RS5A-PATCH1 Index — Prerequisite/Sequencing Correction — 2026-06-21
RS5A-PATCH1 Index — Prerequisite/Sequencing Correction — 2026-06-21
Verdict: RS5A_PATCH1_READY_FOR_CODEX_REVIEW (not forced) · Gate: REGISTRATION_HOLD · REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED=NO · 0 mutations.
Macro: RS5A-PATCH1 — scoped correction addendum after Codex NEED_RS5A_PATCH1. Does NOT overwrite RS5A. Does NOT reopen accepted RS4A/PATCH1/PATCH2 identity semantics.
1. File inventory + readback
Readback: each file's upload_document returned status=created, revision=1; re-listed via list_documents(rs5a-patch1/) → count=8, truncated=false (index added as 9th); rollup created in reports/. No file missing ⇒ no HOLD-on-missing.
| # | file (reports/rs5a-patch1/ unless noted) | revision | readback |
|---|---|---|---|
| idx | rs5a-patch1-index-prerequisite-sequencing-correction (this file) |
1 | created |
| 01 | 01-codex-rs5a-hold-closure-map |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 02 | 02-hard-prerequisite-graph-before-register-dot |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 03 | 03-bootstrap-authority-and-next-step-correction |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 04 | 04-gov-council-approval-quorum-edge |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 05 | 05-governed-registrar-replacement-handler-clarification |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 06 | 06-negative-test-oracle-corrections |
1 | list-confirmed |
| 07 | 07-rs5a-patch1-decision-packet |
1 | list-confirmed |
| cdx | codex-review-packet-rs5a-patch1-prerequisite-sequencing-correction |
1 | list-confirmed |
| roll | reports/macro-rs5a-patch1-prerequisite-sequencing-correction (rollup) |
1 | created |
10 files total (10 required).
2. Residual closure (Codex §13 R1–R5 + §11 R6)
| residual | status | file |
|---|---|---|
| R1 replay/audit "after registration" | CLOSED_FAIL_CLOSED |
02 |
| R2 "Owner executes on accept" | CLOSED |
03 |
| R3 GOV-COUNCIL edge | CLOSED (10th scope) |
04 |
| R4 handler ambiguity | CLOSED (replace-not-wrap) |
05 |
| R5 test oracles | CLOSED (D07/H03/H07/I03/G02/G08) |
06 |
| R6 implicit coupling | CLOSED |
02 §4 |
No residual STILL_OPEN_BY_DESIGN blocks review.
3. Headline corrections
- Prerequisite graph: 4 phases P0→P3; 11 hard runtime prerequisites; replay/audit design-after-decision but exist-and-pass before runtime registration — never after.
- Bootstrap: next step = RS5B execution-design (non-mutating);
BOOTSTRAP_AUTHORITY_UNRESOLVEDacknowledged; no execute-on-accept. - GOV-COUNCIL: explicit 10th scope
DOT_APPROVAL_QUORUM_AUTHORITY+ identity-binding; no broad-approval inheritance. - Handler:
DOT_REGISTER_GOVERNED_REPLACEMENT, replacement not wrapper. - Oracles: 6 codes corrected; replay vs idempotency split.
4. Self-check (Mục tiêu 7)
read Codex RS5A HOLD ✔ · no reopen of RS4A/PATCH2 identity semantics ✔ · prerequisite graph corrected ✔ · forbade replay/audit after runtime registration ✔ · bootstrap wording corrected ✔ · no "Owner executes on accept" ✔ · GOV-COUNCIL edge resolved ✔ · replacement handler clarified ✔ · D07 ✔ · H03 ✔ · H07 ✔ · I03 ✔ · G02/G08 ✔ · no implementation/mutation ✔ · REGISTRATION_HOLD kept ✔ · Codex packet ✔ · readback verified ✔.
5. Next step
Codex reviews RS5A-PATCH1 only → on accept, proceed to RS5B (G2 Owner-of-record execution-design / authorization-design, non-mutating). Residual ⇒ RS5A-PATCH2.