dot-iu-cutter v0.2 — P0-2 Manifest Dry-Run GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-16
Reviewer: GPT
Files reviewed: P0-2 dry-run execution report, verification results, artefact index
Scope: Dry-run review only. No production execution authorized.

---

1. Verdict

p0_2_dry_run_status: PASS_WITH_NOTES
agent_revision_needed: false
verification: 20_of_20_PASS
rollback_test: PASS
production_touched: false
production_execution_allowed_now: false
next_step: P0_2_production_command_review_package

The P0-2 manifest dry-run is accepted. The next gate is production command review, not production execution.

---

2. Confirmed Evidence

dry_run_env: pg-dry-run-v0.2-p0-2-2026-05-16
sysid_distinct_from_production: true
sql_sha256: 023a3be5...e93eab
DDL_execution: single_transaction_psql_rc_0
verification: 20_of_20_PASS
rollback: PASS_bit_identical_to_pre_P0_2_baseline
production_cutter_governance_count: 6
production_manifest_envelope: absent
production_untouched: true

---

3. Accepted Notes

N1_unit_block_column_count_erratum:
  accepted: true
  correct_count: 13
  incorrect_textual_count: 14
  DDL_change_required: false
  command_review_must_use: 13

N2_harness_regclass_schema_prefix_bug:
  accepted: true
  resolved_in_run_03: true
  DDL_affected: false

N3_restore_no_owner_no_acl:
  accepted: true
  follows_phase_alpha_precedent: true

N1 must be carried into command review. The production command package must state manifest_unit_block = 13 columns, not 14.

---

4. Accepted Production Candidate Shape

new_tables:
  - cutter_governance.manifest_envelope
  - cutter_governance.manifest_unit_block
manifest_envelope_columns: 12
manifest_unit_block_columns: 13
row_counts_expected: 0_each
FKs_expected:
  total: 1
  shape: manifest_unit_block.envelope_id_to_manifest_envelope.envelope_id
forbidden_objects:
  cross_schema_FK: 0
  CHECK: 0
  trigger: 0
  DEFAULT: 0
  alias_ref_column: absent
  edge_tables: absent

---

5. Gate Effect

ready_for_P0_2_command_review_package: true
ready_for_production_prompt: false

Agent may author the P0-2 production command review package. It must not execute production commands.