KB-33EE
F2 — Information Unit / Smart Brick + Temp Store / Candidate — Read-only Execution Report
31 min read Revision 1
laws-newf2information-unitsmart-bricktemp-storecandidateiu-stagingexecution-reportread-onlynon-authorizing2026-06-16
F2 — Information Unit / Smart Brick + Temp Store / Candidate — Read-only Execution Report
Ngày: 2026-06-16 · Soạn: Claude Code CLI (read-only AgentData KB) · Track: knowledge/dev/laws-new/
Packet basis: f2-information-unit-temp-store-reuse-survey-packet.md rev1 (this run; internal gate §10 passed — see §1).
Control basis: technical-slice-framework.md rev56 (§6c D4/D5, §6.2/§6.3, §4, §5; S3 pin a2ab3582…889, len 117459).
Concept basis: de-bai-cai-tien.md rev33 (§II/§IV/§V/§VI Lego Protocol; S4 pin 6e921f0a…704, len 29088).
Catalog basis: cau-hoi-khi-tai-cau-truc.md rev82 (§2c/§2d, STG-/STG-REUSE-, CELL-/CONS-003; S5 pin 2da1a82…342, len 145449).
Evidence/gate basis: F1 execution report rev1 (PARTIAL) + reports/f1/f1-owner-decision-record-2026-06-16.md rev1 (F1 gate CLOSED) + F0 decision record rev1 + F0 exec report rev1.
Run authorization: GPT/Owner authorized the F2 Program Macro; this read-only execution ran only because the packet §10 internal gate passed (all 8 items GREEN). No Phase-1, no live DB/runtime, no implementation, no schema/registry/store creation, no canonical birth write, no CONS-003 / CELL- resolution, no cell_id materialization.
Layer: F2 = one layer above F1 in the §6c build order; sits below F3 (IO Contract + Formula + Assembly Machine / DOT).
0. STATUS (one line at top)
STATUS: PARTIAL — F2 read-only execution is complete and honest. All F2 candidate assets are classified into Q1/Q2/Q3 from current-pass KB evidence, the 3 Owner questions are answered, the brick boundary (Smart Brick = subject / temp-store = place; TEMP_ID inherited; canonical birth = F4) is held, and every forbidden action remained blocked. PARTIAL (not PASS) because every F2 substrate candidate is DOCUMENTARY_ONLY and the temp-store substrate (iu_staging_record / iu_staging_payload) is UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE (CONFLICT) = HOLD-1 (framework §4; Phase-1 read-only verify required), and the gating conflicts/risks (CONS-003, CELL-003/004/007, HOLD-1, HOLD-2, STG-012, STG-015, STG-REUSE-001/003, RISK-GC/CAP/BYPASS) remain Owner-/Phase-1-gated and are carried, not resolved. No forbidden action performed. Documentary ≠ live proof · Prior-session ≠ current proof · Engineering PASS ≠ Authority PASS · Reuse-now ≠ live-proven.
1. Status / boundary confirmation (incl. internal gate result)
Internal gate (packet §10) — result: ALL GREEN → execution authorized in-macro.
| # | Gate item | Result | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| G1 | Mandatory sources readable | ✅ GREEN | F1 report/packet, F0 decision/exec, framework rev56, de-bai rev33, catalog rev82, constitution rev44 (Đ0-B/Đ29), operating-rules rev51 — all read this pass |
| G2 | F1 gate closed first | ✅ GREEN | f1-owner-decision-record-2026-06-16.md rev1 accepts F1 |
| G3 | Every F2 asset classifiable honestly | ✅ GREEN | each Q1/Q2/Q3 row pinned to a KB source; no live proof invented |
| G4 | No live DB/runtime/Phase-1 needed | ✅ GREEN | classification is documentary-only; iu_staging_* untouched |
| G5 | No conflict resolution needed | ✅ GREEN | CONS-003 / CELL-003/004/007 carried, not resolved |
| G6 | No schema/design/implementation needed | ✅ GREEN | no cell_id materialization; no new registry/store/table; no DOT/checker |
| G7 | Boundary held | ✅ GREEN | brick = subject / temp-store = place; TEMP_ID inherited; no canonical birth |
| G8 | 3 Owner questions preserved | ✅ GREEN | Q1/Q2/Q3 answered in §2 |
Boundary confirmation:
- read-only only (KB read; no live DB/runtime): yes
- no live DB / Postgres / Directus / runtime / production touched: yes (
iu_staging_*untouched — HOLD-1; Phase-1 untouched) - F2 scope kept to Information Unit / Smart Brick + Temp Store / Candidate (brick = subject; temp-store = place): yes
TEMP_ID/ candidate identity inherited from F1 (no canonical birth /BIRTH_STAMPwritten): yes (F4 deferred)- no new Information Unit registry / temp-store table / packet store/ledger created: yes
cell_id/dot_roleNOT materialized; CONS-003 / CELL-003/004/007 NOT resolved (carried): yes- exactly one F2 execution report document created (this file): yes
In-scope performed: pinned the documentary state of each F2 candidate from KB sources (framework §4/§5/§6.2/§6.3/D4/D5, de-bai §II/§V/§VI, catalog STG-/STG-REUSE-/REUSE rows), classified each into Q1/Q2/Q3 with an evidence pin and a documentary-vs-live label, restated the brick/temp-store boundary, and surfaced the gating conflicts/risks as carried obligations.
2. Owner View — 3 câu hỏi reuse-first (control surface, simple)
Đọc riêng mục này là đủ để Owner/GPT biết F2 đã phân loại gì để dùng lại — không làm gì chạm hệ thống. Chi tiết kỹ thuật ở §3 trở xuống. Mục này KHÔNG ủy quyền bất cứ điều gì.
| Owner question | Answered? | Summary (from current-pass KB evidence) |
|---|---|---|
| Q1 — Cái gì đang có và (giả thuyết) dùng lại được? (reuse-now — documentary) | ✅ Yes | Concept Smart Brick / "Miếng thông tin" (de-bai §II.1/§VI; framework D4) = dùng lại làm chủ thể trung tâm của F2. TEMP_ID / candidate identity kế thừa từ F1 (minimal identity root, no canonical birth). iu_staging_record / iu_staging_payload = ứng viên documentary cho kho tạm/candidate + candidate packet ([GR] 26 cột / 11 cột, CASCADE, 10MiB, blob_ref — tất cả HOLD-1, CHƯA live-proven). metadata/jsonb + payload parts + content_hash = lưu packet bằng jsonb thay vì bảng mới. Candidate packet = view/projection (candidate_id+packet_hash), không store mới. IO Contract 5-field (nhận·trả·schema_min·fail·rollback). cell_id concept (read-only hypothesis). Reuse-first rule (§2c) + Nhóm 0 + F0 baseline/decisions. Trung thực: "reuse-now" = ứng viên tài liệu mang sang F3 — KHÔNG = đã chứng minh live. |
| Q2 — Cái gì cần sửa/kiểm chứng mới dùng lại được? (repair / verify-before-reuse) | ✅ Yes | iu_staging_* live schema/lifecycle/TTL/candidate_id/blob_ref chỉ documentary (UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE CONFLICT, addendum HOLD, Codex checkout ref 0) → cần Phase-1 read-only verify (Owner-gated, không làm ở F2) = HOLD-1. Cleanup scheduler (STG-012 BLOCKER) — ai gọi fn_iu_staging_cleanup? packet_hash coverage (STG-015 BLOCKER). Shared-store sufficiency (STG-REUSE-001 BLOCKER). blob_ref orphan/cap (RISK-GC/RISK-CAP). Cell placement chặn bởi CONS-003 + CELL-003/004/007. IO Contract examples = GAP. Scanner/report insufficiency chưa proven. Checkout/runtime sync chưa proven (CONS-005 caveat). |
| Q3 — Cái gì thật sự phải làm thêm (chỉ khi reuse không đủ)? (add-later — future Owner-gated) | ✅ Yes | Chỉ future Owner-gated, NO by default: Phase-1 read-only survey iu_staging_* (HOLD-1); temp-store/candidate wrapper nhẹ (chỉ khi reuse không đủ); candidate-packet view/binding (không store mới); metadata/schema changes (incl. cell_id) sau proof + Owner gate; KHÔNG Information Unit registry / temp-store table / packet ledger mới; KHÔNG canonical birth/promote (F4). Mỗi "add-new" phải chứng minh đủ 5 điều kiện no-new (catalog §2c). |
3. F2 asset classification table (consolidated — required format)
Mọi dòng substrate dưới là ứng viên documentary (framework §4 — DOCUMENTARY_ONLY;
iu_staging_*= UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE/CONFLICT, HOLD-1). Reuse verdict = mang sang F3 như giả thuyết tài liệu, không = live-proven.
| Asset | Evidence source | Currency | Classification | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Information Unit / Smart Brick concept | framework D4; de-bai §II.1/§VI | documentary (concept) | Q1 (concept reuse-now) | "viên gạch thông minh" central subject; minimal brick = input·output·IO·DOT·rollback·promote (de-bai §VI.1). Live IU lifecycle chưa proven. |
TEMP_ID / candidate identity (inherited F1) |
F1 report §7; de-bai §V.10; framework §6.2 | documentary (concept; F1 in-scope root) | Q1 (inherited) → Q2 (live home) | identity root the brick stands on; TEMP_ID_STAMP/candidate_id/workspace_id. Live home = iu_staging_* = HOLD-1. No canonical birth. |
iu_staging_record |
framework §4; catalog STG-001/003/006/007 | UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE (CONFLICT) / HOLD-1 | Q1 doc-candidate → Q2 (Phase-1 verify) | temp-store/candidate home; [GR] 26 cột, PK uuid; addendum HOLD; Codex checkout ref 0. No new table. |
iu_staging_payload |
framework §4; catalog STG-002/009 | UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE (CONFLICT) / HOLD-1 | Q1 doc-candidate → Q2 (Phase-1 verify) | candidate packet payload; [GR] 11 cột, CASCADE, 10MiB, blob_ref. RISK-GC/RISK-CAP. |
staging metadata jsonb + payload parts + content_hash |
catalog STG-008/009/010 (old survey) | documentary (prior-session) | Q1 doc-candidate → Q2 (live verify) | store candidate packet by metadata/jsonb; content_hash=sha256(payload parts), KHÔNG bao metadata. Kept documentary (framework §18 ca 13). |
| Candidate packet (view/projection) | de-bai §V.13; catalog STG-REUSE-002/003 | documentary (design rule) | Q1 (view logic) / Q3 (NO new store) | packet = view/binding on existing metadata (candidate_id+packet_hash), verdict-only checker; new store = BLOCKER-if-proposed. |
| IO Contract 5-field | framework §6b r1 / D6; de-bai §III.6/§VI.3 | DOCUMENTARY_ONLY | Q1 (boundary concept) → Q2 (examples GAP) | nhận·trả·schema_min·fail·rollback; not Module Contract First; slice examples chưa biết. |
fn_iu_cut_from_manifest |
framework D4 | documentary (~70% reusable) | Q1 doc-candidate → Q2 (wrapper) | reuse via wrapper hypothesis for IU cut. |
fn_iu_staging_create / fn_iu_staging_cleanup |
catalog STG-010/011; STG-REUSE-004/005 | documentary (old survey) | Q1 doc-candidate → Q2 (scheduler) | create binds content_hash; cleanup 3-pass + dry-run; scheduler unproven (STG-012). |
cell_id concept (inherited) |
framework §5 / §6.2; catalog CELL-REUSE-001/002 | DOCUMENTARY_ONLY (concept) | Q1 (concept) / Q2 (dimensions) / Q3 (materialize) | tầng×loài×kho×miền read-only model; CONS-003 + CELL-003/004/007 unresolved; materialization = Owner-gated schema. |
| F0 source baseline (12) + F0/F1 decisions | F0/F1 decision records | current-pass (KB rev) | Q1 (accepted reuse-now) | authority/evidence basis; CONS-004 precedence; CONS-005 KB-only. Covers KB, not runtime. |
BIRTH_STAMP / canonical birth boundary |
framework §6c D10; de-bai §V.5/§V.10 | documentary (boundary) | Not F2 (F4 output) | closes at promote, not in kho tạm; carried as boundary, not an F2 asset. |
HOLD-1 (iu_staging_*) |
framework §4/§18 ca 2; catalog STG-020 | documentary/CONFLICT | Carried Phase-1 obligation (Q2) | temp-store/candidate home; verify-gated. |
| HOLD-2 (atomic promote) | framework §4/§6c; de-bai §V.10/§V.13 | documentary/BLOCKED | Carried F4 obligation | reason canonical birth stays F4. |
| CONS-003 / CELL-003/004/007 | catalog CONS/CELL tables; constitution rev44 | current-pass (CONFLICT/PARTIAL) | Carried gating conflicts (Q2-gating) | block cell placement; Owner-only; not resolved here. |
4. Information Unit / Smart Brick analysis
- What it is (read-only): the Information Unit / Smart Brick / "Miếng thông tin" is the central subject of the whole assembly system (framework D4: "Viên Lego thông minh trung tâm"; de-bai §II.1: "miếng thông tin là 'viên gạch thông minh'"). Its lifecycle (documentary): object sinh tối thiểu / candidate → vào kho tạm → nhận cell/context → IO check → formula/DOT xử lý → nhận stamp → scan thiếu dấu → promote hoặc delete → có thể thành material canonical cho tầng trên (framework D4).
- Minimal brick shape (de-bai §VI.1/§VI.2, documentary): each brick =
input · output · IO Contract · DOT xử lý/kiểm · rollback · trạng thái promote; at workspace/kho tạm minimally needscell_id(hoặc pending) ·input_refs·output_schematối thiểu · IO Contract tối thiểu · rollback/xóa được. F2 reuses this as a documentary shape hypothesis, not as an implemented object. - Boundary held — brick ≠ temp-store: the brick is không chôn trong temp-store (framework D4 sub-note); the temp-store (D5) is only where the brick stands. F2 records this so F3 does not collapse the subject into its storage.
- Forbidden held (framework D4): F2 does not (a) create an Information Unit registry by default, (b) turn the IU into a giant object model, (c) treat
iu_staging_*as proven live substrate, (d) treat the IU lifecycle as implemented, or (e) promote without checker/Owner gate. Status recorded exactly: DOCUMENTARY_ONLY / GAP / CONFLICT (CONFLICT where tied toiu_staging_*HOLD-1); live IU lifecycle chưa proven. - F2 action taken: recorded the brick concept + minimal shape hypothesis + the not-buried boundary as a documentary deliverable for F3. No registry, no object model, no lifecycle implementation, no live proof claimed.
5. Temp-store / Candidate analysis
- What it is (framework D5, documentary): the temp store / staging / candidate = nơi brick đứng trước kho chính — workspace/candidate;
candidate_id;packet_hash; TTL; cleanup/delete-fast;blob_ref. Per-layer temp-store chưa live-proven; no new temp table. - Substrate candidates (documentary, HOLD-1):
iu_staging_record— UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE (CONFLICT); [GR] 26 cột, PK uuid; addendum "HOLD FOR SYSTEM CHECK"; Codex checkout ref 0. Candidate #1 for pre-promote staging + candidate packet store (KHÔNG tạo bảng mới). "Rủi ro cao nhất" nếu bind checker mà schema/lifecycle/TTL không đủ → cả lane sụp → Phase-1 verify (HOLD-1).iu_staging_payload— UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE (CONFLICT); [GR] 11 cột, CASCADE, cap 10MiB,blob_ref.blob_ref→ orphan/cleanup risk (RISK-GC); bind theocandidate_idchưa verify.
- Candidate packet = view, not a store: the candidate packet is view/binding logic on existing staging metadata/payload (
candidate_id+packet_hash), read by a verdict-only checker — it does not generate birth or write canonical (de-bai §V.13; catalog STG-REUSE-002). Creating a packet store/registry is BLOCKER-if-proposed (STG-REUSE-003) and forbidden by default. - Open verification items (carried, Owner-/Phase-1-gated):
STG-012cleanup scheduler (who callsfn_iu_staging_cleanup; nopg_cron) — BLOCKER;STG-015packet_hashcoverage (cell_id+stamps?) — BLOCKER;STG-REUSE-001shared-store sufficiency for all tiers — BLOCKER; RISK-CAP (10 MiB / CASCADE behavior). TTL exists (expires_atNOT NULL, ceiling ≤ +30d per old survey STG-007) but the fail-safe depends on the unproven scheduler. - Forbidden held (framework D5): F2 does not create a temp-store/table, does not use
system_issues/meta_catalogas the packet store, and does not default to a persisted packet ledger. - F2 action taken: recorded
iu_staging_*as the documentary temp-store/candidate candidate (HOLD-1), the candidate-packet-as-view rule, and the open staging verifications as carried obligations. No query, no bind, no new store, no live proof claimed.
6. TEMP_ID inheritance from F1
- Inherited as confirmed (F1 report §7):
TEMP_ID/ candidate identity is the minimal identity root F1 confirmed as in-scope — sufficient to operate (edit/check/delete/rollback) the brick in kho tạm (de-bai §V.10: căn cước tạm để thao tác). F2 reuses it as the identity the Smart Brick stands on before lifecycle. - Two identities kept distinct (de-bai §V.10, held):
TEMP_ID_STAMP/CANDIDATE_ID_STAMP(kho tạm —workspace_id/candidate_id) vsBIRTH_STAMP(canonical, after promote). "KHÔNG dùng cùng một dấu cho hai nghĩa." Pre-promote stamps live in candidate/workspace metadata or staging record — KHÔNG ghibirth_registrycanonical in kho tạm. - Live home = HOLD-1: the identity concept is confirmed, but its live home is
iu_staging_*(HOLD-1) — unproven; carried as a Phase-1 obligation, not a reuse decision. - Boundary held: F2 writes no
TEMP_ID_STAMP, noBIRTH_STAMP, no canonical record — it only classifies the inherited identity concept. Canonical birth remains the output at promote = F4.
7. cell_id / CONS / CELL blocker handling
cell_idcarried as concept, not solved:cell_id = tầng × loài × kho × miềnis a conceptual read-only attribute model (framework §5; §6.2CELL_STAMP; UNKNOWN→chỉ kho tạm). The Smart Brick's minimal shape listscell_idhoặc pending cell_id (de-bai §VI.2) — F2 keeps it pending, not placed.- Upstream conflict carried (NOT resolved): CONS-003 (6-vs-7 tầng) — CONFLICT / BLOCKER (TODO). Confirmed against constitution rev44: Đ0-B "7 Lớp Cấu tạo (33 species)", Đ29 "33 species, 7 dimensions" vs drafts' 6-tầng. Blocks any cell placement.
- Dimension-source conflicts carried (NOT resolved): CELL-003 (
layer:composition_levelvsmeta_catalog.layer) PARTIAL/BLOCKER; CELL-004 (species: 2 namespaces) CONFLICT/BLOCKER; CELL-007 (chuẩn 6-tầng;composition_levelchưa enacted) PARTIAL/BLOCKER. - Forbidden held: F2 makes no dimension decision, no
cell_idmaterialization (column/metadata = schema change, framework §19 STOP), and does not treat the brick's cell as solved. The brick may be classified with a pending cell only. - F2 action taken: recorded
cell_idas a pending-coordinate hypothesis and CONS-003 / CELL-003/004/007 as carried obligations F3 must respect. No resolution, no materialization.
8. HOLD-1 handling
- HOLD-1 =
iu_staging_record/iu_staging_payload— UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE / CONFLICT ("HOLD FOR SYSTEM CHECK"); the natural F2 temp-store / candidate home and theTEMP_IDlive home. - Treatment in F2: classified as a documentary candidate only (Q1 doc-candidate → Q2). Not queried, not bound, not marked live-proven. Framework §18 ca 2 ("
iu_staging_*là live vì [GR] nói vậy" → PHASE-1 READ-ONLY SURVEY REQUIRED; mark CONFLICT/UNKNOWN, không bind) and ca 16 ("Mỗi layer đã có temp store sẵn" → REJECT → CONFLICT/UNKNOWN; không tạo temp-store/table mới) both applied. - Carried to: a separate Owner-gated Phase-1 read-only survey (schema / lifecycle / TTL /
candidate_id/blob_ref/ cleanup scheduler). This is not part of the F2 Program Macro and was not performed.
9. Evidence currency table — sources · evidence · authority · conflict · runtime · provenance · safety lock
| Obligation | F2 discharge (current-pass) | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Sources | Each F2 asset pinned to KB source (framework §4/§5/§6.2/§6.3/D4/D5; de-bai §II/§V/§VI; catalog STG-/STG-REUSE-/REUSE/CELL/CONS rows). Framework rev56 (S3 a2ab3582…889, len 117459), de-bai rev33 (S4 6e921f0a…704, len 29088), catalog rev82 (S5 2da1a82…342, len 145449), constitution rev44 (S1 579c8fb1…2c6), OR rev51 (S2 d7e6230…f4) — all read this run. |
PROVEN (KB-rev currency only) |
| Evidence | Per-asset documentary-vs-live label applied; iu_staging_* = UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE/CONFLICT (HOLD-1); old-survey STG "ANSWERED" rows kept documentary (framework §18 ca 13); reported-LIVE not promoted. |
Discharged |
| Authority | Applied F0-decided CONS-004 working precedence: KB = practical authority for laws-new/* docs; enacted constitution/OR higher (constitution rev44 Đ0-B/Đ29; OR rev51 VPS=SSOT, PG/Directus=truth); cross-class overlap = Owner gate. No cross-class conflict newly triggered by F2. |
Carried (CONS-004 decided at F0) |
| Conflict | CONS-003, CELL-003/004/007, HOLD-1, HOLD-2, STG-012, STG-015, STG-REUSE-001/003, RISK-GC, RISK-CAP, RISK-BYPASS carried as unresolved obligations (see §10). | Carried, not resolved |
| Runtime | Recorded what is NOT proven without Phase-1: live staging schema/lifecycle/TTL/cleanup behavior; candidate_id/blob_ref binding; checkout/runtime sync (CONS-005 caveat). No runtime inferred from documentary. |
Discharged (recorded as gap) |
| Provenance | current-pass (this run KB reads) vs prior-session ("old survey" STG-001..011 ANSWERED rows kept documentary) distinguished; F0/F1 decision lineage carried (CONS-004/005 decided at F0; OBL-R2 closed-by-decision). | Discharged |
| Safety lock | F2 boundary restated (brick = subject / temp-store = place; TEMP_ID inherited; no canonical birth; no new registry/store; no cell_id materialization); stop points named (packet §8). |
Discharged |
10. Conflict / HOLD log (carried forward)
| Item | Status | Blocks what | Carried to |
|---|---|---|---|
| CONS-003 (6 tầng vs 7 composition levels) | CONFLICT / BLOCKER (TODO) — constitution rev44 Đ0-B "7 Lớp Cấu tạo (33 species)" / Đ29 "33 species, 7 dimensions" vs drafts (6 tầng) | cell placement; cell_id dimension resolution |
Owner decision — NOT resolved at F2 |
CELL-003 (layer source) |
PARTIAL / BLOCKER | cell_id "Tầng" dimension |
Owner + Phase-1 verify |
CELL-004 (species source) |
CONFLICT / BLOCKER | cell_id "Loài" dimension (2 namespaces) |
Owner + Phase-1 verify |
| CELL-007 (chuẩn 6-tầng) | PARTIAL / BLOCKER | cell_id tier catalog (composition_level chưa enacted) |
Owner (tied to CONS-003) |
HOLD-1 (iu_staging_record/iu_staging_payload) |
UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE / CONFLICT ("HOLD FOR SYSTEM CHECK") | temp-store/candidate home; TEMP_ID live home; candidate packet store |
Phase-1 read-only survey (separate Owner gate) |
| HOLD-2 (atomic promote) | BLOCKED (no real transaction) | canonical birth / promote write | F4 |
| STG-012 (cleanup scheduler) | TODO / BLOCKER | trusting TTL/delete-fast; who calls fn_iu_staging_cleanup (no pg_cron) |
Phase-1 verify |
STG-015 (packet_hash coverage) |
PARTIAL / BLOCKER | candidate-packet tamper-binding (cell_id+stamps?) | Owner/spec decision + Phase-1 |
| STG-REUSE-001 (shared-store sufficiency) | TODO / BLOCKER | iu_staging_* as shared kho tạm for all tiers v0.1 |
Phase-1 verify |
| STG-REUSE-003 (no new packet store) | BLOCKER-if-proposed | any new packet store/registry | default NO (de-bai §V.13) |
RISK-GC (blob_ref orphan/cleanup) |
OPEN | trusting payload blob lifecycle | Phase-1 verify |
| RISK-CAP (CASCADE / 10 MiB cap) | OPEN | trusting payload under load | Phase-1 verify |
RISK-BYPASS (fn_birth_gate warning + kill-switch) |
OPEN (inherited F1) | trusting the gate at promote | Phase-1 + pilot gate (controlled+audited) |
| CONS-004 (authority order) | DECIDED at F0 — applied, not re-opened | — | reused as authority basis |
| CONS-005 (freeze baseline) | DECIDED at F0 (accepted, KB-only) — reused | — (caveat: no runtime/checkout sync proof) | carried caveat |
11. Adversarial check result (packet §9 — fail-closed)
| # | Bad assumption | Rejected? | Basis in this run |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "iu_staging_* is live because [GR]/26-col/11-col says so." |
✅ Rejected | DOCUMENTARY / UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE; Codex checkout ref 0; framework §18 ca 2; HOLD-1 |
| 2 | "Each layer already has a temp store ready to use." | ✅ Rejected | framework §18 ca 16 → CONFLICT/UNKNOWN; no new temp-store/table |
| 3 | "The IU lifecycle is implemented." | ✅ Rejected | framework D4 — DOCUMENTARY_ONLY; live IU lifecycle chưa proven |
| 4 | "Bury the brick in the temp-store." | ✅ Rejected | D4 — temp-store = place, not the brick; §4 boundary |
| 5 | "Create an Information Unit registry to organize IU." | ✅ Rejected | D4 Forbidden; no new sổ; 5 no-new conditions unmet |
| 6 | "Make the IU a giant object model." | ✅ Rejected | D4 Forbidden; minimal brick only |
| 7 | "Candidate packet needs a new store/ledger." | ✅ Rejected | STG-REUSE-002/003; de-bai §V.13 (packet = view) |
| 8 | "cell_id is solved, place the brick in its cell." |
✅ Rejected | CONS-003 + CELL-003/004/007 BLOCKER; §7 (pending cell only) |
| 9 | "TEMP_ID = canonical birth, write BIRTH_STAMP at candidate." |
✅ Rejected | de-bai §V.10 (two distinct stamps); canonical birth = F4; §6 |
| 10 | "blob_ref cleanup is handled, reuse freely." |
✅ Rejected | RISK-GC; STG-012 cleanup scheduler unverified BLOCKER; §5 |
| 11 | "Documentary row counts / old-survey 'ANSWERED' rows prove live." | ✅ Rejected | documentary ≠ live; framework §18 ca 13; §3/§9 |
| 12 | "Promote the candidate without checker / Owner gate." | ✅ Rejected | D4 Forbidden; verdict-only checker + Atomic Promote Contract + Owner gate |
| 13 | "Reading staging schema live is fine because it's read-only." | ✅ Rejected | Phase-1 separately Owner-gated; no DB/runtime touched; §1 |
| 14 | "Use system_issues / meta_catalog as the packet store." |
✅ Rejected | framework D5 Forbidden; §5 |
Conclusion: no bad assumption led to a PASS-to-act or a forbidden action → F2 execution is not fail-open.
12. Non-authorization confirmation + self-check
Non-authorization confirmation:
- F2 read-only execution only: yes — this run executed the read-only F2 survey and nothing more.
- no Phase-1: yes — no substrate survey;
iu_staging_*untouched (HOLD-1). - no DB/runtime: yes — no live DB / Postgres / Directus / runtime / production read or write.
- no
iu_staging_*live touch: yes — classified documentary/HOLD-1 only; not queried/bound. - no
cell_idmaterialization: yes — pending-coordinate hypothesis only; no column/metadata. - no schema/table/registry/store: yes — nothing created or altered; no IU registry / temp-store table / packet ledger.
- no canonical birth: yes — not written; remains F4 output at promote (D10).
- no
BIRTH_STAMP/TEMP_ID_STAMPwrite: yes — concept only. - no implementation: yes — no code / migration / DDL / DML / DOT / checker / scanner / pilot.
- no CONS-003 / CELL-003/004/007 resolution: yes — carried as BLOCKERs; CONS-004/005 only reused as F0-decided.
- Documentary ≠ live proof · Prior-session ≠ current proof · Reuse-now ≠ live-proven · Engineering PASS ≠ Authority PASS.
Self-check:
- Answered the 3 Owner questions at the control surface: yes (§2).
- Kept F2 to Information Unit / Smart Brick + Temp Store / Candidate (brick = subject, temp-store = place): yes (§4, §5).
- Kept
iu_staging_*documentary / HOLD-1 only: yes (§5, §8). - Avoided
cell_idmaterialization; carried CONS-003 / CELL-* honestly: yes (§7). - Avoided live DB / runtime / Phase-1: yes (§1).
- Avoided new temp-store / table / registry / packet store: yes (§5).
- Avoided canonical birth /
BIRTH_STAMP: yes (§6; F4 deferred). - Distinguished documentary vs live proof: yes (§3, §9).
- Kept Owner/GPT as the only phase authority; Codex = control verdict only: yes.
Engineering PASS (report self-verifying complete & honest): achieved, with the explicitly-flagged PARTIAL condition (all candidates documentary-only; iu_staging_* HOLD-1; conflicts/risks carried). Authority PASS (permission to move to F3 / Phase-1 / detailed design): NOT granted — Owner-only.
13. F3 handoff / next-gate recommendation
- This F2 execution report → GPT/Owner, alongside the F1 decision record and the F2 packet. Owner reviews the Q1/Q2/Q3 classification (§2/§3), the Smart Brick analysis (§4), the temp-store/candidate analysis (§5), the
TEMP_IDinheritance (§6), thecell_id/CONS/CELL handling (§7), HOLD-1 (§8), and the carried conflict/HOLD log (§10). - Codex checkpoint (recommended). Owner may route the F1 decision + F2 packet + F2 report together to Codex for an independent control review (same 3-question Owner structure; deep layer = sources / evidence / authority / conflict / runtime / provenance / safety-lock).
- Owner decisions that F2 surfaces but does not make: resolve CONS-003 (6-vs-7 tầng) and CELL-003/004/007; authorize (or not) a scoped read-only Phase-1 substrate survey for HOLD-1 (
iu_staging_*schema/lifecycle/TTL/candidate_id/blob_ref+ STG-012 cleanup scheduler + STG-015packet_hash+ STG-REUSE-001 shared-store sufficiency + RISK-GC/RISK-CAP). - F3 handoff. F3 (§6c) = IO Contract + Formula + Assembly Machine / DOT. F2 hands F3: a documentary Smart Brick shape hypothesis (minimal fields · inherited
TEMP_ID/candidate_id· IO boundary · pending cell context · DOT/wrapper path · stamp path · temp-store path · delete/cleanup path); the temp-store/candidate reuse map (iu_staging_*+ metadata/jsonb + candidate-packet-as-view) with HOLD-1 pinned as a Phase-1 obligation; the IO Contract 5-field boundary (nhận·trả·schema_min·fail·rollback) as the brick-to-brick contract F3 builds the assembly machine / DOT around — without Module Contract First; and the carried conflicts (CONS-003, CELL-003/004/007) + risks (RISK-GC, RISK-CAP, STG-012, STG-015) as obligations F3 must respect, not inherit as solved. F3 preparation must again preserve the 3 reuse-first Owner questions and remain non-authorizing until its own GPT → Codex → Owner gate. - Nothing downstream is authorized by F2. Default HOLD for everything touching canonical / production / runtime / schema /
cell_idmaterialization / new store. A clean F2 (or a Codex PASS on it) confirms classification quality only — it does not open F3, Phase-1, or any design/implementation. Only Owner opens phases.
F2 — Information Unit / Smart Brick + Temp Store / Candidate — Read-only Execution Report | 2026-06-16 | STATUS: PARTIAL (honest; all candidates documentary-only; iu_staging_* HOLD-1; CONS-003 / CELL-003/004/007 / HOLD-1 / HOLD-2 / STG-012 / STG-015 / STG-REUSE-001/003 / RISK-GC/CAP/BYPASS carried). READ-ONLY, NON-AUTHORIZING. Brick = subject ≠ temp-store = place. TEMP_ID inherited ≠ BIRTH_STAMP ≠ canonical birth (F4). Documentary ≠ live proof. Engineering PASS ≠ Authority PASS.