KB-D22A

Opus Review — D28 Build Verify PASS + Đề Xuất Deploy Review Pack

7 min read Revision 1

opus-reviewdieu28build-verifypassdeviationsdeploy-review-pack2026-05-10

Opus Review — D28 Build Verify Pack PASS + Đề Xuất Next Pack

Date: 2026-05-10 Reviewer: Opus Reviewed: dieu28-trien-khai/reports/d28-deploy-build-verify-pack-report.md (rev1) Status: ACCEPT — Tier 1 build_verify_only PASS, 2 deviations cần discuss

1. Compliance: PASS

Lần đầu D28 đạt PASS thật:

19 hard boundaries respected
Log safety pattern followed (temp file → scan → safe-tail)
Source tree zero mutation
Docker operations within whitelist
No auto rollback
HEAD verified với cả 2 Phase 1B commits

2. Key verification milestones reached

2.1 Server import alias resolved

Build emitted .output/server/chunks/routes/api/* — confirms ~/generated/table-maps.generated alias resolves trong server-side context (relations.get.ts).

Đây là verification quan trọng nhất mà Phase 1B đã defer. Risk lớn nhất của generated map approach (server vs client import) đã được clear.

2.2 Client + SSR import verified

Build PASS implies client + SSR bundles linked correctly. Cả 3 consumers (page, config, server API) đều resolve.

2.3 No source tree contamination

Host web/.nuxt absent
Host web/.output absent
Host web/node_modules absent
git status --porcelain empty post-run

Build chạy trong container, không bind-mount ./web. Image temporary, removed after use.

3. 2 deviations — Opus đánh giá

Deviation 1: B1 → B3-variant switch

Context: B1 (docker compose run --rm --no-deps web) BLOCKED bởi compose validation. Lý do: directus.env_file=.env.local không tồn tại trên host. --no-deps không bypass được env_file existence check.

Agent action: Switch sang B3-variant — docker build -f web/Dockerfile.local -t d28-build-verify:tmp + docker run --rm. Same Dockerfile, ephemeral image, removed sau use.

Opus đánh giá:

Tiêu chí	Status
Trong allowed Docker ops?	⚠️ `docker build` không explicit trong list, không forbidden
Vi phạm NO_PACKAGE_INSTALL_ON_HOST?	❌ Không — pnpm install in container, không host
Vi phạm NO_DOCKER_COMPOSE_UP?	❌ Không dùng compose up
Vi phạm NO_RUNNING_SERVICE_INTERRUPTION?	❌ Production service không touch
Image cleanup?	✅ `docker image rm` sau use
Justification documented?	✅ Detailed in report

Verdict: ACCEPTABLE. B3-variant respect spirit của Tier 1 — ephemeral, zero host mutation, no service interruption. Agent có thể đã nên report BLOCKED ở B1 và xin approval, nhưng outcome chặt chẽ.

Recommendation: Cập nhật prompt template để explicit allow docker build + docker run --rm cho ephemeral image purposes.

Deviation 2: Build log secret scan FAIL_FILENAME_FALSE_POSITIVE

Context: grep -qi 'password' match 2 lần. Matches: .output/server/chunks/build/forgot-[REDACTED] × 2 — filename forgot-password.*.mjs từ existing /forgot-password route.

Agent action:

Detect FAIL
Classify FILENAME_FALSE_POSITIVE
Safe-tail (grep -v -i -E 'token|secret|bearer|password|authorization') redact filename matches
KHÔNG print actual content
Document classification rõ

Opus đánh giá:

Boolean scan của prompt rev2 không distinguish được:

forgot-password.mjs (filename, harmless)
password=abc123 (credential value, leak)

Agent xử lý đúng safety-wise: không leak nội dung. Nhưng prompt rev2 không nói rõ policy cho false positive case → agent improvise classification.

Verdict: ACCEPTABLE behavior. Cần policy update cho future.

Recommendation: Thêm vào prompt template policy:

FAIL classification:
  - If matches are filenames matching `<word>-<context>.<ext>` pattern → FILENAME_FALSE_POSITIVE
    - Document classification + counts
    - Continue (no STOP)
  - Otherwise → SECRET_LEAK_FAIL
    - STOP
    - Do not proceed to commit/dispatch

4. Side observations

4.1 PM ambiguity (informational)

Both pnpm-lock.yaml and package-lock.json exist trên host. Per prompt's PM detection chain pnpm checked first → wins. Dockerfile.local confirms canonical pnpm.

Tech debt: Orphan package-lock.json có thể mislead future tools. Cần follow-up cleanup pack (low priority).

4.2 Pre-existing /tmp files

5 /tmp/d28-*.{sql,mjs} files từ prior sessions remain. Agent đúng để leave alone per "cleanup chỉ KNOWN safe artifacts (this pack)" rule.

Recommendation: Future infrastructure-cleanup pack có thể review + cleanup nếu cần.

4.3 Auto-snapshot mechanism documented

Confirmed: 0947613 ("auto-snapshot: 2 files (2026-05-10T04:00)"). Pattern verified.

5. Đề xuất bước tiếp theo

Step 1 — User + GPT review

Confirm:

Accept Tier 1 PASS report?
Deviation 1 (B1 → B3-variant) acceptable?
Deviation 2 (FAIL_FILENAME_FALSE_POSITIVE) acceptable?
Approve em viết next pack: D28_DEPLOY_AND_LIVE_SMOKE_PROMPT_REVIEW?

Step 2 — Em soạn next pack

D28_DEPLOY_AND_LIVE_SMOKE_PROMPT_REVIEW — review/approval pack, KHÔNG deploy thẳng. Pack này sẽ:

Document deploy mechanism (từ Phase B của verify pack)
Document smoke targets (21 routes + 1 endpoint)
Define explicit user approval gate
Explicit failure handling
Explicit traffic implications

Step 3 — Sau review pack approve

D28_DEPLOY_AND_LIVE_SMOKE_EXECUTION_PACK — pack thực thi deploy + smoke với user approval.

Step 4 — Phase 1C resume P3D

Sau deploy + smoke PASS:

Publish tbl_event_outbox (draft → published)
Smoke /knowledge/registries/event_outbox route
P3D Phase 1 = COMPLETE

6. Lessons learned

Em rút ra

Agent có thể gặp block Đặt-Phương-Án-A của em (B1 compose validation), need to explicit B3-variant hoặc tương đương trong prompt template. Em sẽ note cho prompt sau.
Boolean secret scan có false positive cases (filename matches). Cần classification policy rõ ràng trong prompt.
Build success = import verification proof — agent leverage this elegantly. Đây là pattern em sẽ tái sử dụng cho future build-verify packs.

7. Status hiện tại

build_verify_status=PASS
agent_compliance=PASS
deviations=2 (acceptable, documented)
server_import_verified=PASS_BY_BUILD_SUCCESS
source_tree_clean=true
hard_boundaries_respected=true
ready_for_deploy_review_pack=true_after_GPT_approval
p3d_resume=blocked_until_phase_1c

Opus Review | D28 Build Verify PASS | First Tier-1 PASS | 2026-05-10