dot-iu-cutter v0.1 — P0 Gate Ratification Outcome GPT Review

Date: 2026-05-15
Reviewer: GPT
File reviewed: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/ratification/dot-iu-cutter-v0.1-dieu44-dieu24-p0-gate-ratification-outcome-2026-05-15.md
Scope: Review only. No implementation, no migration, no PG mutation.

---

1. Verdict

p0_gate_outcome_status: PASS
agent_revision_needed: false
p0_migration_design_gate_status: OPEN_PENDING_EXPLICIT_PROMPT_APPROVAL
implementation_planning_allowed: false
implementation_allowed: false
next_step: explicit_prompt_for_p0_migration_design_phase

The outcome record correctly reflects the intended gate status. It opens eligibility for P0 Migration Design only after an explicit prompt, and does not authorize implementation, DDL, SQL, migration, PG mutation, or implementation planning.

---

2. Confirmed

1. Đ44 Steps 1–3 are ratified_with_notes for P0 gate.
2. Đ44 Step 4 semantic_thread is deferred to P2.
3. Đ24 Step 1 is ratified_with_notes for P0 gate.
4. Đ24 Step 2 HIGH-risk G-5 vocabulary is deferred to G-5 operational handoff.
5. Đ24 Step 3 P2/P3 vocabulary is deferred.
6. p0_migration_design_gate_status is exactly OPEN_PENDING_EXPLICIT_PROMPT_APPROVAL.
7. Hard boundaries are preserved.

---

3. GPT Decision for P0 Migration Design Approach

Use a hybrid structure, not one giant monolithic document and not six isolated phases.

Create one master P0 Migration Design Package plus six per-item design sections/files in dependency order:

1. P0-5 decision_backlog_entry
2. P0-1 canonical_address
3. P0-2 manifest_envelope + manifest_unit_block
4. P0-6 review_decision
5. P0-3 cut_change_set + rollback_key
6. P0-4 verify_result

Rationale:

• P0-5 is foundational for tracking all open follow-ups.
• P0-1 gives canonical identity before manifest and unit-block design.
• P0-2 depends on canonical addressing and Decision 5 child-row shape.
• P0-6 can use the governance_event envelope.
• P0-3 and P0-4 are later because they involve rollback and DOT-pair verification semantics.

Đ32 review should be per item plus a final consolidated risk review after the package is complete.

---

4. Status

ready_to_prompt_agent_for_p0_migration_design: true
migration_design_scope: DESIGN_ONLY
no_execution_allowed: true