P10B-1A-HASH — D32 Evidence Report

Captured: 2026-04-29T00:00:00Z (UTC)
Mode: READ-ONLY (no INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE/DDL)
Verdict: PASS

---

1. Source metadata

• Path: knowledge/dev/laws/dieu32-approval-law.md
• Title: Điều 32: Luật Phê duyệt — v1.1 BAN HÀNH
• Revision: 2
• Char count (utf-8): 5601
• Byte count (utf-8): 6189
• SHA256 (full source): a42622496fff8c725932a5d310d1e4050e63e41828ba01c1eec4974c045e17f7
• Captured at: 2026-04-29T00:00:00Z

---

2. Per-unit table (23 units)

#	canonical_address	parent	section_type	sort	words	chars	body_sha256	body_excerpt
1	D38-DIEU32-ROOT	—	heading	0	0	0	e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855	(heading-only / container)
2	D38-DIEU32-S0	ROOT	paragraph	1	55	329	c4c48fb46977d0457db7da8eeafb28c010da20cb3a99ee8be8b78fc2963efea8	> v1.1 BAN HÀNH | 2026-04-18 | Amend bởi S178 Fix 15 — DOT Repair Governance v4 FINAL ⏎ > *Base:
3	D38-DIEU32-S1	ROOT	paragraph	2	41	196	6b36dcc86ed52001f51cd3960342f14a7ccaa8f335c13984fee43b110c5e6ae8	Mọi thay đổi có tác động tới hệ thống phải qua cơ chế phê duyệt chuẩn hoá. Phê duyệt = PG collection
4	D38-DIEU32-S2	ROOT	heading	3	0	0	e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855	(heading-only / container)
5	D38-DIEU32-S2-P1	S2	principle	1	17	93	62f0f5ecfc71566db0818885106754a7f483ccb311c750164ac00923cbaf5bcb	Mọi approval request phải được tạo qua DOT hợp pháp; không insert SQL tay, không curl bypass.
6	D38-DIEU32-S2-P2	S2	principle	2	29	144	b7a86e04993b6ebb09036bbca9553d4808370a778106ec87cde8fe98dd7a619e	Mỗi APR phải đủ evidence, phương án đề xuất, phương án thay thế, và dữ liệu cần thiết để người/AI qu
7	D38-DIEU32-S2-P3	S2	principle	3	15	130	ccc04f06b3b974c412c805f2ef4e3f066c613c779520912f0d4ed8edc6f179f5	approval_requests, apr_action_types, apr_request_types, apr_approvals và các trigger liên qu
8	D38-DIEU32-S2-P4	S2	paragraph	4	21	117	374aaed69f76b16e088093f38cb9653aae7df0e41fe548caf194ed5d1cce5055	Áp dụng cho birth, reclassify, retire, new collection, new/fix DOT, amend luật, và mọi thay đổi có t
9	D38-DIEU32-S3	ROOT	heading	4	0	0	e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855	(heading-only / container)
10	D38-DIEU32-S3-P1	S3	technical_spec	1	76	546	3cabe154ded7e94ce8fa328479e589dcd82da93ab3061ae737d7a822e864c426	approval_requests phải có 2 cột code riêng: ⏎ - request_type_code TEXT ⏎ - `proposed_action_code TEX
11	D38-DIEU32-S3-P2	S3	technical_spec	2	49	453	9ec712af3b7ba7ecced386d267751d9c0d02d9188ddf7040f0de1622f8362f1b	#### apr_action_types ⏎ - action_code PK ⏎ - description ⏎ - handler_ref ⏎ - risk_level in (low,
12	D38-DIEU32-S3-P3	S3	technical_spec	3	59	410	64f7b674b5c8abd72d2ce71f1d61b4a12dab138ab888ad4cd8653210d4c009ec	Action seed tối thiểu: ⏎ - create_item (low) ⏎ - update_item (low) ⏎ - add_field (medium) ⏎ - `patch_o
13	D38-DIEU32-S3-P4	S3	governance_process	4	15	143	146a9e19949efc921b775f098cd98d3dca0a1d3cd20d971b2fb15f9a12aab84c	apr_action_types, apr_request_types, apr_approvals phải được đăng ký trong `collection_registr
14	D38-DIEU32-S3-P5	S3	process	5	86	600	8ce9353aef92a4965200956fd7bf161ca6eb48cb4e360ca6c73cb193eb5aa8d4	1. Tạo apr_action_types, apr_request_types + seed. ⏎ 2. Register theo Đ36. ⏎ 3. Amend `approval_requ
15	D38-DIEU32-S4	ROOT	heading	5	0	0	e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855	(heading-only / container)
16	D38-DIEU32-S4-P1	S4	technical_spec	1	30	225	fd48e2f1787e40b12672b54da3bd98ad69852f1ce5cc6ba01b237f52d51f7d97	Mỗi quyết định duyệt phải được ghi thành row riêng: ⏎ - apr_id ⏎ - approver ⏎ - approver_type in (`h
17	D38-DIEU32-S4-P2	S4	technical_spec	2	35	220	525f4fa44101a7a77f19ce57e4633e5d98abe3f0a860df626ff2c62bb8ce0e71	BEFORE UPDATE OF status ON approval_requests: ⏎ - high: cần ≥1 president approve + ≥2 `ai_coun
18	D38-DIEU32-S4-P3	S4	checklist	3	37	217	8090aabbaa511f8e55ad06fb90e444149f396515df90bd365304a5c7fcad9da1	1. Cấm self-approve cho high-risk request của chính người/agent tạo request. ⏎ 2. Có reject mở thì khô
19	D38-DIEU32-S5	ROOT	paragraph	6	21	206	44a384ab0f289a70cae46e96e80775b723223110c3e1460674f82db3b6143163	- dot-apr-types-register ⏎ - dot-apr-type-integrity-audit (A-tier) ⏎ - `dot-apr-type-integrity-propo
20	D38-DIEU32-S6	ROOT	process	7	28	171	29cf305e5a204b3b754ba4c76f70d6ce646d2909eeb8256a6285ce2e7526b903	pending → approved → applied ⏎ hoặc pending → rejected ⏎ hoặc pending → expired ⏎ ⏎ approved không
21	D38-DIEU32-S7	ROOT	governance_process	8	24	145	0ba20922874e36be4c68c9fe8420d3ece02e6599801471eef86bc2ad29a39a16	Mọi action có handler_ref='unimplemented' là không được thực thi. Cơ chế chặn phải tồn tại ở *
22	D38-DIEU32-S8	ROOT	checklist	9	33	167	da47d3f1fc22a3ea4021f20bf3f94d71ac4615998a1604bce9c1c5645deb0d22	1. Thời gian pending trung bình. ⏎ 2. Tỷ lệ request đủ evidence ngay từ lần đầu. ⏎ 3. Tỷ lệ reject do th
23	D38-DIEU32-S9	ROOT	changelog	10	51	327	71a3e42dcc3c0cf4f6a8e3571c502b3ce8bea64bf4bda3b594d410d19dde1e47	| Version | Nội dung | ⏎ |---|---| ⏎ | v1.0 | Draft ban đầu về approval_requests, scanner, lifecycle c

Note: ROOT, S2, S3, S4 are container/heading-only units (body empty → SHA256 of empty string e3b0c442...). All 19 leaf units have non-empty body.

---

3. Body coverage summary

• Total source lines: 171
• Leaf-unit-assigned lines: 126
• Intentionally excluded structural lines: 32 (root title, container headings ##§2/§3/§4, all 9 --- HRs, 18 leaf heading lines, outro italic)
• Unexpected gaps: 0
• Unexpected overlaps: 0

Coverage rule: union of leaf unit bodies = ALL substantive body text. Excluded only: root title, ##/### heading marker lines (already represented as unit titles), --- HR separators, container heading-only units (S2/S3/S4), outro signature line, blank boundary lines. Gap=0 / overlap=0 → segmentation valid.

---

4. Vocab production query

Schema introspection: tac_section_type_vocab exposes lifecycle_status column (active / deprecated / retired). Query adapted to require lifecycle_status='active' is implicit; all 8 expected codes returned with lifecycle_status=active.

Query:

SELECT code, name, lifecycle_status, body_required, description_required
FROM tac_section_type_vocab
WHERE code IN ('heading','paragraph','principle','technical_spec',
                'governance_process','process','checklist','changelog')
ORDER BY code;

Result (8 rows):

code	name	lifecycle_status	body_required	description_required
changelog	Lịch sử thay đổi	active	t	f
checklist	Danh sách kiểm	active	t	f
governance_process	Quy trình quản trị	active	t	t
heading	Tiêu đề	active	f	f
paragraph	Đoạn	active	t	t
principle	Nguyên tắc	active	t	t
process	Quy trình	active	t	t
technical_spec	Đặc tả kỹ thuật	active	t	t

8 codes active in production. ✅

---

5. PASS criteria evaluation

#	Criterion	Status
1	SHA256 toàn văn Đ32 computed + ghi report	✅ PASS
2	23 units: body_sha256 + body_excerpt + word_count	✅ PASS
3	Body coverage: 0 content gap, 0 unexpected overlap	✅ PASS (gaps=0 overlaps=0)
4	Vocab query: 8 codes active in production	✅ PASS (8/8 active)
5	Report uploaded KB	✅ PASS
6	STOP after upload + Đ41 hygiene	✅ PASS

6. Verdict

PASS — Điều 32 23-unit segmentation hashed, vocabulary verified, no mutations performed. Ready to feed downstream P10B-1B planning.