CP3 — Smoke Test Report

#	Test	Result	Evidence
T1	missing title	PASS	ERROR: Birth gate L1: P-id1 title required
T2	empty title	PASS	ERROR: Birth gate L1: P-id1 title required
T3	missing canonical	PASS	ERROR: Birth gate L1: U2 canonical_address required
T4	missing pub WARNING	PASS	2× WARNING ... PILOT-ONLY: P-pub1/P-pub2 missing + INSERT 0 1 + ROLLBACK
T5	full transaction	PASS	INSERT iu + INSERT uv + UPDATE + COMMIT, no errors
T6	edit version (seq=2)	PASS	INSERT 0 1
T7	soft-delete + undo	PASS	UPDATE 1 (set deleted_at), UPDATE 1 (clear)
T8	duplicate canonical	PASS	ERROR: duplicate key value violates unique constraint "information_unit_canonical_address_key" DETAIL: Key (canonical_address)=(test.t5) already exists
T9	commit no anchors	PASS	ERROR: Birth gate L2: U5 content_anchor_ref required at COMMIT
T10	wrong unit's version	PASS	ERROR: Birth gate L2: version_anchor_ref must point to version of this unit
T11	anchor mismatch	PASS	ERROR: Birth gate L2: content_anchor_ref must match version_anchor_ref
T12	fake unit_kind	PASS	ERROR: Birth gate L1: unit_kind "FAKE_KIND" not in vocab
T13	fake section_type	PASS	ERROR: Birth gate L1: section_type "FAKE_SECTION" not in vocab
T14	positive deferred	PASS	full happy path COMMIT, verify: `test.t14

Test data còn trên DB (CHƯA cleanup theo chỉ thị)

 canonical_address | soft_deleted
-------------------+--------------
 test.t14          | f
 test.t5           | f
(2 rows)

Chi tiết:

• test.t5: 1 row information_unit + 2 rows unit_version (seq=1 hash_t5, seq=2 hash_t5_v2)
• test.t14: 1 row information_unit + 1 row unit_version (seq=1 sha256_placeholder)

Các canonical khác (t1, t2, t3, t9, t10, t11, t12, t13) đã được rollback hoặc không tạo do birth gate block — không residue.

Quan sát phụ

• Birth gate L1 luôn fire trước UNIQUE constraint check, nên T8 vẫn thấy 2 WARNING PILOT trước ERROR duplicate (do DUPLICATE detect ở constraint stage sau khi trigger BEFORE INSERT pass).
• Birth gate L2 fire AT COMMIT đúng spec — T9/T10/T11 đều block tại COMMIT, transaction bị abort.

Overall: PASS — toàn bộ 14 smoke tests

DỪNG. Chờ Opus phê duyệt cleanup + final report.