ĐIỀU 43 DRAFT — SUPERSEDED

⛔ SUPERSEDED 2026-04-16. Đ43 v1.1 FINAL đã BAN HÀNH tại file chính thức. File hiện hành: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu43-system-context-law.md rev 1 (v1.1 FINAL) File này (draft): giữ để trace Council R1 + R2 patches, không dùng làm luật.

---

TRACE COUNCIL

Round	Agent	Score	Verdict
R1	Gemini	8.2/10	APPROVE WITH CHANGES — 1 CRITICAL + 2 HIGH
R1	GPT	7.8/10	APPROVE WITH CHANGES — 2 CRITICAL + 4 HIGH
R2	Gemini	9.5/10	APPROVE FINAL — không còn blocker
R2	GPT	8.9/10	APPROVE WITH MINOR — 4 patches inline (A/B/C/D)

14 PATCHES R1 APPLIED (v1.0 → v1.1)

P1 downgrade NT14 khỏi HP → clause Đ43 §3.1 A/B/C P2 bảng lookup context_trigger_sources FK P3 bảng queue context_pack_requests + dedupe_bucket P4 manifest bỏ UNIQUE(checksum), thêm publish_status+kb_mirror_status+published_at P5 sections CHECK enum section_name P6 pg_try_advisory_lock(43,1) thay pg_advisory_lock(43001) P7 checksum skip nếu không đổi P8 Bước 7 2-phase publish + compensating P9 chốt birth_registry, bỏ pivot_count() P10 git_commit fallback chain P11 trigger_type='cron' + coverage_status='complete' + secondary trong extra_metadata P12 fn_log_issue 5 params P13 H5 2 ngưỡng 15KB/20KB P14 on-deploy chỉ fire sau Đ41 Bước 6.5 is_known_good

4 PATCHES R2 APPLIED (v1.1 DRAFT → v1.1 FINAL)

Patch A — context_pack_requests.status giữ enum 5 values, reason vào detail.reason Patch B — Tách logical_checksum_sha256 (strip header volatile, compare skip) + file_checksum_sha256 (verify drift H3) Patch C — Bước 7g repair clause FS-live/DB-staging + publish_step column + H9 check Patch D — Trigger wording NEW.key LIKE theo schema thực tế kb_documents(key TEXT PK)

---

TÀI LIỆU TRACE

• Báo cáo Council R1: knowledge/current-state/reports/council-review-dieu43-v1-{gemini,gpt}-round1.md
• Báo cáo Council R2: knowledge/current-state/reports/council-review-dieu43-v1-{gemini,gpt}-round2.md
• Luật hiện hành: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu43-system-context-law.md rev 1 v1.1 FINAL

---

SUPERSEDED 2026-04-16 | Draft trace only | Luật hiện hành ở file khác