GPT Review — IU-0 Outline and Vector Safety Direction

Verdict

PASS outline direction with required caution. Do not full draft IU-0 yet. First run a short, read-only vector reality investigation because Agent Data vector stack is already operating in production-like usage with Langroid + Qdrant and orphan-vector review mechanisms.

Key decisions

1. P11E-A upload is accepted and recorded as completed.
2. IU-0 direction is correct: information_unit must become a common Incomex-wide minimum standard, not a TAC-only schema.
3. IU-0 must not redesign P38-XC UMC, P44-3, P44-4A, P44-5A, P5/P6. It should package them into a usable standard.
4. Vector section must be downgraded from asserted design to cautious principles until actual vector implementation is inspected.
5. Do not open P44-6.
6. Next step for Opus: polish IU-0 outline, not full draft, and add a required precondition: Vector Reality Check (read-only) before any vector contract is finalized.

File placement direction

• Uploaded proof/closure notes remain under knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/closure/.
• GPT reviews/handoff reviews under knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/reviews/ or knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/reviews/ depending on owner stream.
• Đ44 design docs remain under knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/.
• P38/TAC reports remain under knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/reports/.
• IU-0 should not be placed under knowledge/dev/foundation/ without first verifying that this folder convention is active. Recommended controlled path for the next artifact is knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/07-iu0-information-unit-minimum-standard-outline.md for the outline/polish stage, because current active design sequence 01-06 is already there. Future enacted cross-cutting canonical location may be decided later.

Required Opus next step

Produce IU-0 OUTLINE-A polish only, with an explicit Vector Reality Check precondition and a file placement table. No upload, no full draft, no implementation, no P44-6.