dot-iu-cutter v0.2 — P0-2 Production Execution GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-16
Reviewer: GPT
File reviewed: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/v0.2-execution/dot-iu-cutter-v0.2-p0-2-production-execution-report-2026-05-16.md
Scope: Production execution review. No further execution authorized by this review.

---

1. Verdict

p0_2_production_execution_status: PASS
execution_status: success
agent_revision_needed: false
rollback_executed: false
scope_expansion: false
non_scope_performed: false
p0_2_live: true
next_step: p0_6_plus_p0_5_remainder_batch_design

P0-2 production execution is accepted and ratified.

---

2. Confirmed Execution Results

backup_freshness_at_migration: 9_seconds
preflight: 10_of_10_PASS
migration_C_06: rc_0_COMMIT
verification_C_07: ALL_PASS
rollback_C_08: not_triggered
production_identity: 7611578671664259111

The first C-03 abort is accepted as harmless because it occurred before any mutation and production was verified intact before the successful rerun.

---

3. Confirmed Production State

cutter_governance_table_count: 8
new_P0_2_tables:
  manifest_envelope:
    columns: 12
    rows: 0
    PK: envelope_id
  manifest_unit_block:
    columns: 13
    rows: 0
    PK: [envelope_id, unit_local_id]
    FK_count: 1
    FK_shape: envelope_id_to_manifest_envelope
forbidden_objects_absent:
  cross_schema_FK: true
  CHECK: true
  trigger: true
  DEFAULT: true
  alias_ref: true
  edge_table: true

N1 erratum is confirmed in production: manifest_unit_block has 13 columns, not 14.

---

4. Scope Integrity

Confirmed not performed:

INSERT_manifest_rows: false
INSERT_unit_block_rows: false
review_decision_created: false
P0_5_remainder_created: false
alias_rows_inserted: false
identity_profile_cleanup: false
production_CUT: false
production_VERIFY: false
Qdrant_vector_mutation: false
deploy: false
preexisting_objects_changed: false

public.tac_logical_unit and sandbox_tac.logical_unit remain unchanged from Phase α state.

---

5. Current v0.2 State

live_components:
  v0_1_governance_tables: 5
  phase_alpha_canonical_address_alias: 1
  P0_2_manifest_tables: 2
cutter_governance_tables_total: 8
remaining_v0_2_items:
  - P0_6_review_decision
  - P0_5_remainder_history_dependency_sweep_log

---

6. Direction

Proceed with a combined design batch for P0-6 and P0-5 remainder. These are independent enough to design together and doing so reduces review overhead. Do not start DDL yet.

next_allowed_work_after_explicit_prompt:
  - P0_6_plus_P0_5_remainder_batch_design
not_allowed_without_new_prompt:
  - DDL_authoring
  - dry_run
  - production_migration
  - CUT_VERIFY