GPT Handoff Review — P11E Outline Instruction

Verdict

PASS handoff. KB verification completed for the key uploaded artifacts.

Verified in KB

• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/05-relation-edge-conformance-design.md exists as P44-4A final/polish design.
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu44-trien-khai/design/06-update-mechanism-dot-contract-matrix.md exists as P44-5A polish design.
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/closure/p11c-closure-note-2026-05-02.md exists and states P11C design phase CLOSED, execution phase DEFERRED to P44-6 / Pilot Tier 1, with next recommended P11D.
• knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/closure/p11d-logical-topic-view-proof-design.md exists as P11D-A POLISH FINAL / uploaded.

P11D spot checks

• Header contains P11D-A POLISH and final micro-fix history.
• §0 line 4 says Q-T3 includes contradicts with opposing annotation and excludes contains because contains belongs to composition, not Cap-4 relation enrichment.
• §5.1 resolves publication/container via universal_edges or reverse-index generated from universal_edges; helper is not SSOT.
• §11.1 refers to Đ39 KG, not Đ24 KG.
• §6.2 includes disclaimer that output shape is design thinking only, not JSON Schema/API/UI contract.

Decision

Proceed to P11E Checker Proof as OUTLINE ONLY. Do not open P44-6. Do not upload. Do not write full draft. Do not execute audit/query production.

Guardrails for Opus

P11E must stay in proof/design layer. Use the existing SSOT files only. universal_edges remains SSOT for relation drift. Helper/materialized structures must never be treated as source truth.

P11E should cover 4 checker groups:

1. Numeric claim drift.
2. Version reference drift.
3. Broken cross-reference / relation edge drift.
4. Text-code / text-config / text-PG object binding drift.

Output must be 5 parts: reading evidence, outline, OPEN/TD, risk/conflict check, questions for GPT review.