dot-iu-cutter v0.2 — P0-6 + P0-5 Remainder Production Command Review GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-16
Reviewer: GPT
File reviewed: P0-6 + P0-5 Remainder Production Command-Review Package
Scope: Command review only. No production command executed by GPT.

---

1. Verdict

p0_6_p0_5_remainder_production_command_review_status: PASS
agent_revision_needed: false
production_execution_prompt_allowed: true
production_execution_authorized_by_this_review: false
next_step: explicit_final_v0_2_production_execution_prompt

The command-review package is accepted. Production execution may proceed only under the explicit execution prompt referencing this review.

---

2. Accepted Command Plan

commands_total: 8
planned_mutating_command: C_06_migration
conditional_rollback_command: C_08_only_if_post_commit_verification_fails_and_explicitly_triggered
safety_gates: 11
DDL_revision: r2
DDL_sha256: 89652d5f1f22dad18b6dfeaf88dc77b3452e78a0f28cc79befa389af3025c4b0

Accepted sequence:

• C-01 fresh production backup;
• C-02 backup checksum and age stamp;
• C-03 pre-migration schema snapshot;
• C-04 pre-migration row-count snapshot;
• C-05 preflight checks;
• C-06 atomic r2 migration with ON_ERROR_STOP=1;
• C-07 post-migration verification;
• C-08 rollback only under explicit failure trigger.

---

3. Accepted Production Candidate Shape

new_tables:
  - cutter_governance.review_decision
  - cutter_governance.decision_backlog_history
  - cutter_governance.decision_backlog_dependency
  - cutter_governance.decision_backlog_sweep_log
expected_cutter_governance_table_count_after_execution: 12
row_counts_expected: 0_each
FK_count_expected: 7
forbidden_objects:
  cross_schema_FK: 0
  CHECK: 0
  trigger: 0
  DEFAULT: 0
  PG_enum: 0
  lookup_table: 0
  seed_rows: 0

---

4. Binding Safety Gates

The execution prompt must enforce all 11 gates, especially:

G_03_DDL_sha256: 89652d5f1f22dad18b6dfeaf88dc77b3452e78a0f28cc79befa389af3025c4b0
G_05_pre_count: cutter_governance_table_count_must_equal_8
G_07_A1: decision_backlog_entry_PK_must_equal_entry_id_uuid
G_08_P0_2_parents: manifest_envelope_and_manifest_unit_block_shapes_must_match
G_11_post_verification: all_checks_must_pass

---

5. Expected Final v0.2 State After Success

cutter_governance_table_count: 12
v0_2_schema_complete: true
new_final_batch_tables_live: 4
all_cutter_governance_tables_expected_empty: true
production_CUT_VERIFY_authorized: false

Even after this migration succeeds, production CUT/VERIFY remains unauthorized until a separate app/tooling phase.

---

6. Status

ready_for_explicit_final_v0_2_production_execution_prompt: true
production_execution_allowed_without_prompt: false