_signature
  - cut_change_set
  - cut_change_set_affected_row
  - verify_result
phase_alpha:
  - canonical_address_alias
P0_2:
  - manifest_envelope
  - manifest_unit_block
P0_6_P0_5_remainder:
  - review_decision
  - decision_backlog_history
  - decision_backlog_dependency
  - decision_backlog_sweep_log

---

4. Non-Scope Confirmed

INSERT_seed_backfill: false
production_CUT: false
production_VERIFY: false
Qdrant_vector_mutation: false
app_deploy: false
P0_2_change: false
phase_alpha_change: false
v0_1_change: false
public_tac_logical_unit_change: false
sandbox_tac_logical_unit_change: false
further_migration_started: false

---

5. Operational Boundary

This review ratifies structural schema completion only. It does not authorize:

not_authorized:
  - production_CUT
  - production_VERIFY
  - app_or_tooling_integration
  - data_writes_into_cutter_governance
  - Qdrant_or_vector_mutation
  - Directus_permissions_or_UI_changes
  - further_schema_migration

---

6. Required Closeout

Agent should create a v0.2 closeout and handoff package next. The closeout must include:

required_outputs:
  - v0_2_production_handoff_status
  - v0_2_structural_schema_inventory
  - v0_2_post_execution_backup_verification
  - v0_3_or_app_tooling_next_phase_routing_note

No production action is authorized by this closeout request except a read-only/post-execution backup verification if explicitly included in the next prompt.

---

7. Status

v0_2_schema_layer: DONE
next_layer: app_tooling_and_integration_design
agent_self_advance_to_next_layer: prohibited