READY-TO-ASSEMBLE-LEGO1 13 — Final Readiness Decision — 2026-06-22
READY-TO-ASSEMBLE-LEGO1 13 — Final Readiness Decision — 2026-06-22
VERDICT: READY_TO_ASSEMBLE_LEGO1_PACKAGE (not forced).
Chosen LEGO #1: C1 — canonical_operation vocabulary contract carrier.
Gate: REGISTRATION_HOLD · REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED = NO · 0 runtime mutations · P2 CLOSED · NOT_OPENED · NOT_AUTHORIZED · no named lane opened · no Chairman authorization asserted.
1. The 17 readiness criteria (instruction §3.13)
| # | Criterion | Status | Where |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | chosen carrier specific + justified | ✔ C1 | file 03 |
| 2 | read-only inventory complete | ✔ | file 02 |
| 3 | build plan complete | ✔ | file 06 |
| 4 | dependency map complete | ✔ (in=0, out=E1) | file 05 |
| 5 | carrier boundary complete | ✔ | file 04 |
| 6 | test matrix complete | ✔ (valid/invalid/adversarial/regression) | file 07 |
| 7 | rollback plan complete | ✔ (RBP-0..10) | file 08 |
| 8 | preflight plan complete | ✔ | file 09 |
| 9 | evidence plan complete | ✔ | file 10 |
| 10 | Gate B packet complete | ✔ | file 11 |
| 11 | Chairman authorization template complete | ✔ (template, not asserted) | file 11 §4 |
| 12 | adversarial self-review passes | ✔ A1–A25 | file 12 |
| 13 | no preparation gap remains | ✔ (residuals authority/execution only) | §2 |
| 14 | no runtime/write executed | ✔ 0 mutations | file 02 §8; file 06 §9 |
| 15 | no authority overclaimed | ✔ | file 11 §5; file 12 §3 |
| 16 | REGISTRATION_HOLD remains active | ✔ | all files |
| 17 | P2/named lane remains closed | ✔ | file 11 §3 |
All 17 true ⇒ READY is honestly reachable.
2. Preparation-gap check (the decisive test)
A preparation gap would force READY_TO_ASSEMBLE_LEGO1_REJECT_PREPARATION_GAP_REMAINS. Classifying every residual (instruction §5):
| Residual | Classification | Preparation gap? |
|---|---|---|
| Gate A / Gate B acceptance | execution/authority | No — review step, not preparation |
| Exact-scoped Chairman token | AUTHORITY_MISSING_ONLY |
No — template + exact later check defined (file 09 PF5, file 11 §4) |
| Runtime/write authorization | RUNTIME_ACCESS_MISSING_ONLY |
No — exact plan/commands/preflight defined (files 06/09) |
| Execution window | execution | No |
canonical_operation value set |
execution (governed per-value) | No — admission contract prepared; values admitted in build (file 12 §2) |
No PREPARATION_INPUT_MISSING, SOURCE_READ_FAILED, or DISCOVERY_FAILED remains. The only remaining work is authority/execution. ⇒ no preparation gap.
3. Why this verdict (not another)
- Not
…_HOLD_CODEX_MODE_MISSING: posture recorded (file 01 §0). - Not
…_HOLD_SOURCE_READ_FAILED: controlling Codex accept + packages read directly (file 01). - Not
…_HOLD_REPO_DISCOVERY_FAILED: live read-only inventory complete (file 02). - Not
…_HOLD_NO_SAFE_CARRIER: C1 is safe and chosen (file 03). - Not
…_HOLD_CARRIER_BOUNDARY_UNCLEAR: four boundaries defined (file 04). - Not
…_HOLD_DEPENDENCY_MAP_INCOMPLETE: in/out edges proven (file 05). - Not
…_HOLD_BUILD_PLAN_INCOMPLETE: steps/surfaces/commands defined, write-labelled (file 06). - Not
…_HOLD_TEST_MATRIX_INCOMPLETE: matrix fail-closed (file 07). - Not
…_HOLD_ROLLBACK_PLAN_INCOMPLETE: RBP-0..10 mapped (file 08). - Not
…_HOLD_PREFLIGHT_PLAN_INCOMPLETE: PF1–PF9 + rerun rule (file 09). - Not
…_HOLD_EVIDENCE_PLAN_INCOMPLETE: artifacts + tiers + readback (file 10). - Not
…_HOLD_GATE_B_PACKET_INCOMPLETE: Gate B inputs + Chairman template (file 11). - Not
…_HOLD_ADVERSARIAL_SELF_REVIEW_FAILED: A1–A25 pass (file 12). - Not
…_REJECT_SCOPE_DRIFT: only LEGO-1 preparation authored; Job A / I1–I10 not reopened. - Not
…_REJECT_RUNTIME_MUTATION: 0 mutations. - Not
…_REJECT_MEGA_REGISTRY: C1 is one isolated LEGO (file 04 §5). - Not
…_REJECT_AUTHORITY_OVERCLAIM: no authority/Chairman/P2 asserted. - Not
…_REJECT_P2_OPENED_EARLY: P2 closed; no named lane opened. - Not
…_REJECT_PREPARATION_GAP_REMAINS: no preparation gap (§2).
The verdict is not forced: had any criterion failed, the corresponding HOLD/REJECT above would have been emitted.
4. Carried blockers (UNCHANGED, none resolved, none added)
G2–G7, STATUS_DOMAIN_NOT_DB_ENFORCED, U3_PARTIAL_UNIQUE_SURFACE_ABSENT, OWNER_MINT_PATH_FAIL_CLOSED, QUORUM_EFFECT_BINDING_INSUFFICIENT, QUORUM_APPROVER_IDENTITY_UNVERIFIED, BOOTSTRAP_AUTHORITY_UNRESOLVED, CANONICAL_PRINCIPAL_SURFACE_REQUIRED_NOT_PRESENT. No new blocker. No new runtime reject code — the C1-specific labels (CANONICAL_OPERATION_VALUE_ABSENT, …_RETIRED_FOR_NEW_USE) are carrier-classifier labels for the future build, not runtime blockers, and resolve nothing now.
5. Single next step
Independent (GPT → Codex) review of this preparation package only. On accept, the prepared C1 plan is the input to a future Gate B evaluation; only a satisfied Gate B (per-carrier rollback proof + current live preflight + exact-scoped Chairman token + independent plan review + no mutation) may open the named C1 lane only and authorize the C1 build. Registration/activation/register_dot/P3 remain separate later gates. Residual ⇒ READY_TO_ASSEMBLE_LEGO1-PATCH1.
Default HOLD discipline retained: readiness-for-assembly ≠ assembly execution; engineering/contract PASS ≠ authority/runtime PASS; baseline ≠ P2-open; satisfied Gate B ≠ registration; review ≠ Chairman authorization; deletion ≠ rollback; validity ≠ presence; one input → one code.
6. Boundary attestation
This file records the decision at design level. It creates no carrier, writes no row, opens no P2/lane, executes no rollback, asserts no Chairman authorization, and clears no blocker. REGISTRATION_HOLD retained; REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED = NO; 0 runtime mutations.