KB-3B1D

READY-TO-ASSEMBLE-LEGO1-PATCH1 10 — [P2-1/P2-2] Truthful Blast-Radius & Overclaim Retraction — 2026-06-22

5 min read Revision 1
ready-to-assemble-lego1-patch1p2-1p2-2blast-radiusoperational-dependenciesoverclaim-retractionregistration-hold2026-06-22

READY-TO-ASSEMBLE-LEGO1-PATCH1 10 — [P2-1/P2-2] Truthful Blast-Radius & Overclaim Retraction — 2026-06-22

Closes Codex P2-1 and P2-2. Gate: REGISTRATION_HOLD · CAN_PROCEED = NO · 0 runtime mutations.


1. [P2-1] Operational dependency map (beyond the carrier graph)

"No incoming carrier edge (E1–E8)" is true but does not mean no build dependency. C1's build has these operational dependencies, each with an explicit join/preflight contract:

Operational dependency Why C1 depends on it Join / preflight contract
apr_action_types / process_axis_action_vocabulary (value source) provides R_C1 candidate values + provenance file 04 resolver; PF9
governance_build_authorization (authorization) gates the build; exact-scoped grant file 05 verifier; PF5
Directus metadata (directus_collections/directus_fields) + table_registry the collection is created here (DOT-only) file 02; PF1, PF-SCHEMA-DOT, Registry Wiring Rule
Dispatcher fn_process_agent_api_dispatch + paired DOT contract the only execution channel file 02; precond_endpoint_bound
Real-run gate set v_dotkg_realrun_preflight governs DRY_RUN→REAL_RUN file 07 PF7
dot_iu_runtime_lease (concurrency) single-execution guard file 05; PF-LEASE
Audit sink (governance_audit_log / governed handler) rollback/audit evidence file 06 S6; file 09
dot_config flips (dry_run_only, execute_enabled, real_run_enabled) enable REAL_RUN file 07 (BLOCK today)
President/owner authority (process_axis_action_vocabulary.requires_president; owner gate) canon-mutating admission requires president; owner gate present file 07 gate_dotkg_owner_present; carried …PRINCIPAL_SURFACE…

2. [P2-1] Truthful blast-radius model

Surface Blast radius Truthful statement
Existing C2 data zero proven orphan — C2 absent (file 02 §5) "No currently proven C2 data reference would be orphaned." (NOT "blast radius = 0")
Directus metadata non-zero a new collection writes directus_collections/directus_fields + table_registry
Audit sink non-zero birth + per-value admission write audit rows
Authorization non-zero one grant consumed
Config / gates non-zero (if flipped) REAL_RUN requires governed dot_config flips affecting the runtime posture
Future lookup contract non-zero once C2 is built, E1 becomes a live dependency on C1

Corrected claim: C1 has a bounded, non-zero operational blast radius confined to its own collection + Directus metadata + table_registry + audit + one authorization + (on REAL_RUN) governed config; it has zero proven orphan risk on existing C2 data because C2 is absent.

3. [P2-2] Overclaim retraction (superseded phrases)

Prior phrase Where Status Replacement
"blast radius = 0" / "blast radius of zero" base file 05 §3, file 06 §6 SUPERSEDED "no currently proven C2 data reference would be orphaned; bounded non-zero operational blast radius" (§2)
"structurally complete" (re governance_build_authorization) base file 02 §3.4, file 11 SUPERSEDED "carries the necessary columns; enforcement is the file-05 verifier contract, unproven until a grant is created+verified"
"read-only inventory complete" / "inventory complete" base file 02, file 13 SUPERSEDED "read-only inventory sufficient for C1 preparation; PF7 governed real-run preflight now included; live re-verification required at build"
"the only remaining work is authority/execution" base file 13 §2, rollup QUALIFIED "after PATCH1 closes P0/P1/P2, the remaining residuals are authority/execution plus the Gate-B governed review/curation act (manifest selection, config flips, owner/president, Chairman token) — all governance/execution, not missing design"

4. Honest residual classification (post-PATCH1)

Residual Class Preparation gap?
Gate-B governed manifest curation governance review act No — resolver + snapshot prepared (file 04)
Authorized schema DOT for C1 collection authority No — path specified; authorization is Gate-B (PF-SCHEMA-DOT)
dot_config real-run flips + owner/president present authority/execution No — governed by v_dotkg_realrun_preflight
Chairman exact-scoped grant authority No — verifier + template defined (file 05)
Execution window execution No

No PREPARATION_INPUT_MISSING remains. The honest claim is scoped, not absolute.

5. Boundary attestation

Design-only correction of claims; no mutation. REGISTRATION_HOLD retained; CAN_PROCEED = NO; 0 runtime mutations. Supersedes the four overclaim phrases above in the base package.

Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/ready-to-assemble-lego1-patch1/10-p2-truthful-blast-radius-and-overclaim-retraction-2026-06-22.md