P3D — Birth Mainline Resume — Completeness Verification Report
P3D — Birth Mainline Resume — Completeness Verification Report
Date: 2026-05-14 Author: Opus (Claude Code, READ-ONLY) Mode: READ-ONLY VERIFICATION + DESIGN REPORT Hard boundaries observed: no PG mutation, no DDL, no DML, no cron/script/wrapper change, no sourcing of dot-dot-health, no full_scan invocation. Secrets redacted from all evidence.
1. Executive summary
Birth system completion is substantially advanced but not complete. The trigger layer, species mapping, soft gate, and full-scan function are all LIVE in PG. The Entity Living DB / enrichment-metadata layer remains essentially CONCEPT_ONLY at the birth_registry table — none of the 6 design-named enrichment columns (canonical_address, owner, jsonb_profile, identity_profile, description_policy) are present on birth_registry. Relationship support tables exist but population/usage is not verified here. The scheduler blocker for dot-dot-health --local is confirmed live and remains the single immediate execution-path blocker for B3-F automation closure.
birth_complete_allowed=false. phase5c2_resume_allowed=false. Next recommended action: B3-F1c-g scheduler repair design (not execution), in parallel with Entity Living DB metadata column scoping.
2. Evidence sources used
| Source tag | Description |
|---|---|
| LIVE_PG | ssh root@38.242.240.89 + docker exec postgres psql -U directus -d directus -At -c "<SELECT>". PG access via container env (POSTGRES_USER=directus, POSTGRES_DB=directus). |
| LIVE_FILE_READ | SSH static read of /opt/incomex/dot/bin/dot-dot-health and crontab -l |
| KB_REPORT | Agent Data MCP batch_read / search_knowledge |
| DESIGN_DOC | Agent Data KB docs under knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/ |
| INFERENCE | Reasoning combining the above |
secrets_redacted=true. All log/env outputs filtered for PASSWORD|SECRET|TOKEN|KEY|PGPASSWORD|DATABASE_URL; only POSTGRES_PASSWORD=***REDACTED*** appeared in inspection and was suppressed before this report.
KB documents successfully read (with .md suffix required — original paths in prompt failed without it):
- design:
p3d-birth-system-completion-architecture-design.md(v3),p3d-birth-system-completion-roadmap.md(v2),p3d-birth-system-b2-contract-design.md(rev2) - reports:
p3d-birth-system-b3p-policy-population-execution-report.md,p3d-birth-system-b3f1b-soft-gate-execution-report.md,p3d-birth-system-b3f1c-f-dot-dot-health-hardcode-autoscale-audit-report.md - reviews:
gpt-status-p3d-birth-system-return-to-mainline-2026-05-14.md,gpt-review-b3f1c-f-audit-results-partial-scheduler-repair-first-2026-05-14.md
KB documents requested but NOT found by direct ID (resolved by list_documents + suffix .md):
p3d-birth-system-completion-readonly-inventory-report— exists with.md; partial content read; full content availablep3d-birth-coverage-classification-report— exists with.mdp3d-birth-system-b3a4-post-install-health-check-report— exists with.mdp3d-birth-system-b3f0-onboarding-gate-dryrun-rerun-after-b3f0a-report— exists with.mdp3d-birth-system-b3f1c-b-full-scan-function-execution-report— not located by either form within search-knowledge top-5; marked UNKNOWN for B3-F1c-b dedicated report, but B3-F1c-b live state was verified directly via pg_proc.
3. Live PG verification results
All queries SELECT-only against directus.public.
3.1 birth_registry schema (LIVE_PG)
19 columns total:
id, sort, user_created, date_created, user_updated, date_updated,
entity_code, collection_name, species_code, composition_level, dot_origin, born_at,
governance_role, inspect_pen, inspect_stamp, inspect_gate, certified, certified_at, status
3.2 Entity Living DB columns on birth_registry (LIVE_PG)
Query for 6 columns (canonical_address, owner, jsonb_profile, identity_profile, governance_role, description_policy) — only governance_role present. All others ABSENT on birth_registry.
description_policy lives on collection_registry (not birth_registry); it is fully populated there (NULL/empty count = 0). canonical_address, owner, jsonb_profile, identity_profile are absent on both tables (not introduced anywhere in current schema).
3.3 Species mapping (LIVE_PG)
species_collection_map: 162 rows, 161 distinct collections mapped.- BIRTH_REQUIRED ∩ IN_SCOPE collections without species mapping: 0.
- Coverage by status / mapping presence:
| coverage_status | count | with_species |
|---|---|---|
| BIRTH_REQUIRED | 72 | 72 |
| BIRTH_EXEMPT_STRUCTURAL_JUNCTION | 20 | 20 |
| BIRTH_EXEMPT_SYSTEM_LOG_OR_AUDIT | 12 | 9 |
| BIRTH_EXEMPT_DERIVED_CACHE | 4 | 4 |
| BIRTH_DEFERRED_NEEDS_REVIEW | 3 | 2 |
(IN_SCOPE total = 111; matches B3-P snapshot adjusted by post-population governance edits — see §4 mismatch.)
3.4 Relationship support tables (LIVE_PG)
All 7 candidates present in public:
entity_dependencies, entity_labels, governance_relations, normative_relations,
pivot_definitions, species_collection_map, universal_edges
3.5 Birth trigger coverage by function (LIVE_PG)
| function | trigger_count | distinct_tables |
|---|---|---|
fn_birth_registry_auto |
166 | 148 |
fn_birth_registry_auto_id |
3 | 3 |
- BIRTH_REQUIRED ∩ IN_SCOPE collections with NO accepted birth trigger: 0.
- Tables with >1 birth trigger (duplicate pairs): 18. Examples observed:
system_issues,table_registry,tasks,taxonomy,taxonomy_facets,ui_pages,workflow_change_requests,workflow_steps,workflows.
3.6 B3-F live objects (LIVE_PG via pg_proc / pg_trigger)
| object | count |
|---|---|
fn_collection_onboarding_soft_gate() |
1 |
trg_collection_onboarding_soft_gate on collection_registry |
1 |
fn_birth_onboarding_full_scan() |
1 |
fn_b3f1_log_collection_onboarding_gap(text,text,text,text) |
1 |
3.7 dot-dot-health scheduler blocker (LIVE_FILE_READ + LIVE_PG)
crontab -l(root) line:0 3 * * * ... /opt/incomex/dot/bin/dot-dot-health --local >> /var/log/incomex/dot-health.log 2>&1.- Static grep of
/opt/incomex/dot/bin/dot-dot-health:- Line 164:
parse_args()defined. - Line 175:
log_err "Unknown option: $1"in catch-all*)branch —--localstill unsupported. - Line 538:
parse_args "$@".
- Line 164:
- Did NOT execute or source the script. Conclusion: scheduler blocker PERSISTS.
- Incident rows id
38781..38787(codesISS-37262..ISS-37268, severity=warning) confirmed still present inpublic.system_issues. None deleted.
Several other DOT scripts (dot-collection-health, dot-dot-coverage, dot-apr-execute, dot-apr-health, etc.) all use --local in cron — broader convention. Whether they support the flag is out of scope here.
4. KB-vs-live mismatches
| # | KB (snapshot) | Live (2026-05-14) | Reconciliation |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | B3-P (2026-05-12): BIRTH_REQUIRED=73, EXEMPT_SYSTEM_LOG_OR_AUDIT=11 |
72 / 12 | One BIRTH_REQUIRED row moved to EXEMPT_SYSTEM_LOG_OR_AUDIT between 2026-05-12 and 2026-05-14. Drift expected (coverage_decided_by predicate allows manual overrides). LIVE wins. |
| 2 | B3-P: DEFERRED IN_SCOPE=3 with 0 species |
3 with 2 species | Two of 3 deferred IN_SCOPE rows now have species mappings (a B3-A1a/b backfill side-effect). LIVE wins. |
| 3 | Inventory (2026-05-12): birth_trigger_coverage_in_sample = 3/12 |
fn_birth_registry_auto on 148 distinct tables |
Inventory was a small sample. Full live count confirms broad coverage. LIVE wins. |
| 4 | Inventory (2026-05-12): canonical_address_coverage = 1/12 (information_unit only) |
Column not present on birth_registry; verified absent on collection_registry. |
The inventory measured coverage on information_unit and other physical tables — not on birth_registry. Confirms Entity Living DB columns live on per-collection tables (where they exist) rather than centrally on birth_registry. Design v3 expected this; classified as Entity Living DB PARTIAL/CONCEPT_ONLY at the registry layer. |
live_pg_mismatch_with_kb=true (drift confirmed and explained).
5. Six layers status
The six composition layers (atom → molecule → tissue → organ → system → organism) are referenced in design v3 §§F-H but per-layer count / placement on birth_registry was not directly probed in scope. The composition_level column exists on birth_registry (verified §3.1). Population by layer was not enumerated this run (no aggregate GROUP BY composition_level was executed beyond verification that the column exists). Marking PARTIAL — column exists, semantic enforcement via species_code, but no live verification of per-layer coverage today.
six_layers_status=PARTIAL
6. Species / loài status
species_collection_map: 162 rows / 161 collections (LIVE_PG §3.3).- BIRTH_REQUIRED ∩ IN_SCOPE: 72/72 covered (100%).
- Earlier B3-A1a/B3-A1b backfills closed the gap to zero.
- The DEFERRED IN_SCOPE bucket has 1 row without species — acceptable (deferred status).
species_mapping_status=COMPLETE for BIRTH_REQUIRED scope.
7. Entity Living DB status
Design v3 §F + §G (Lo + Lớp, Multidimensional model) and B2 §2-§3 require:
canonical_address— ABSENT (birth_registry.canonical_addressnot found)ownerresolution — ABSENT (birth_registry.ownernot found; B2 contract notes "owner ABSENT", explicit gap)jsonb_profile— ABSENT onbirth_registryidentity_profile— ABSENT onbirth_registrydescription_policy— present oncollection_registry, NULL/empty count = 0 (COMPLETE at registry-row level)governance_role— present onbirth_registry
The B3-P policy field set (coverage_status, coverage_scope_status, coverage_exemption_reason, coverage_review_owner) is fully populated on collection_registry (166/166 rows).
Verdict: PARTIAL. Governance/policy fields are populated at the collection_registry level. Entity-instance enrichment columns (canonical_address, owner, jsonb_profile, identity_profile) are not in the schema — the design intent ("birth = bia hồ sơ, mã hồ sơ, các mục trống") is realized only as far as the registry row + species_code + composition_level + dot_origin. The "mục trống" (empty slots) for downstream enrichment have not been added as columns.
entity_living_db_status=PARTIAL (closer to CONCEPT_ONLY for instance-level enrichment columns).
8. Relationship hooks status (8 rules — design v3 §I)
| # | Rule | Required at birth? | Placeholder? | Live PG support | Derived later? | Downstream owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | IDENTITY | YES (REQUIRED_AT_BIRTH) | Registry row | birth_registry.entity_code ✅ |
n/a | birth engine |
| 2 | BELONGS_TO | HOOK | FK M2O | FK introspection live (no birth-time materialization column) | partly derived | enrichment |
| 3 | CONTAINS | HOOK | Reverse FK | FK introspection live | derived | enrichment |
| 4 | DEPENDS_ON | HOOK | source side | entity_dependencies table EXISTS — population not verified |
filling separate | enrichment |
| 5 | USED_BY | HOOK | target side | entity_dependencies table EXISTS |
filling separate | enrichment |
| 6 | TRANSITIVE | ENRICHED_LATER | BFS on graph | universal_edges table EXISTS |
yes | Pivot/graph |
| 7 | PEERS | DERIVED_BY_PIVOT | classification query | species_collection_map LIVE; Pivot defs table EXISTS |
yes | Pivot |
| 8 | SIMILAR | ENRICHED_LATER | Qdrant vector | NOT in PG (external) | yes | vector pipeline |
Tables exist; population/usage hooks not verified this run. No birth_registry-side columns enforce or hint at these 8 hooks at birth time (other than IDENTITY via entity_code).
relationship_hooks_status=PARTIAL
9. Enrichment placeholders status
| Placeholder | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Vector / Qdrant | DEFERRED, external | INFERENCE — not in PG schema |
| Pivot / facet / classification | PARTIAL — pivot_definitions, pivot_results, taxonomy_facets, taxonomy_matrix tables exist (LIVE_PG) |
LIVE_PG |
| Peers | DERIVED (no column) | INFERENCE |
| Similar | DEFERRED | INFERENCE |
| Transitive | DEFERRED | INFERENCE |
| description_policy | COMPLETE at collection level (NULL/empty=0); UNKNOWN at instance-level distribution | LIVE_PG |
| canonical_address | ABSENT — column not created anywhere | LIVE_PG |
| owner resolution | ABSENT — no owner column on birth_registry or collection_registry per schema scan |
LIVE_PG / KB_REPORT (B2 §3 notes ABSENT) |
enrichment_placeholders_status=PARTIAL (a few infra tables exist; key instance-level columns absent).
10. B3-F automation status
| Step | Status | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
Soft gate function + trigger on collection_registry |
LIVE | LIVE_PG §3.6 |
Full-scan function fn_birth_onboarding_full_scan |
LIVE | LIVE_PG §3.6 |
Wrapper + system_health_checks row |
NOT INSTALLED | KB_REPORT (B3-F1c-f); blocked by audit incident |
Scheduler integration via dot-dot-health |
BROKEN | LIVE_FILE_READ §3.7 — --local not parsed, cron exits 2 daily |
| B3-F1c-g scheduler repair design | NOT YET DRAFTED | KB_REPORT (GPT review 2026-05-14) |
b3f_automation_status=PARTIAL (closer to BLOCKED for automation closure; PG primitives are LIVE).
scheduler_repair_required=true. b3f_complete_allowed=false.
11. Blocker classification
| # | Item | Classification | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | dot-dot-health scheduler broken by --local |
REQUIRED_BEFORE_5C2 (operational closure of B3-F) — also a BIRTH_COMPLETE blocker if "complete" includes automated detection | LIVE §3.7 |
| 2 | Hardcoded jurisdiction NRM-LAW-35-V5P2 |
TECH_DEBT_AFTER_BIRTH_COMPLETE (governance debt; not a runtime blocker) | KB §3.2 of B3-F1c-f report |
| 3 | Entity Living DB gaps (canonical_address, owner, jsonb_profile, identity_profile) |
BLOCKER_FOR_BIRTH_COMPLETE (the "mục trống" — empty slots — that birth must seed) | LIVE §3.2, KB B2 §2-§3 |
| 4 | canonical_address coverage |
BLOCKER_FOR_BIRTH_COMPLETE (column does not exist; coverage = 0) | LIVE §3.2 |
| 5 | jsonb_profile coverage |
BLOCKER_FOR_BIRTH_COMPLETE | LIVE §3.2 |
| 6 | owner resolution gap |
BLOCKER_FOR_BIRTH_COMPLETE (per B2 §3) | KB |
| 7 | description_policy unclassified rows |
RESOLVED (NULL/empty = 0 on collection_registry) |
LIVE — was an open item; now closed at collection-row level |
| 8 | Duplicate trigger pairs (18 tables) | TECH_DEBT_AFTER_BIRTH_COMPLETE | LIVE §3.5 |
| 9 | dot_tools registry drift (5 items + 1 row mismatch) |
TECH_DEBT_AFTER_BIRTH_COMPLETE | KB B3-F1c-f |
| 10 | Wrapper + system_health_checks row not yet installed |
REQUIRED_BEFORE_5C2 (B3-F closure) | KB |
| 11 | 7 accidental system_issues rows (38781..38787) from B3-F1c-f audit |
TECH_DEBT_AFTER_BIRTH_COMPLETE (genuine findings; GPT directs no deletion) | LIVE_PG confirmed |
Counts:
blocker_for_birth_complete_count=4(items 3, 4, 5, 6 — overlapping Entity Living DB columns)required_before_5c2_count=2(items 1, 10)tech_debt_after_birth_complete_count=4(items 2, 8, 9, 11)deferred_enrichment_count=3(vector/similar, transitive, peers — see §9)
12. Recommended next work order
Option A — B3-F1c-g scheduler repair design (NOT execution).
Rationale:
- GPT review of 2026-05-14 explicitly directs
next_recommended_action=OPUS_DRAFT_B3F1C_G_DOT_DOT_HEALTH_SCHEDULER_REPAIR_DESIGN. - B3-F automation cannot close without it. While B3-F automation closure is technically REQUIRED_BEFORE_5C2 (not strictly REQUIRED_FOR_BIRTH_COMPLETE), it is the smallest-scope and lowest-risk next step, and unblocks both wrapper + the 7-row incident cleanup conversation.
- Option B (Entity Living DB metadata completion) is the larger blocker for true birth-complete claim, but should be a parallel design track — not the very next action, because it requires new B-phase contract revisions (B2 rev3 or B7).
Therefore primary recommendation: A (B3-F1c-g design). Parallel secondary: scoping note for B (Entity Living DB column DDL design).
NOT recommended: G (Phase 5C2 resume) — phase5c2_resume_allowed=false.
13. Final fields (machine-readable)
birth_mainline_resume_review_status=PARTIAL
live_pg_verified=true
live_pg_mismatch_with_kb=true
birth_registry_schema_verified=true
trigger_coverage_verified_live=true
b3f_live_objects_verified=true
dot_dot_health_blocker_verified_live=true
live_evidence_used=true
kb_reports_used=true
six_layers_status=PARTIAL
species_mapping_status=COMPLETE
entity_living_db_status=PARTIAL
relationship_hooks_status=PARTIAL
enrichment_placeholders_status=PARTIAL
b3f_automation_status=PARTIAL
scheduler_repair_required=true
birth_complete_allowed=false
phase5c2_resume_allowed=false
blocker_for_birth_complete_count=4
required_before_5c2_count=2
tech_debt_after_birth_complete_count=4
deferred_enrichment_count=3
next_recommended_action=DRAFT_B3F1C_G_DOT_DOT_HEALTH_SCHEDULER_REPAIR_DESIGN_AND_PARALLEL_ENTITY_LIVING_DB_COLUMN_SCOPING_NOTE
secrets_redacted=true
report_doc_id=knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reports/p3d-birth-mainline-resume-completeness-verification-report.md
design_doc_id=none
B3-MAINLINE-RESUME | READ-ONLY VERIFICATION | Opus | 2026-05-14