Incomex AI Portal
KB-2D37

RS-TKT-0A-PATCH1 · 00 Codex Blocker Closure Map

7 min read Revision 1
tool-kiem-thulegolaws-newrs-tkt-0a-patch1codex-blocker-closurenon-authorizing2026-06-21

RS-TKT-0A-PATCH1 · 00 — Codex Blocker Closure Map

Lane: RS-TKT-0A-PATCH1 — close Codex blockers against RS-TKT-0A Path: knowledge/dev/laws-new/tool-kiem-thu-lego/patch1/00-codex-blocker-closure-map-2026-06-21.md Date: 2026-06-21 Verdict (rollup): RS_TKT_0A_PATCH1_READY_FOR_GPT_REVIEW (see 08-final-patch1-report-…) Gate: REGISTRATION_HOLD · REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED = NO · 0 runtime mutations (KB design-doc writes only) Authority: NON_AUTHORITY · may_gate=false · decision_effect=NONE · survey/design-patch only

0. What this patch is

Codex verdict on RS-TKT-0A was NEED_RS_TKT_0A_PATCH1 (knowledge/current-state/reports/codex-review-rs-tkt-0a-tool-kiem-thu-lego-survey-conversion-plan-2026-06-21.md, rev 1, read in full). PATCH1 is a narrow additive correction that closes exactly the seven required corrections P1–P7. It opens no new scope, opens no Phase 1, builds no tool, and mutates nothing runtime/production/registration. REGISTRATION_HOLD stays active; CAN_PROCEED = NO stays.

1. Codex findings being closed

Codex listed 4 blockers before Phase 1 and 5 carry-forward caveats:

  • Blockers: (1) bad-output detector treats nonzero exit as erasing emitted dangerous output [P1]; (2) TKT-L3-GOVERNANCE is multi-concern [P2]; (3) DRAFT laws-new sources mislabeled as binding authority [P3]; (4) L1/Phase-4 execution boundary ambiguous [P4].
  • Caveats: MCB-1 (RS5B no external Codex review) → [P6]; MCB-2 (two NVSZ taxonomies) + MCB-3 (ledger filename) → [P5]; MCB-5 (no NVSZ root) blocks Phase 3 not Phase 1 → recorded in [P5]; MCB-6 (no single enacted laws-new architecture doc) → [P3].
  • Codex also required [P7] dependency/output consistency (L2 depends on L0+L1; consistent N/A; aggregate ≠ authority/gating).

Codex accepted: authority boundary strong; NVSZ safe to retain (not REJECT_NVSZ_UNSAFE); no runtime authority overclaim (so PATCH1, not REJECT_AUTHORITY_OVERCLAIM). Runtime non-mutation accepted only as package attestation, not live Codex proof.

2. Closure map (P1–P7)

Codex item Severity Patch doc Status (design-level) Closes
P1 fail-open bad-output contract BLOCKER 01-fail-closed-forbidden-output-contract-patch CLOSED conjunctive invalid_input_safe; structured event/artifact detection; BAD-FC-001..005; corrected self-check
P2 split L3 into one-concern bricks BLOCKER 02-l3-lego-boundary-split-patch CLOSED 4 bricks (AUTHORITY-FIREWALL / CLAIM-AUDIT / IDENTITY / NVSZ) + aggregate
P3 correct source authority labels BLOCKER 03-source-authority-status-hierarchy-patch CLOSED (MCB-6 stays open) Tier-1/2/3 hierarchy; "controlling design inputs," not "binding enacted law"
P4 L1 vs Phase-4 execution boundary BLOCKER 04-l1-vs-phase4-execution-boundary-patch CLOSED L1 = recipe-on-inert-fixtures only; HOLD_RUNTIME_SURFACE_REQUIRED
P5 NVSZ deterministic identifiers caveat→required 05-nvsz-taxonomy-and-ledger-normalization-patch CLOSED (MCB-2/3 close pre-Phase-1; MCB-5 → Phase 3) ESCROW_E*/ROOT_E* namespaces; canonical hash_manifest.sha256; legacy normalize-before-pin
P6 RS5A/RS5B provenance split caveat→required 06-rs5a-rs5b-profile-provenance-split-patch CLOSED CODEX_CAUGHT_RS5A vs SELF_REPORTED_RS5B_DRAFT; per-rule provenance metadata
P7 dependency/output consistency required 07-level-dependency-and-output-consistency-patch CLOSED L0→L1→L2→L3 chain; consistent N/A; 5 separated status fields

3. No-overwrite discipline (how PATCH1 corrects without editing prior files)

Consistent with the laws-new RS-patch convention (each patch is additive; prior files stay at revision 1 for audit) and with RS-TKT-0A's own TKT-RS-PKG-004 (no overwrite of a prior package), no prior numbered deliverable (00–08) was edited. All nine remain revision 1. PATCH1 corrects by additive supersession clauses. The only existing file touched is the navigation index.md (additive PATCH1 pointer appended; navigation index, not a sealed packet artifact).

Supersession table (prior clause → superseding patch doc)

Prior file · clause Superseded by Effect
04 §0 global "Detector-correctness rule: a PASS/seal/cert token counts as emitted only when the producing process exits 0"; echoed in 04 TKT-L2-FAIL-CLOSED, 06 global, 08 §8a-5 / §8b-Q1 patch1/01 exit==0 is necessary not sufficient; forbidden token/artifact = FAIL regardless of exit (conjunctive)
04 §A TKT-L3-GOVERNANCE single block; 03 §3 table row L3; 06 Group references to L3 patch1/02 L3 = aggregate of 4 one-concern bricks
02 §0/§1 "laws-new SSOT … binding"; 00 "SSOT (binding)"; 08 §10 Q1 "current and binding" patch1/03 DRAFT = "controlling design inputs within the laws-new planning workspace, subject to Owner/Codex acceptance"
03 §3 "clean-room rerun"; 04 TKT-L1-PACKET "clean-room reconstruct … rerun"; 07 Phase 2/4 boundary patch1/04 L1 runs only the TKT reconstruction/verifier recipe on inert packet fixtures; subject-under-test runtime ⇒ Phase 4
05 §1.2 bare numeric escrow taxonomy; 05 §2 "accept either and warn"; MCB-3 handling patch1/05 namespaced exit codes; one canonical ledger filename; normalize-before-pin
06 mixed RS5A/RS5B profile; generic "RS-series" labeling of 84/86 + Q-order patch1/06 provenance split; RS5A-specific not generic
04 TKT-L2-FAIL-CLOSED "dependencies: TKT-L0-FILE"; 03 level model dependency; 08 status semantics patch1/07 L2 depends on L0 and L1; consistent N/A; aggregate ≠ authority

4. Scope guard (what PATCH1 does NOT do)

Does not open Phase 1; does not build runtime/Python/shell/DOT; does not create validator/registrar/Owner/scope/APR/register_dot; does not mutate PG/Directus/registry/system_issues; does not clear REGISTRATION_HOLD; does not set CAN_PROCEED=YES; does not claim semantic Text-as-Code / implementation / runtime / production PASS; does not reopen the 433-doc survey; adds no scope beyond P1–P7.

5. Next step

GPT review of PATCH1 → one independent read-only Codex re-review. On acceptance, the only authorized next step is Open Phase 1 — TKT Base design package (design-only), still under REGISTRATION_HOLD.