Incomex AI Portal
KB-18BE rev 2

P3D Pack 1 Phase 4 — Vocab/Species Seed Implementation Report (v7 dispatch, COMMITTED)

19 min read Revision 2
dieu44p3dpack1phase4vocab-prepimplementation-reportcommitteddraft-v72026-05-11

P3D Pack 1 Phase 4 — Vocab/Species Seed Implementation Report (v7 dispatch, COMMITTED)

  • Prompt executed: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/prompts/p3d-pack1-phase4-governance-vocab-species-prep-implementation-prompt-DRAFT.md (DRAFT v7, revision 9, approved 2026-05-11)
  • Approval review: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reviews/gpt-final-review-p3d-pack1-phase4-vocab-prep-draft-v7-approved-2026-05-11.md
  • RUN_MARKER: p3d-phase4-vocab-20260511-082717
  • VPS log: /tmp/p3d-phase4-vocab-20260511-082717.log on 38.242.240.89 (host vmi3080463)
  • Outcome: PASS — G1..G7 all PASS inside one transaction; COMMIT reached; 14 vocab rows persisted into public.dot_config.
  • Dispatch host: VPS 38.242.240.89, container postgres, db directus, role directus.
  • Date: 2026-05-11 (UTC: 2026-05-11T06:27:17Z)

1. RUN_MARKER

p3d-phase4-vocab-20260511-082717

2. Section A — Read-only preflight (A1..A5, verbatim)

A1 — dot_config schema

 column_name |        data_type         | is_nullable | column_default
-------------+--------------------------+-------------+----------------
 key         | text                     | NO          |
 value       | text                     | NO          |
 description | text                     | YES         |
 updated_at  | timestamp with time zone | NO          | now()
(4 rows)

Matches G1 required set {key, value, description, updated_at} exactly.

A2 — dot_config constraints / indexes

     conname     | contype |        def
-----------------+---------+-------------------
 dot_config_pkey | p       | PRIMARY KEY (key)
(1 row)

    indexname    |                                  indexdef
-----------------+----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 dot_config_pkey | CREATE UNIQUE INDEX dot_config_pkey ON public.dot_config USING btree (key)
(1 row)

Single-column PK on key satisfies G2.

A3 — source tables present

     relname
------------------
 dot_config
 tac_logical_unit
 tac_publication
(3 rows)

A4 — current vocab.* state (pre-run)

                key                 |       value
------------------------------------+--------------------
 vocab.publication_type.design_doc  | design_doc
 vocab.section_type.section         | section
 vocab.unit_kind.design_doc_section | design_doc_section
(3 rows)

A5 — read-only delta preview (14 rows)

     category     |        code        |              target_key
------------------+--------------------+---------------------------------------
 publication_type | law                | vocab.publication_type.law
 section_type     | appendix           | vocab.section_type.appendix
 section_type     | article            | vocab.section_type.article
 section_type     | changelog          | vocab.section_type.changelog
 section_type     | checklist          | vocab.section_type.checklist
 section_type     | definition         | vocab.section_type.definition
 section_type     | governance_process | vocab.section_type.governance_process
 section_type     | heading            | vocab.section_type.heading
 section_type     | instruction_block  | vocab.section_type.instruction_block
 section_type     | paragraph          | vocab.section_type.paragraph
 section_type     | principle          | vocab.section_type.principle
 section_type     | process            | vocab.section_type.process
 section_type     | technical_spec     | vocab.section_type.technical_spec
 unit_kind        | law_unit           | vocab.unit_kind.law_unit
(14 rows)

All 14 codes are legitimate identifiers (12 section_type + 1 publication_type + 1 unit_kind=law_unit). No garbage values; Section B was allowed to proceed.

3. Section B — Executable transaction (gate notices, verbatim)

BEGIN
SET
SET
SET
NOTICE:  G1_PASS dot_config has columns (key,value,description,updated_at)
DO
NOTICE:  G2_PASS dot_config(key) is uniquely indexed
DO
NOTICE:  G3_PASS source tables present; fn_iu_create_plan oid=196377 has exact 9-arg identity and returns jsonb
DO
NOTICE:  G4_PASS source columns present
DO
DO
NOTICE:  G6_PASS run_marker=p3d-phase4-vocab-20260511-082717
SELECT 12         -- _delta_section_type
SELECT 1          -- _delta_pub_type
SELECT 1          -- _delta_unit_kind
NOTICE:  G5_PASS no value conflict between delta and existing dot_config rows
== DRY-RUN PREVIEW ==
...14 rows printed (identical to A5)...
== DELTA COUNTS ==
delta_section_type=12 | delta_publication_type=1 | delta_unit_kind=1
CREATE TABLE
INSERT 0 12       -- section_type into _inserted_keys
INSERT 0 1        -- publication_type into _inserted_keys
INSERT 0 1        -- unit_kind into _inserted_keys
== INSERTED KEYS ==
...14 rows printed (see §5)...
== TOTAL INSERTED ==
total_inserted=14
NOTICE:  G7_PASS status=plan_ok resolved_unit_kind=law_unit plan={"mode": "plan", "issues": [], "status": "plan_ok", "existing": null, "preflight": "pass", "body_length": 10, "would_create": true, "resolved_owner_ref": "p3d-phase4-vocab-20260511-082717", "resolved_unit_kind": "law_unit", "content_hash_preview": "c33e499600945406", "fk_initially_deferred": true, "resolved_section_type": "appendix"}
COMMIT

Outcome: all seven executable gates raised PASS notices. G3 (exact contract) verified fn_iu_create_plan oid=196377 with the 9-arg identity and jsonb return type. COMMIT executed; 14 rows persisted in public.dot_config.

Gates that emitted PASS notices: G1, G2, G3, G4, G5, G6, G7. Gates that aborted execution: none.

4. Section B — dry-run preview (verbatim)

     category     |        code        |              target_key
------------------+--------------------+---------------------------------------
 publication_type | law                | vocab.publication_type.law
 section_type     | appendix           | vocab.section_type.appendix
 section_type     | article            | vocab.section_type.article
 section_type     | changelog          | vocab.section_type.changelog
 section_type     | checklist          | vocab.section_type.checklist
 section_type     | definition         | vocab.section_type.definition
 section_type     | governance_process | vocab.section_type.governance_process
 section_type     | heading            | vocab.section_type.heading
 section_type     | instruction_block  | vocab.section_type.instruction_block
 section_type     | paragraph          | vocab.section_type.paragraph
 section_type     | principle          | vocab.section_type.principle
 section_type     | process            | vocab.section_type.process
 section_type     | technical_spec     | vocab.section_type.technical_spec
 unit_kind        | law_unit           | vocab.unit_kind.law_unit
(14 rows)

 delta_section_type | delta_publication_type | delta_unit_kind
                 12 |                      1 |               1

5. Section B — _inserted_keys snapshot (verbatim, RETURNING-captured pre-COMMIT)

     category     |                  key                  |       value
------------------+---------------------------------------+--------------------
 publication_type | vocab.publication_type.law            | law
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.appendix           | appendix
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.article            | article
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.changelog          | changelog
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.checklist          | checklist
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.definition         | definition
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.governance_process | governance_process
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.heading            | heading
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.instruction_block  | instruction_block
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.paragraph          | paragraph
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.principle          | principle
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.process            | process
 section_type     | vocab.section_type.technical_spec     | technical_spec
 unit_kind        | vocab.unit_kind.law_unit              | law_unit
(14 rows)

 total_inserted
 ---------------
             14

Authoritative inserted-keys list (use verbatim if a future rollback is required):

vocab.publication_type.law
vocab.section_type.appendix
vocab.section_type.article
vocab.section_type.changelog
vocab.section_type.checklist
vocab.section_type.definition
vocab.section_type.governance_process
vocab.section_type.heading
vocab.section_type.instruction_block
vocab.section_type.paragraph
vocab.section_type.principle
vocab.section_type.process
vocab.section_type.technical_spec
vocab.unit_kind.law_unit

These rows are persisted (COMMIT executed). No rollback is required or being performed.

6. Section B — G7 planner-probe jsonb result (verbatim)

{
  "mode": "plan",
  "issues": [],
  "status": "plan_ok",
  "existing": null,
  "preflight": "pass",
  "body_length": 10,
  "would_create": true,
  "resolved_owner_ref": "p3d-phase4-vocab-20260511-082717",
  "resolved_unit_kind": "law_unit",
  "content_hash_preview": "c33e499600945406",
  "fk_initially_deferred": true,
  "resolved_section_type": "appendix"
}

G7 contract assertions inside the transaction:

  • jsonb_typeof(v_plan) = 'object' — ✅
  • v_plan ? 'status' — ✅
  • v_plan ? 'resolved_unit_kind' — ✅
  • status NOT ILIKE '%unresolved_vocab%' — ✅ (status=plan_ok)
  • resolved_unit_kind = 'law_unit' — ✅

7. Section C — Post-commit verification (verbatim)

C1 — persisted rows from this run (description = RUN_MARKER)

                  key                  |       value        |          updated_at
---------------------------------------+--------------------+-------------------------------
 vocab.publication_type.law            | law                | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.appendix           | appendix           | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.article            | article            | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.changelog          | changelog          | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.checklist          | checklist          | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.definition         | definition         | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.governance_process | governance_process | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.heading            | heading            | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.instruction_block  | instruction_block  | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.paragraph          | paragraph          | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.principle          | principle          | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.process            | process            | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.section_type.technical_spec     | technical_spec     | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
 vocab.unit_kind.law_unit              | law_unit           | 2026-05-11 06:27:18.361772+00
(14 rows)

C2 — full vocab.* state after run (17 rows)

                  key                  |       value
---------------------------------------+--------------------
 vocab.publication_type.design_doc     | design_doc
 vocab.publication_type.law            | law
 vocab.section_type.appendix           | appendix
 vocab.section_type.article            | article
 vocab.section_type.changelog          | changelog
 vocab.section_type.checklist          | checklist
 vocab.section_type.definition         | definition
 vocab.section_type.governance_process | governance_process
 vocab.section_type.heading            | heading
 vocab.section_type.instruction_block  | instruction_block
 vocab.section_type.paragraph          | paragraph
 vocab.section_type.principle          | principle
 vocab.section_type.process            | process
 vocab.section_type.section            | section
 vocab.section_type.technical_spec     | technical_spec
 vocab.unit_kind.design_doc_section    | design_doc_section
 vocab.unit_kind.law_unit              | law_unit
(17 rows)

C3 — standalone planner probe (post-commit, 9-arg jsonb)

{
  "mode": "plan",
  "issues": [],
  "status": "plan_ok",
  "existing": null,
  "preflight": "pass",
  "body_length": 10,
  "would_create": true,
  "resolved_owner_ref": "p3d-phase4-vocab-20260511-082717",
  "resolved_unit_kind": "law_unit",
  "content_hash_preview": "c33e499600945406",
  "fk_initially_deferred": true,
  "resolved_section_type": "appendix"
}

Post-commit planner contract is intact: status=plan_ok, resolved_unit_kind=law_unit. Vocab gate is unblocked for downstream EVOLVE work.

8. Section D — Species READ-ONLY candidate report

D1 — active species catalog

FAILED with schema mismatch (read-only diagnostic, not a gate, not transactional):

ERROR:  column "species_name" does not exist
LINE 1: SELECT species_code, species_name, composition_level, lifecy...
                             ^
HINT:  Perhaps you meant to reference the column "entity_species.species_code".

The approved prompt §6 D1 references entity_species.species_name; the live schema does not have that column. Per the executing-agent directive (Do not retry a failed gate by editing or improvising; report failure and stop), D1 was not edited, and because psql aborted on the read-only entity_species query, D2 and D3 were not executed in this run.

This is non-blocking for the vocab prep outcome: the executable transaction (Section B) had already COMMITTED before Section D ran; no vocab data is at risk.

D2 / D3 — not executed

Skipped because D1 raised under ON_ERROR_STOP=1 in the read-only diagnostic call. Section D will need a small read-only correction (introspect entity_species columns first, then re-issue D1 with live column names) before re-dispatch. This correction is outside the scope of this dispatch per the no-improvise rule.

Status flags from prompt §6 (still hold)

species_mapping_executable=false
species_mapping_requires_separate_GPT_User_approved_prompt=true
fuzzy_match_in_executable_path=false

9. Section E — Hash provenance (document-only)

No executable code. Contract recorded per prompt §7:

hash_provenance_document_only=true
hash_provenance_contract=preserves_original_tac_unit_version_content_hash

IU layer preserves the original tac_unit_version.content_hash as a provenance reference; no re-hashing in the IU layer. No DDL / backfill / migration occurred. See prompt §7 for the field-by-field schema (source_hashes.tac_v1.{algorithm, input_recipe, value, source_table, source_id}).

10. Status flag block (verbatim, prompt §9)

phase4_draft_v7_executed=true
vocab_executable_committed=true
single_session_transaction=true
executable_stop_gates=true
temp_table_cross_session_bug_present=false
hardcoded_seed_list_present=false
species_mapping_executable=false
hash_provenance_document_only=true
hash_provenance_contract=preserves_original_tac_unit_version_content_hash
requires_GPT_User_review_before_dispatch=true

Run-level wire flags:

phase4_vocab_prep_status=PASS
vocab_executable_committed=true
inserted_keys=14 (see §5 for the verbatim 14-key list)
single_session_transaction=true
executable_stop_gates=true
hardcoded_seed_list_present=false
species_mapping_executable=false
hash_provenance_document_only=true
hash_provenance_contract=preserves_original_tac_unit_version_content_hash
migration_performed=false
rollback_performed=false

11. Exact-key list for any future rollback

14 keys persisted; rollback is not being performed by this dispatch. If a future correction necessitates rollback, the authoritative key = ANY(ARRAY[...]) input is:

DELETE FROM public.dot_config
WHERE key = ANY(ARRAY[
  'vocab.publication_type.law',
  'vocab.section_type.appendix',
  'vocab.section_type.article',
  'vocab.section_type.changelog',
  'vocab.section_type.checklist',
  'vocab.section_type.definition',
  'vocab.section_type.governance_process',
  'vocab.section_type.heading',
  'vocab.section_type.instruction_block',
  'vocab.section_type.paragraph',
  'vocab.section_type.principle',
  'vocab.section_type.process',
  'vocab.section_type.technical_spec',
  'vocab.unit_kind.law_unit'
]::text[]);

Cross-check predicate (verification only, not a deletion predicate):

SELECT count(*) FROM public.dot_config WHERE description = 'p3d-phase4-vocab-20260511-082717';
-- Expect 0 after the exact-key DELETE above.

12. Hard-boundary attestation (this run)

  • No species INSERT performed. ✅
  • No species_collection_map write. ✅
  • No migration / DDL / function / trigger patch. ✅
  • No Directus / Nuxt / Qdrant touch. ✅
  • No collection promotion / edge materialization / birth-gate change. ✅
  • No hardcoded seed list — every value derived live from tac_logical_unit.section_type, tac_publication.publication_type, or the Pack 1 EVOLVE contract value law_unit. ✅
  • No nested/secondary agent dispatch. ✅
  • No retry / edit of a failed gate. ✅ (D1 read-only diagnostic failed; not retried, not improvised.)
  • Single psql session / single BEGIN..COMMIT for the executable section. ✅
  • Hash provenance: document-only. ✅

13. Non-blocking follow-up (for next prompt design)

The species read-only candidate report block (prompt §6, Section D) needs a minor correction before next dispatch:

  • D1 currently references entity_species.species_name; the live public.entity_species table does not have that column.
  • Recommended preflight in the next prompt: SELECT column_name FROM information_schema.columns WHERE table_schema='public' AND table_name='entity_species' ORDER BY ordinal_position; before any read of species name-like attributes.
  • D2 and D3 also did not execute (psql aborted at D1 under ON_ERROR_STOP=1); they will need to be re-run after D1 is corrected.

This does not affect the executable vocab outcome (Section B committed before Section D started).

Dispatch executed by Opus 4.7 on 2026-05-11. Single-session transaction. Executable STOP gates. Live deltas only. Exact fn_iu_create_plan 9-arg jsonb contract verified at G3 and exercised at G7 / C3.

Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/p3d-pack1-phase4-vocab-species-seed-implementation-report.md