KB-7880

RS-TKT-1 (Phase 1) · 15 Future Construction Blueprint — Non-Runtime Constraints

4 min read Revision 1
tool-kiem-thulegolaws-newrs-tkt-1phase1-designfuture-construction-blueprintnon-runtime-constraintsnon-executable2026-06-22

RS-TKT-1 (Phase 1) · 15 — Future Construction Blueprint: Non-Runtime Constraints

NON_EXECUTABLE_DESIGN_EXAMPLE
FUTURE_CONSTRUCTION_BLUEPRINT_ONLY
NOT_IMPLEMENTED
NOT_AUTHORIZED_FOR_RUNTIME

Lane: RS-TKT-1 — Phase 1 TKT Base Design Package (design-only) Date: 2026-06-22 Gate: REGISTRATION_HOLD · REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED = NO · 0 runtime mutations Authority: NON_AUTHORITY · may_gate=false · decision_effect=NONE

The complete list of forbidden runtime behaviors that bind Phase 1 and Phase 2 planning. These constraints are inherited by every construction-blueprint file (0914) and every Base design file (0108).


1. Forbidden in Phase 1 (absolute)

No .py · no .sh · no actual CLI · no actual runner · no actual validator · no actual registrar.
No DOT runtime · no handler · no Owner/scope/APR/register_dot.
No PG mutation · no Directus mutation · no registry/system_issues mutation.
No production command · no runtime execution · no subject-under-test execution.
No semantic Text-as-Code PASS · no implementation PASS · no runtime PASS · no production PASS.
No registration movement. REGISTRATION_HOLD stays active. REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED = NO.

2. Forbidden in Phase 2 planning (carried forward)

Phase 2 (MVP read/report inspector) — even when later authorized — MUST NOT:
  - execute the subject under test (that is Phase 4 + a Call Contract);
  - mutate PG / Directus / registry / system_issues;
  - gate, seal, or clear REGISTRATION_HOLD; set CAN_PROCEED=YES;
  - create Owner/scope/APR/register_dot;
  - claim a semantic / IU / release / implementation / runtime / production PASS.
Phase 2 is read/report-only and runs L0–L3 over INERT fixtures; it stops at HOLD_NO_EXEC_SURFACE
  until the Owner authorizes a deny-by-default execution surface.

3. The runtime-surface stop rule (PATCH1 P4)

If any design subpart would require runtime execution to be specified, that subpart STOPS at:
  HOLD_RUNTIME_SURFACE_REQUIRED
and the rest of the design continues. This is the smuggling-prevention rule: a runtime execution verifier
cannot appear inside Base because L1 fails closed to HOLD the moment subject-under-test runtime is required.

4. Stop-state vocabulary (paper — which stop belongs to which phase)

HOLD_RUNTIME_SURFACE_REQUIRED  — L1 cannot verify an inert packet without SUT runtime (→ Phase 4).
HOLD_OUTPUT_SURFACE_UNAVAILABLE — fail-closed detector cannot see the full scan surface (04).
HOLD_NO_EXEC_SURFACE           — Phase 2 has no authorized execution surface yet.
HOLD_NO_CALL_CONTRACT          — Phase 4 has no approved Call Contract yet.
HOLD_NVSZ_ROOT_UNDESIGNATED    — Phase 3 has no owner/operator-designated root (MCB-5).

5. Cross-phase invariants (from RS-TKT-0A 07, binding)

1. No phase clears REGISTRATION_HOLD — only a separate, explicitly authorized Owner decision can.
2. Engineering PASS is never upgraded to authority/runtime/registration/production PASS.
3. No mega-X — every output is a LEGO brick (born/tested/changed/rolled-back separately).
4. Silent caps forbidden — any sampling/top-N/no-retry bound must be logged; "we checked everything" must be true.
5. Default = HOLD — ambiguity stops at a HOLD stop-state, never a PASS.

6. The construction-vs-construction-blueprint wall

A construction blueprint (09–14) describes how to build. It is NOT building.
Designing the future tool layout is allowed. Building the tool is NOT.
No file in this package may contain an executable code block that could be copy-run as implementation.
Every future-interface example is labeled NON_EXECUTABLE_DESIGN_EXAMPLE / FUTURE_CONSTRUCTION_BLUEPRINT_ONLY / NOT_IMPLEMENTED / NOT_AUTHORIZED_FOR_RUNTIME.

Violation of any item here is a Phase-1 REJECT (REJECT_RUNTIME_DRIFT / REJECT_AUTHORITY_OVERCLAIM / REJECT_MEGA_SYSTEM_DRIFT), checked in 18/19.

Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/laws-new/tool-kiem-thu-lego/phase1-design/15-future-construction-blueprint-non-runtime-constraints-2026-06-22.md