RS-TKT-1-PATCH1B · 05 Dry-Run Launch Readiness Packet
RS-TKT-1-PATCH1B · 05 — Dry-Run Launch Readiness Packet
NON_EXECUTABLE_DESIGN_EXAMPLE
FUTURE_DRY_RUN_BLUEPRINT_ONLY
NOT_IMPLEMENTED
NOT_AUTHORIZED_FOR_RUNTIME
Lane: RS-TKT-1 — Phase 1 TKT Base Design Package · PATCH1B (dry-run readiness preflight / proof-doc-only)
Date: 2026-06-22
Gate: REGISTRATION_HOLD · REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED = NO · 0 runtime mutations
Authority: NON_AUTHORITY · may_gate=false · decision_effect=NONE
Closes: Codex F9 / macro §2.1. After this packet, a future Phase-2 dry-run / read-report inspector can begin without further design clarification — only Codex confirmation and an explicit Owner/GPT Phase-2 open command remain.
This proves dry-run readiness. It does not run a dry-run, does not build the inspector, and does not open Phase 2. Decisions below labelled
SAFE_DEFAULT_SELECTEDare the design-doc defaults this macro (§0A) authorizes Claude to set. They fix what the inspector would read/write; they do not grant the execution-time permission to actually run it — that remains the Owner Phase-2 open command.
1. Future dry-run identity and scope
future_dry_run_name : RS-TKT-2-DRYRUN-READ-REPORT-INSPECTOR
future_dry_run_mode : READ_REPORT_INSPECTOR_ONLY
future_dry_run_scope : a read/report inspector over INERT fixtures and governed KB packets only.
It READS governed packets, applies the canonical oracle (patch1b/01–02), and WRITES a result report.
forbidden_dry_run_mode: SUBJECT_UNDER_TEST_RUNTIME · PG_MUTATION · DIRECTUS_MUTATION · REGISTRY_MUTATION ·
NVSZ_ROOT_DESIGNATION · RAW_LOG_WRITE
Dry-run readiness ≠ dry-run execution. Construction blueprint ≠ construction. Readiness-to-open ≠ authorization-to-open.
2. Future allowed paths (SAFE_DEFAULT_SELECTED — macro §2.5/§4.6; Owner may override)
allowed_source_prefix (read) : knowledge/dev/laws-new/tool-kiem-thu-lego/
allowed Phase-1 source subset:
knowledge/dev/laws-new/tool-kiem-thu-lego/phase1-design/
knowledge/dev/laws-new/tool-kiem-thu-lego/phase1-design/patch1/
knowledge/dev/laws-new/tool-kiem-thu-lego/phase1-design/patch1b-dryrun-readiness/
allowed_output_prefix (write) : knowledge/current-state/reports/tool-kiem-thu-lego/phase2-dryrun/
future_report_filename_pattern : rs-tkt-2-dryrun-read-report-inspector-YYYY-MM-DD.md
future_report_schema : phase1-design/13 (result.json / result.md; advisory; NONE effects)
disposable_workbench (if any) : local + hashed + regenerable; NEVER a vector-KB path (07 §5); NEVER /tmp alone.
3. Future read-only permission model (SAFE_DEFAULT_SELECTED — deny-by-default)
read KB governed files under allowed_source_prefix : ALLOWED
write ONE KB report under allowed_output_prefix : ALLOWED
run local runtime / subject-under-test / DOT / CLI : FORBIDDEN (no runtime required; L1 stops at HOLD_RUNTIME_SURFACE_REQUIRED)
mutate PG / Directus / registry / system_issues : FORBIDDEN
write raw logs into a vector-KB path : FORBIDDEN (ESCROW_E5)
designate NON_VECTOR_ROOT : FORBIDDEN (ESCROW_E9 / ROOT_E4; Phase 3 + Owner only)
move registration / open register_dot / set CAN_PROCEED=YES : FORBIDDEN
If a required read/write surface is unavailable ⇒ HOLD (never PASS): HOLD_NO_EXEC_SURFACE / HOLD_OUTPUT_SURFACE_UNAVAILABLE.
4. Future forbidden operations (explicit)
no subject-under-test execution · no Python/shell/CLI runner · no DOT runtime · no validator/registrar created ·
no Owner/scope/APR/register_dot · no PG/Directus/registry/system_issues mutation · no NVSZ root designation ·
no raw-log write · no registration movement · no production · no semantic Text-as-Code PASS · no IU traceability PASS ·
no release bundle PASS · no implementation/runtime/production PASS · no automatic Phase-2 open.
5. Future stop states (enumerated — 15 §4)
HOLD_NO_EXEC_SURFACE — no authorized read/report surface exists yet ⇒ inspector stops (default until Owner opens Phase 2).
HOLD_RUNTIME_SURFACE_REQUIRED — reconstruction would need subject-under-test runtime ⇒ Phase 4, never PASS in Base.
HOLD_OUTPUT_SURFACE_UNAVAILABLE — scan/output surface incomplete ⇒ HOLD, never PASS.
plus the verdict stop-states in patch1b/09 for any nonzero defect count.
6. Future expected artifacts
ONE result report at: knowledge/current-state/reports/tool-kiem-thu-lego/phase2-dryrun/rs-tkt-2-dryrun-read-report-inspector-YYYY-MM-DD.md
containing: per-fixture {fixture_id, expected_check_status, observed (paper), canonical_outcome_code}, the aggregate truth-table
result (06), and authority_effect=NONE / registration_effect=NONE throughout. result.json/result.md per schema 13. No other artifact.
7. Future pass/fail/hold rules (advisory; never authority)
Per-fixture: expected_check_status from catalog 02 (PASS|FAIL|HOLD|N/A); one canonical_outcome_code.
Aggregate : FAIL > HOLD > PASS (06 §5); N/A never upgrades; aggregate ∈ {PASS,FAIL,HOLD}.
aggregate_status is ADVISORY ONLY. aggregate=PASS does NOT imply authority/gate/registration/CAN_PROCEED=YES or any
semantic/implementation/runtime/production PASS. authority_effect/registration_effect are ALWAYS NONE (06 §8).
8. Launch gates (the ONLY things that remain after this packet)
GATE-1 Codex confirmation of PATCH1B : CODEX_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED (expected gate, not a design gap)
GATE-2 Owner/GPT explicit "open Phase 2" command : OWNER_AUTHORIZATION_STILL_REQUIRED (expected gate, not a design gap)
INVARIANT-1 REGISTRATION_HOLD remains active : MUST_STAY_TRUE
INVARIANT-2 REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED = NO : MUST_STAY_TRUE
After GATE-1 + GATE-2, no missing design clarification remains: the name, scope, paths, permissions, stop states, artifacts,
pass/fail/hold rules, and the oracle/coverage/traceability proofs are all fixed by patch1b/01–04 + this packet.
9. Input / permission / decision register (DR-1..DR-17 — re-classified; SAFE_DEFAULT applied where this macro authorizes)
| item_id | item | item_type | required_for | classification | safe_fallback |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DR-1 | Phase 1 + PATCH1B accepted by GPT then Codex | CODEX_CONFIRMATION | PHASE2 | CODEX_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED | stay in Phase 1 design |
| DR-2 | Owner explicitly opens Phase 2 | OWNER_DECISION | PHASE2 | OWNER_AUTHORIZATION_STILL_REQUIRED | Phase 2 stays closed |
| DR-3 | allowed KB source prefixes (read) | INPUT | PHASE2 | SAFE_DEFAULT_SELECTED (…/tool-kiem-thu-lego/) |
none named ⇒ HOLD_NO_EXEC_SURFACE |
| DR-4 | allowed disposable workbench path | INPUT | PHASE2 | SAFE_DEFAULT_SELECTED (local+hashed+regenerable; never vector KB) | none ⇒ no reconstruction |
| DR-5 | allowed OUTPUT KB path for result.json/md | INPUT | PHASE2 | SAFE_DEFAULT_SELECTED (…/reports/tool-kiem-thu-lego/phase2-dryrun/) |
none ⇒ HOLD_OUTPUT_SURFACE_UNAVAILABLE |
| DR-6 | fixture / oracle catalog accepted | CODEX_CONFIRMATION | PHASE2 | READY (artifact = patch1b/01+02) |
— |
| DR-7 | report schema accepted | CODEX_CONFIRMATION | PHASE2 | READY (artifact = 13) |
— |
| DR-8 | stop states accepted | CODEX_CONFIRMATION | PHASE2 | READY (artifact = §5 here + 15 §4) |
— |
| DR-9 | read-only permission model | PERMISSION | PHASE2 | SAFE_DEFAULT_SELECTED (read KB / write report only; §3) | deny-by-default ⇒ HOLD |
| DR-10 | no runtime-execution permission (absent) | PERMISSION | PHASE2 | READY (must stay absent) | L1 ⇒ HOLD_RUNTIME_SURFACE_REQUIRED |
| DR-11 | no subject-under-test access (absent) | PERMISSION | PHASE2 | READY (must stay absent) | inert fixtures only |
| DR-12 | implementation language / tooling | PHASE2_INPUT | PHASE2 | OWNER_DECISION (OD-4; not a design gap) | 09/10 are paper modules |
| DR-13 | repo / path for implementation | PHASE2_INPUT | PHASE2 | OWNER_DECISION (OD-5; not a design gap) | 09 layout is a drawing |
| DR-14 | base-pack currency confirmation | CODEX_CONFIRMATION | PHASE2 | OWNER_DECISION (OD-11) | treat base pack as reference |
| DR-15 | NVSZ root designation | DEFERRED (PHASE3) | PHASE3 | DEFERRED (OD-1) | designated=false; never invent |
| DR-16 | Call Contract / execution verifier | DEFERRED (PHASE4) | FUTURE | DEFERRED (OD-7) | no SUT execution |
| DR-17 | L4 IU / L5 semantic / L6 release inputs | DEFERRED | FUTURE_L4_L6 | DEFERRED | tokens forbidden output (04 §3) |
10. Future dry-run command sheet (PSEUDO — for illustration of scope only)
PSEUDO_COMMAND_ONLY
NOT_EXECUTABLE
NOT_AUTHORIZED_FOR_RUNTIME
pseudo> rs-tkt-2 inspect \
--mode READ_REPORT_INSPECTOR_ONLY \
--source-prefix knowledge/dev/laws-new/tool-kiem-thu-lego/ \
--oracle patch1b-dryrun-readiness/01,02 \
--report-out knowledge/current-state/reports/tool-kiem-thu-lego/phase2-dryrun/rs-tkt-2-dryrun-read-report-inspector-<DATE>.md \
--no-runtime --no-sut --no-mutation --no-root-designation
# Illustration only. No such binary exists; nothing is built or run by this packet.
# If no authorized read/report surface exists at run time ⇒ HOLD_NO_EXEC_SURFACE (never PASS).
11. Carry-forward caveats re-checked against Phase-2 readiness
MCB-1 (RS5B no external Codex review): NON-BLOCKING for Phase-2 dry-run; RS5B stays SELF_REPORTED_DRAFT.
MCB-5 (NON_VECTOR_ROOT undesignated) : blocks Phase 3, NOT Phase-2 read/report dry-run (DR-15).
MCB-6 (no enacted laws-new baseline) : NON-BLOCKING; three-tier hierarchy meanwhile.
⇒ none of MCB-1/5/6 is a current Phase-2 dry-run blocker.
12. Numeric rollup (counted in 07)
dryrun_source_paths_unresolved = 0 (DR-3/DR-4 SAFE_DEFAULT_SELECTED)
dryrun_output_paths_unresolved = 0 (DR-5 SAFE_DEFAULT_SELECTED)
dryrun_permissions_unresolved = 0 (DR-9/DR-10/DR-11 resolved; deny-by-default)
dryrun_stop_states_unresolved = 0 (§5 enumerated)
dryrun_owner_decision_gaps = 0 (the only remaining owner decisions are the EXPECTED gates GATE-1/GATE-2; 0 are unclassified/undecidable)
dryrun_required_inputs_unclassified = 0
dryrun_required_permissions_unclassified= 0
dryrun_phase2_blockers_other_than_owner_authorization = 0
⇒ dry-run launch readiness COMPLETE. The only remaining items are the two expected gates (Codex confirmation + Owner Phase-2 open), which are gates by design, not design gaps. If any count above were nonzero, the verdict would drop to RS_TKT_1_PATCH1B_HOLD_DRYRUN_READINESS_INCOMPLETE.