Incomex AI Portal
KB-2E6C

P10B-2C-R2 — D28 Execute Report 2026-04-30

15 min read Revision 1
reportp10bd28execute-r2failstep-failed

P10B-2C-R2 — D28 Execute from KB Package via SSH VPS

Date: 2026-04-30
Scope: Execute D28 insert, verify, render/diff deliverables.
Verdict: FAIL — T5 verify flow-control failure after successful commit.

0. Skill + Law Read

  • Read .claude/skills/incomex-rules.md in main process.
  • Agent Data search_knowledge("operating rules SSOT") in main process.
  • Agent Data search_knowledge("hiến pháp v4.0 constitution") in main process.
  • Agent Data search_knowledge("P10B-2C-R2 Execute D28 KB package PF-R2") in main process.

0-W. 3 câu Tuyên ngôn

  1. Vĩnh viễn: Execution uses KB package manifest as root artifact; all available execution evidence is promoted back to KB.
  2. Nhầm được không: Gate 0 + package SHA + runtime preflight + run-file guard prevent wrong host/package and prevent bare rollback.
  3. 100% tự động: Flow-control marker STEP_FAILED determines skip/jump behavior and artifact upload path.

1. Gate 0

=== Control Host ===
Nguyens-MacBook-Air.local
=== Runtime Host ===
vmi3080463.contaboserver.net
Linux vmi3080463 6.8.0-90-generic #91-Ubuntu SMP PREEMPT_DYNAMIC Tue Nov 18 14:14:30 UTC 2025 x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux
postgres
directus/directus

Gate 0 PASS: SSH target is VPS, Docker postgres is running, DB identity is directus/directus.

2. Package SHA Verification

manifest.json: bytes=2673 sha256=04c159ccaeadd252ec106b7845eec6c83b9141fc06f25d9103f118bb90595904 source=knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/data/p10b-d28-fix-package/manifest.json
insert-candidate.sql: bytes=48691 sha256=b71fd67544e1f97a72e1c6477218367f2f02be2c7009c6eb73490b601369e537 source=knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/data/p10b-d28-fix-package/insert-candidate.sql
render.sql: bytes=1165 sha256=478d2115ded1e472b580c250a166945b4989d6e76019a5748a3012db168874e9 source=knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/data/p10b-d28-fix-package/render.sql
rollback.sql: bytes=1007 sha256=bf07e44ddfd3557b621c455483a45784aa135f4ea4d4c8ec844a93a8512ed7c7 source=knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/data/p10b-d28-fix-package/rollback.sql
verify-counts.sql: bytes=978 sha256=3662534c043134b0feb78c124e309db846c042cd0d3b8b7c7281667f981e705d source=knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/data/p10b-d28-fix-package/verify-counts.sql
candidate-units-r2.json: bytes=23486 sha256=e47775e33cc752656468edb287cca7b58539804678443b6c1b1dd03b165de8ad source=knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/data/p10b-d28-fix-package/candidate-units-r2.json
d28-original.md: bytes=9289 sha256=fa5ed5c1f6a6ab70f69f48e0bd3a2e4d822eb6b672a1c2b2313edd23f3277d7b source=knowledge/dev/laws/dieu28-display-technology-law.md
T1 verdict: PASS

T1 PASS: manifest and required files fetched from KB and verified.

3. Runtime Preflight

=== T2a DB identity ===
directus/directus
=== T2b schema table column counts ===
tac_logical_unit	13
tac_publication	15
tac_publication_member	6
tac_unit_version	20
=== T2c trigger count ===
3
=== T2d collisions ===
publication collision: 0
logical_unit collision: 0
=== T2e baseline counts ===
           t            | count 
------------------------+-------
 tac_publication        |     2
 tac_logical_unit       |    59
 tac_unit_version       |    59
 tac_publication_member |    59
(4 rows)

T2 PASS: schema tables present, trigger count 3, collision 0/0, baseline counts captured.

4. Baseline Counts

Captured in T2 baseline:

 tac_publication        |     2
 tac_logical_unit       |    59
 tac_unit_version       |    59
 tac_publication_member |    59

5. Run-File SHA

=== tail before ===
INSERT INTO tac_logical_unit (id, canonical_address, doc_code, parent_id, sort_order, section_type, section_code, owner, identity_profile, tier, lifecycle_status)
VALUES ('9a1d49af-b0d7-5399-b843-dd5c9cf0be99'::uuid, 'D38-DIEU28-S11', 'DIEU-28', '09e5a5a5-bfc7-5882-9bf6-948a445b5341'::uuid, 12, 'paragraph', 'S11', 'INCOMEX', '{"body_sha256": "a8c128769877b7c52cf9c0f914807765f4f2f2b6748d1077bcb3ff696928a5ce", "canonical_address": "D38-DIEU28-S11", "source_span": {"end_line": 229, "start_line": 228}}'::jsonb, 'unit', 'draft_only');
INSERT INTO tac_unit_version (id, logical_unit_id, version_number, title, body, description, content_hash, lifecycle_status, review_state, length_flag, content_profile, editor, provenance)
VALUES ('03189ba6-4dd0-5446-ae9b-a44c021eceec'::uuid, '9a1d49af-b0d7-5399-b843-dd5c9cf0be99'::uuid, 1, 'Footer', $BODYTAG27$*Điều 28 v2.0 BAN HÀNH | 13/13 NT ✅ | 6/6 Q ✅ | Ref table status | PG trigger lifecycle+checklist guard | DOT paired rõ | instance_collection FK | Dùng chung dot_config*$BODYTAG27$, 'Footer', 'a8c128769877b7c52cf9c0f914807765f4f2f2b6748d1077bcb3ff696928a5ce', 'draft', 'unreviewed', 'normal', '{"description_required": true, "source_span": {"end_line": 229, "start_line": 228}, "word_count": 33}'::jsonb, 'GPT', 'PROV-AI');
INSERT INTO tac_publication_member (id, publication_id, logical_unit_id, unit_version_id, render_order)
VALUES ('308507d7-3474-56cb-a9f5-00c41333f605'::uuid, 'cf8d4dc0-3d70-55f8-8c35-e01da101d710'::uuid, '9a1d49af-b0d7-5399-b843-dd5c9cf0be99'::uuid, '03189ba6-4dd0-5446-ae9b-a44c021eceec'::uuid, 26);

-- Review manually after PF-R2. Exactly one of the following may be uncommented during authorized execute step.
-- COMMIT;
-- ROLLBACK;
OK: COMMIT uncommented.
=== source sha ===
b71fd67544e1f97a72e1c6477218367f2f02be2c7009c6eb73490b601369e537  /tmp/p10b-2c-r2/insert-candidate.sql
=== run guards ===
bare COMMIT count: 1
bare ROLLBACK count: 0
OK: final=COMMIT;
=== run sha ===
7137152b489117b588277b50fd4e3921f7420d7f83035ad6e2d0aaa1ab3675bd  /tmp/p10b-2c-r2/d28-insert-run.sql
=== tail after ===
INSERT INTO tac_logical_unit (id, canonical_address, doc_code, parent_id, sort_order, section_type, section_code, owner, identity_profile, tier, lifecycle_status)
VALUES ('9a1d49af-b0d7-5399-b843-dd5c9cf0be99'::uuid, 'D38-DIEU28-S11', 'DIEU-28', '09e5a5a5-bfc7-5882-9bf6-948a445b5341'::uuid, 12, 'paragraph', 'S11', 'INCOMEX', '{"body_sha256": "a8c128769877b7c52cf9c0f914807765f4f2f2b6748d1077bcb3ff696928a5ce", "canonical_address": "D38-DIEU28-S11", "source_span": {"end_line": 229, "start_line": 228}}'::jsonb, 'unit', 'draft_only');
INSERT INTO tac_unit_version (id, logical_unit_id, version_number, title, body, description, content_hash, lifecycle_status, review_state, length_flag, content_profile, editor, provenance)
VALUES ('03189ba6-4dd0-5446-ae9b-a44c021eceec'::uuid, '9a1d49af-b0d7-5399-b843-dd5c9cf0be99'::uuid, 1, 'Footer', $BODYTAG27$*Điều 28 v2.0 BAN HÀNH | 13/13 NT ✅ | 6/6 Q ✅ | Ref table status | PG trigger lifecycle+checklist guard | DOT paired rõ | instance_collection FK | Dùng chung dot_config*$BODYTAG27$, 'Footer', 'a8c128769877b7c52cf9c0f914807765f4f2f2b6748d1077bcb3ff696928a5ce', 'draft', 'unreviewed', 'normal', '{"description_required": true, "source_span": {"end_line": 229, "start_line": 228}, "word_count": 33}'::jsonb, 'GPT', 'PROV-AI');
INSERT INTO tac_publication_member (id, publication_id, logical_unit_id, unit_version_id, render_order)
VALUES ('308507d7-3474-56cb-a9f5-00c41333f605'::uuid, 'cf8d4dc0-3d70-55f8-8c35-e01da101d710'::uuid, '9a1d49af-b0d7-5399-b843-dd5c9cf0be99'::uuid, '03189ba6-4dd0-5446-ae9b-a44c021eceec'::uuid, 26);

-- Review manually after PF-R2. Exactly one of the following may be uncommented during authorized execute step.
COMMIT;
-- ROLLBACK;

Run-file SHA: 7137152b489117b588277b50fd4e3921f7420d7f83035ad6e2d0aaa1ab3675bd.
Source insert SHA: b71fd67544e1f97a72e1c6477218367f2f02be2c7009c6eb73490b601369e537.

6. Execute Output + pub_id

d28-insert-output.log:

BEGIN
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
INSERT 0 1
COMMIT

T4 note:

=== T4 wrapper note ===
psql output contains COMMIT; local wrapper failed after psql due zsh read-only variable name status. Insert was not retried.
insert_count_lines: 82
commit_lines: 1
=== pub_id ===
cf8d4dc0-3d70-55f8-8c35-e01da101d710

T4 effective verdict: PASS

Actual pub_id:

cf8d4dc0-3d70-55f8-8c35-e01da101d710

Important: psql output reached COMMIT with 82 INSERT 0 1 lines. The local wrapper failed after psql because zsh treats status as a read-only variable; insert was not retried.

7. Row Counts

verify-counts.sql output:

       target       | expected | actual | pass 
--------------------+----------+--------+------
 publication        |        1 |      1 | t
 logical_unit       |       27 |     27 | t
 unit_version       |       27 |     27 | t
 publication_member |       27 |     27 | t
 total              |       82 |     82 | t
(5 rows)

Row counts PASS: publication=1, LU=27, UV=27, PM=27, total=82.

8. Lifecycle / Review

Post-commit guard output:

=== lifecycle publication ===
proposed
=== lifecycle UV ===
ERROR:  column reference "lifecycle_status" is ambiguous
LINE 1: SELECT lifecycle_status, count(*) FROM tac_unit_version uv J...
               ^
=== review UV ===
 review_state | count 
--------------+-------
 unreviewed   |    27
(1 row)

=== scope publication count ===
1
=== scope LU count ===
27
=== scope PM count ===
27
=== BG-UV-02 description live ===
   case    | count 
-----------+-------
 has_desc  |    20
 null_desc |     7
(2 rows)

T5 lifecycle check failed because the prompt query used unqualified lifecycle_status, which is ambiguous across joined tac_unit_version and tac_logical_unit.

9. Scope Guard

From T5 post-commit guard output:

publication doc_code DIEU-28 count: 1
logical_unit D38-DIEU28-% count: 27
publication_member for pub_id count: 27

10. BG-UV-02 20/7 Live

From T5 post-commit guard output:

has_desc  | 20
null_desc | 7

11. Render Summary

Skipped due to prior failure at T5 per flow-control. T6-T10 were not run.

12. Diff Result

Skipped due to prior failure at T5 per flow-control.

13. Tree Report

Skipped due to prior failure at T5 per flow-control.

14. Rollback Reference

Rollback SQL was not executed. Package rollback artifact is available:

rollback.sql SHA256: bf07e44ddfd3557b621c455483a45784aa135f4ea4d4c8ec844a93a8512ed7c7
expected: bf07e44ddfd3557b621c455483a45784aa135f4ea4d4c8ec844a93a8512ed7c7
pub_id: cf8d4dc0-3d70-55f8-8c35-e01da101d710
doc_code: DIEU-28
version: v2.0
scope: reverse-FK DELETE by doc_code/version/canonical prefix
WARNING: do not execute rollback unless separately authorized.

15. Renderer Rules

Skipped due to prior failure at T5. No D28-specific renderer rule was applied in this run.

16. STEP_FAILED

T5_VERIFY failed.
verify-counts.sql PASS (publication=1, logical_unit=27, unit_version=27, publication_member=27, total=82).
T5 lifecycle query failed: ERROR: column reference "lifecycle_status" is ambiguous.
Per flow-control: skip T6-T10, do not retry/correct SELECT, jump to T11 upload artifacts + failure report.

17. Artifacts Uploaded

File Bytes SHA256
STEP_FAILED 316 b560bc6febe3a08e84fb9cc58290a8a1e5464bb82febd2846862722990c19bec
candidate-units-r2.json 23486 e47775e33cc752656468edb287cca7b58539804678443b6c1b1dd03b165de8ad
d28-insert-output.log 915 a4953e4b6b8f28920dc275fa2a6f18cf3ee8c4c87c2358b5f5204637827661cf
d28-insert-run.sql 48688 7137152b489117b588277b50fd4e3921f7420d7f83035ad6e2d0aaa1ab3675bd
d28-original.md 9289 fa5ed5c1f6a6ab70f69f48e0bd3a2e4d822eb6b672a1c2b2313edd23f3277d7b
d28-pub-id.txt 37 d282027f83c1d7f2e28b8ad735104d53e84d4839a5aedbd259559de7f79a7be3
d28-verify-output.log 326 c034e0e277ec80bd41004b01a9828cf740efab509af4bbeb351dc91246ae1a66
gate0.txt 249 5dbbd0dca36d05d86c8d0090575783547d94824b853fac38bf1c61bab1930a13
insert-candidate.sql 48691 b71fd67544e1f97a72e1c6477218367f2f02be2c7009c6eb73490b601369e537
manifest.json 2673 04c159ccaeadd252ec106b7845eec6c83b9141fc06f25d9103f118bb90595904
render.sql 1165 478d2115ded1e472b580c250a166945b4989d6e76019a5748a3012db168874e9
rollback.sql 1007 bf07e44ddfd3557b621c455483a45784aa135f4ea4d4c8ec844a93a8512ed7c7
t1-package-fetch.txt 1303 25757ee9d15c938b03457545b8ef73aac2614fee7051059c8db6b0cf59acd09c
t2-preflight.txt 499 39bc6a180fe1410e1e8658f9982a79d9ce4f148318196c1274e0db4a81765a14
t3-run-file.txt 3822 e91f3448c421c014ef476b8c74d916f463040e1777aa9ed45e84c86aaaadbe4d
t4-effective-status.txt 27 ab68d464b47c96d610e1be780a6387975aef45864b77f13d17a5720284b735ee
t4-post-execute-check.txt 240 05dc6fc974b3125bbd2d923f95b4fb580585d6882a62c73588eae38675027652
t5-post-commit-guards.txt 509 05cb62fbe84a2fdbceda976ee64e04a627098859a10d2fe3aac37de824b48518
t5-status.txt 25 80decf069ae6ede4fb47c39d1f8746835149ee04bc21dd4e8afe26a40efaca63
verify-counts.sql 978 3662534c043134b0feb78c124e309db846c042cd0d3b8b7c7281667f981e705d

18. Verdict

FAIL — T5_VERIFY. The insert committed and row-count verification passed, but T5 lifecycle verification failed on the provided ambiguous SELECT. Per flow-control, T6-T10 were skipped, no corrective SQL was attempted, no retry was performed, and no rollback was executed.

STOP. Do not closeout P10B. Await Opus review + GPT confirm.