KB-5896
RS5B-CLOSEOUT 01 — Source Register & Codex Acceptance Reconstruction — 2026-06-21
10 min read Revision 1
rs5b-closeoutsource-registercodex-acceptancedirect-readregistration-hold2026-06-21
RS5B-CLOSEOUT 01 — Source Register & Codex Acceptance Reconstruction — 2026-06-21
Evidence tier: AgentData KB direct read. No chat summary, local prose, memory, or unread report was used as proof. Every source below was read complete (truncated=false) via mcp__agent-data__batch_read (full=true); the three Codex reports were read directly in the main process, and the RS5B/PATCH1/PATCH2 bodies were read in full via dedicated direct-read passes whose per-file metadata is recorded verbatim from the AgentData JSON.
1. Source register — Codex official reviews (controlling)
| Path | Revision | content_length | truncated | What it proves |
|---|---|---|---|---|
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/codex/codex-review-rs5a-patch4-total-quorum-precedence-and-g02-domain-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 12672 | false | ACCEPT_RS5A_PATCH4; REGISTRATION_HOLD; REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED = NO; single next step = RS5B (non-mutating). |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/codex/codex-review-rs5b-patch1-effect-authorization-binding-correction-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 9896 | false | NEED_RS5B_PATCH2; direction fixed; R1 operation-hardcode + R2 BI-E1/BI-E6 overlap residuals remain; HOLD retained. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/codex/codex-review-rs5b-patch2-canonical-operation-and-bi-domain-separation-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 10437 | false | STATUS: PASS_WITH_CAVEATS; ACCEPT_RS5B_PATCH2; stop RS5B_PATCH2_ACCEPTED_CONTRACT_ONLY_REGISTRATION_HOLD; HOLD retained; 5 caveats. |
2. Source register — RS5B original package
| Path | Revision | content_length | truncated | What it proves |
|---|---|---|---|---|
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/macro-rs5b-g2-owner-execution-authorization-design-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 6489 | false | RS5B rollup: verdict RS5B_READY_FOR_GPT_REVIEW (not forced); D-as-design on E-as-runtime; 0 runtime mutations. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b/01-source-register-and-current-state-reconstruction-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 10770 | false | LIVE current-state: ownership=0; 6 scopes (no registration-authority scope); registry=9; 14 apr_action_types, no register_dot; assign_governance_owner unimplemented. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b/02-g2-owner-of-record-bootstrap-problem-statement-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 7102 | false | Bootstrap circularity; Constitution v4.6.3 + Chairman as only non-circular first-authority; design-solved ≠ runtime-resolved. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b/03-authority-chain-candidate-models-and-rejection-matrix-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 8045 | false | Models A/B/C rejected; D founding-act PREFERRED (design-only); E runtime-HOLD; chosen posture D-as-design on E-as-runtime. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b/04-preferred-non-mutating-execution-design-runbook-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 7153 | false | Non-mutating runbook; W1–W4 all [GATE]; replace-not-wrap; LEGO_BOUNDARY_HELD; must-not-inherit edges. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b/05-authorization-packet-requirements-before-any-write-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 6770 | false | 13-element authorization packet, conjunctive; item 13 = Chairman, last/unconditional; necessary-not-sufficient. Carries the original item-5 "kept out of the authorization binding" wording later superseded. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b/06-fail-closed-adversarial-self-check-and-bad-inputs-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 10955 | false | BI01–BI10 adversarial probes + 2 self-traps; all fail-closed; ADVERSARIAL_SELF_CHECK_PASSED_NO_FAIL_OPEN. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b/07-rs5b-decision-packet-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 8058 | false | RS5B decision packet; engineering/design PASS only; 24 must-not-do held; LEGO_BOUNDARY_HELD. |
3. Source register — RS5B-PATCH1 (read in full)
| Path | Revision | content_length | truncated | What it proves |
|---|---|---|---|---|
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b-patch1/02-corrected-effect-identity-and-authorization-binding-contract-2026-06-21.md |
4 | 7366 | false | Real separation = authority-OUT-OF-effect_identity (pure), NOT effect-out-of-binding; authorization_binding_digest MUST INCLUDE effect_identity; new rejects AUTHORIZATION_BINDING_MISSING_EFFECT, EFFECT_IDENTITY_IMPURE. (Still carried literal operation="register_dot" — superseded by PATCH2.) |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b-patch1/03-rs5b-document-impact-map-and-superseded-wording-2026-06-21.md |
5 | 4758 | false | One direct unsafe occurrence: RS5B-05 item-5 "kept out of the authorization binding (separation)" → SUPERSEDED_BY_RS5B_PATCH1. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b-patch1/05-rs5b-patch1-decision-packet-2026-06-21.md |
3 | 4500 | false | RS5B_PATCH1_READY_FOR_GPT_REVIEW (not forced); HOLD; 0 runtime mutations; RS4A-PATCH2-02 found & read full. |
4. Source register — RS5B-PATCH2 (read in full)
| Path | Revision | content_length | truncated | What it proves |
|---|---|---|---|---|
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b-patch2/02-canonical-operation-effect-identity-correction-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 9308 | false | General formula uses canonical_operation (NOT hardcoded); register_dot = one specialization; founding/scope MUST NOT = register_dot; authority change ≠ new effect; vocabulary absent ⇒ CANONICAL_OPERATION_VOCABULARY_REQUIRED_NOT_PRESENT; OP-BI-1..4. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b-patch2/03-bi-e1-bi-e6-domain-separation-and-oracle-totality-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 7758 | false | Discriminator P = (effect_identity ∈ authorization_binding_digest input schema); BI-E6 Layer-1 shape first, BI-E1 Layer-2 only-if-L1-passed; precedence MISSING_EFFECT < NOT_BOUND; oracle total over declared classifier set; BINDING_CHECK_PASS necessary-not-sufficient. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b-patch2/04-impact-map-and-superseded-wording-2026-06-21.md |
1 | 5858 | false | PATCH1-02 general operation="register_dot" SUPERSEDED by canonical_operation; old overlapping BI-E1/BI-E6 SUPERSEDED by layered classifier; field set / RS4A-PATCH2-02 / RS5A-PATCH4 / models / 13-element packet NOT reopened. |
knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b-patch2/06-rs5b-patch2-decision-packet-2026-06-21.md |
2 | 5608 | false | RS5B_PATCH2_READY_FOR_GPT_REVIEW (not forced); HOLD; 0 runtime mutations. Revision 2 — the file the PATCH2 rollup's "all revision 1" sentence is inaccurate about (caveat C1). |
5. Codex acceptance reconstruction (verbatim controlling states)
5.1 RS5A-PATCH4 (upstream gate carried in)
STATUS: ACCEPTED_WITH_REGISTRATION_HOLD·REVIEW VERDICT: ACCEPT_RS5A_PATCH4·Stop state: RS5A_PATCH4_ACCEPTED.REGISTRATION_HOLD·REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED = NO.- "The only next step is RS5B — G2 Owner-of-record execution-design / authorization-design," non-mutating, bootstrap-solving, separately-authorized before any write.
- Evidence tier: "AgentData KB contract-only review. NO_CODEX_LIVE_READ."
5.2 RS5B-PATCH1 (HOLD — needs PATCH2)
STATUS: HOLD·REVIEW VERDICT: NEED_RS5B_PATCH2·Stop state: RS5B_PATCH1_EFFECT_BINDING_CORRECTION_INCOMPLETE.- §4 NEEDS_PATCH: PATCH1-02 still defined
operation = "register_dot"in the general founding formula → can bind a founding authorization to the wrong business act (R1). - §7 NEEDS_PATCH: BI-E1 and BI-E6 still overlap at the input-predicate level → "two contract-compliant outcomes despite the 'one canonical rejection' claim" (R2).
- Accepted: binding direction fixed; digest includes pure effect + required envelope refs; same approval cannot authorize a different bound effect; same effect + changed authority cannot mint a second registration.
REGISTRATION_HOLD·REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED = NO.
5.3 RS5B-PATCH2 (ACCEPT, contract-only, with caveats)
STATUS: PASS_WITH_CAVEATS·REVIEW VERDICT: ACCEPT_RS5B_PATCH2·Stop state: RS5B_PATCH2_ACCEPTED_CONTRACT_ONLY_REGISTRATION_HOLD.- Evidence tier (verbatim): "AgentData KB contract-only review · NO_CODEX_LIVE_READ · NO_RUNTIME_VERIFICATION."
- §3 R1 PASS: general formula uses
canonical_operation;register_dotonly the specialization; founding/scope prohibited fromregister_dot; authority-only change does not mint a new effect; vocabulary absence ⇒CANONICAL_OPERATION_VOCABULARY_REQUIRED_NOT_PRESENT(no default, no invented row, no PASS). - §4 R2 PASS: discriminator
P; ¬P→BI-E6 only (AUTHORIZATION_BINDING_MISSING_EFFECT, stop); P→Layer-2 BI-E1 (APPROVAL_NOT_BOUND_TO_EFFECT_IDENTITY); precedenceAUTHORIZATION_BINDING_MISSING_EFFECT < APPROVAL_NOT_BOUND_TO_EFFECT_IDENTITY; BI-E1/BI-E4 safely share NOT_BOUND;BINDING_CHECK_PASSnecessary-not-sufficient. - §9 Rejected/overclaimed (the five caveats): (1) rollup "All revision 1" rejected as metadata fact — PATCH2-06 is revision 2; (2) design fixtures/pseudocode rejected as runtime proof; (3) "every input" totality rejected as unrestricted — accepted only over the declared classifier domain; (4) historical zero-mutation attestations not independently verified (no live runtime read); (5) P2 / Chairman execution / vocabulary creation / owner-scope creation / implementation / registration / activation NOT authorized.
REGISTRATION_HOLD·REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED = NO.
6. Additivity proof
Before this package, direct list_documents on knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/rs5b-closeout-p2-entry/ returned count=0, and the macro-rollup path returned count=0. This package is therefore strictly additive: it overwrites no RS5B, PATCH1, PATCH2, or Codex document. All cited source files retain their listed revisions; the consolidation in file 02 is a controlling reading, not a mutation of any original.