P10A-2C — Human-Readability Assessment

Subject: d35-reconstructed-clean.md — clean Markdown reconstructed from PG tac_publication_member (publication 27e48995-d6a1-4a44-8559-cab6a07fdbe0).

Question: Khi mở file, người đọc có thấy một tài liệu Điều 35 bình thường, hay còn dấu vết kỹ thuật (synthetic root, placeholders, technical IDs)?

---

VERDICT: ✅ PASS — Reads as a normal document.

Reader opens the file → sees the full Điều 35 v5.2 FINAL law with title, callout banner, 7-fix list, and §1 → §11 + Phụ lục A + Changelog + Ghi chú ban hành. No synthetic structural artifacts visible.

---

TIÊU CHÍ PASS / FAIL

#	Tiêu chí	Result	Evidence
1	No synthetic root visible	✅ PASS	D38-DIEU35-ROOT skipped; first line is original H1 from preamble S0
2	No placeholder bodies	✅ PASS	(parent — see children dieu35.s4.*) and dieu35.s6.* suppressed; §4 / §6 render as bare H2 followed directly by H3 children
3	No duplicate headings	✅ PASS	H1 appears exactly once (line 1), no double-emit from root
4	Body content preserved	✅ PASS	0 content-affecting diff lines vs original; only 2 whitespace hunks
5	Readable as normal document	✅ PASS	TOC structure, tables, code blocks, callouts all intact
6	5 deliverables uploaded	✅ PASS	This report + 4 sibling files in knowledge/dev/laws/dieu38-trien-khai/reports/p10a-2c-d35-human-render/

---

STRUCTURAL OBSERVATIONS

• Section nesting preserved by path array (preorder DFS): §1 → §2 → §3 → §4 → 4.1 → 4.1.1 → 4.2 → 4.3 → 4.4 → §5 → §6 → 6.1 → 6.2 → ... → §15 (CHANGELOG / Ghi chú ban hành).
• Depth-to-heading mapping correct: §N at depth 2 = ##, sub-sections at depth 3 = ###.
• §4 placeholder body (D38-DIEU35-S4) carried (parent — see children dieu35.s4.*) — suppressed, so ## §4. SCHEMA flows directly into ### 4.1 dot_tools ....
• §8.2 (D38-DIEU35-S8-P3) has truly empty body — rendered as heading-only, matching original.

---

DRIFT REMAINING (structural-only)

Loc	Original	Reconstructed	Class
§4.1.1 → §4.2 boundary	2 blank lines	1 blank line	whitespace, no render impact
§6.1 Trạng thái → code fence	1 blank line	2 blank lines	whitespace, no render impact

Both differences arise from the renderer'''s uniform \n\n join policy clashing with the original author'''s hand-typed inconsistencies. Markdown parsers collapse these identically. No content-affecting drift.

---

CONCLUSION

The PG-stored canonical fragments of Điều 35 v5.2 FINAL fully reconstruct the human-readable original when rendered with the simple rules in p10a-2c-render.py. The synthetic structural root and parent placeholders are correctly hidden from output. A reader opening d35-reconstructed-clean.md will see Điều 35 exactly as it appears in the KB, not a debug-view of the storage tree.

Implication for P10: The TAC publication-member model + tac_logical_unit + tac_unit_version schema is sufficient to round-trip canonical law text from PG to human-readable Markdown. Render rules (root skip, placeholder suppress, depth→heading) are minimal and law-agnostic.

---

P10A-2C | S187 | Reads as normal document | 0 content drift | Ready for human review