GPT Review — P11E Checker Proof Full Draft

Verdict

PASS có điều kiện. Không upload bản hiện tại. Yêu cầu Opus polish thành P11E-A trước upload.

Key review

P11E full draft đi đúng hướng: giữ proof/design layer, tách P6 structural checker vs P44-5A edge checker vs P11E semantic metadata drift, kế thừa severity BLOCK/ERROR/WARN/INFO của P6 và thêm readiness contract để tránh claim runtime proof khi metadata chưa populate.

Required P11E-A fixes

1. Rename checker_status to checker_run_status.
2. Add AP-CHECKER prefix convention for P11E sub-checker IDs to avoid collision with P6 checker IDs.
3. Add checker outcome truth table combining metadata presence, source availability, drift detection, severity, issue creation, and recommended action.
4. Split C2 Phase 1 into C2a legal normative refs and C2b profile/design-doc refs; keep C2b logical/defer until P44 profile/version metadata is stable.
5. Move source_of_truth_registry and metadata schema sketches to non-normative examples; avoid implying new registry or schema creation in P11E.
6. Add explicit upload target decision: recommend knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/closure/p11e-checker-proof-design.md, because P11E is a closure/proof note, not a report or design artifact.

Direction

Opus should produce P11E-A polish only, not upload. After GPT/User review of P11E-A, upload if PASS.