RS5A Index — G2 Owner-of-record Decision — 2026-06-21
RS5A Index — G2 Owner-of-record Decision — 2026-06-21
Verdict: G2_OWNER_DECISION_READY_FOR_CODEX_REVIEW · Gate: REGISTRATION_HOLD · REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED=NO · 0 mutations.
Macro: RS5A — G2 Owner-of-record decision dossier opened after Codex ACCEPT_RS4A_PATCH2. Design-only; read-only live reconstruction. Not execution.
1. File inventory + readback verification
Readback method: each file's upload_document returned status=created, revision=1; the set was re-listed via list_documents(rs5a/) returning count=13, truncated=false (index added as 14th in rs5a/); rollup created in reports/. No file missing ⇒ no HOLD-on-missing.
| # | file (reports/rs5a/ unless noted) | revision | readback |
|---|---|---|---|
| idx | rs5a-index-g2-owner-of-record-decision (this file) |
1 | created |
| 01 | 01-codex-rs4a-acceptance-and-caveat-register |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 02 | 02-current-authority-state-fresh-reconstruction (LIVE) |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 03 | 03-owner-of-record-concept-model |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 04 | 04-object-scope-taxonomy-and-boundaries |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 05 | 05-candidate-owner-decision-matrix |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 06 | 06-register-dot-action-contract-v1 |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 07 | 07-authority-envelope-v1-for-authorization-binding |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 08 | 08-quorum-and-approval-proof-obligations |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 09 | 09-negative-authority-test-suite-80-cases (84 cases) |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 10 | 10-owner-decision-options-and-recommendation |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 11 | 11-lego-boundary-and-non-mega-coupling-check |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 12 | 12-g2-decision-packet |
1 | list-confirmed |
| cdx | codex-review-packet-rs5a-g2-owner-of-record-decision |
1 | list-confirmed |
| roll | reports/macro-rs5a-g2-owner-of-record-decision (rollup) |
1 | created |
15 files total (≥15 required).
2. Correction/extension map (what RS5A adds, what it does NOT touch)
| layer | RS5A action |
|---|---|
| RS4A/PATCH1/PATCH2 accepted contract | referenced, not reopened (effect-identity business-only, authz-binding-separated, U3, Phase-4 no-success-audit, PX2, count=111) |
| G2 deciding-authority blocker | dossier authored (concept, scopes, candidates, action, envelope, quorum, tests, options) |
| runtime substrate | 0 mutations (read-only) |
3. Headline results
- Authority state (LIVE):
governance_object_ownership=0; no registration-authority scope;register_dotabsent; quorum readable but effect-binding insufficient; owner-mint path fail-closed. - Owner candidate:
SURFACE_PROVEN(GOV-DOT/GOV-SIV/GOV-COUNCIL) ·NO_ACCOUNTABLE_HEAD_BOUND. register_dot:REQUIRED_NOT_PRESENT(contract v1 defined).- Authority envelope:
V1_DEFINED, authority out of U1. - Quorum:
SEMANTICS_READ+BINDING_INSUFFICIENT. - Negative tests: 84, defined-not-executed.
- Recommendation: Option B (split by scope cluster).
- Single next step: Codex reviews RS5A → Owner executes G2 designation.
4. Self-check (Mục tiêu 7)
Read Codex PATCH2 acceptance ✔ · kept REGISTRATION_HOLD ✔ · no Owner/APR/register_dot created ✔ · fresh-reconstructed authority surfaces (live) ✔ · distinguished Owner/caller/operator/validator/registrar ✔ · evaluated dot_tools.owner free-text ✔ · evaluated Directus users/roles ✔ · checked governance_object_ownership ✔ · checked apr_action_types ✔ · read quorum functions ✔ · scope taxonomy ✔ · candidate matrix ✔ · register_dot action contract ✔ · authority envelope v1 ✔ · proof obligations ✔ · ≥80 negative tests (84) ✔ · options + recommendation ✔ · no-mega proof ✔ · authority not in U1 ✔ · no implementation/mutation ✔ · readback verified ✔ · Codex packet ✔.