KB-63AD
F1 Birth / Identity Root + Registries / Matrix Classification — Read-only Execution Report — 2026-06-16
32 min read Revision 1
laws-newmatrix-assemblystamp-governancef1birth-identityregistriesmatrix-classificationreuse-firstexecution-reportread-onlynon-authorizingpartial2026-06-16
F1 — Birth / Identity Root + Registries / Matrix Classification — Read-only Execution Report
Ngày: 2026-06-16 · Soạn: Claude Code CLI (read-only AgentData KB) · Track: knowledge/dev/laws-new/
Packet basis: f1-birth-identity-registry-reuse-survey-packet.md rev1 (Codex PASS, accepted by GPT/Owner).
Control basis: technical-slice-framework.md rev56 (S3 pin a2ab3582…889, len 117459, read current-pass this run).
Evidence basis: reports/f0/f0-source-authority-evidence-execution-report-2026-06-16.md rev1 (PARTIAL) + reports/f0/f0-owner-decision-record-2026-06-16.md rev1 (F0 gate CLOSED).
Run authorization: GPT/Owner authorized F1 read-only execution only (this run). No Phase-1, no live DB/runtime, no implementation, no schema/registry creation, no canonical birth write, no CONS-003 resolution.
Layer: F1 = one layer above F0 in the §6c build order; sits below F2.
0. STATUS (one line at top)
STATUS: PARTIAL — F1 read-only execution is complete and honest. All F1 candidate assets are classified into Q1/Q2/Q3 from current-pass KB evidence, the 3 Owner questions are answered, the birth boundary (TEMP_ID vs BIRTH_STAMP vs canonical birth) is held, and every forbidden action remained blocked. PARTIAL (not PASS) because every F1 substrate candidate is DOCUMENTARY_ONLY (framework §4 downgraded all reported-LIVE labels to documentary until a separately-authorized Phase-1 read-only verify) and four gating conflicts (CONS-003, CELL-003/004/007, HOLD-1, HOLD-2) remain Owner-/Phase-1-gated and are carried, not resolved. No forbidden action performed. Documentary ≠ live proof · Prior-session ≠ current proof · Engineering PASS ≠ Authority PASS · Reuse-now ≠ live-proven.
1. Owner View — 3 câu hỏi reuse-first (control surface, simple)
Đọc riêng mục này là đủ để Owner/GPT biết F1 đã phân loại gì để dùng lại — không làm gì chạm hệ thống. Chi tiết kỹ thuật ở §3 trở xuống. Mục này KHÔNG ủy quyền bất cứ điều gì.
| Owner question | Answered? | Summary (from current-pass KB evidence) |
|---|---|---|
| Q1 — Cái gì đang có và (giả thuyết) dùng lại được? (reuse-now — documentary) | ✅ Yes | F0 frozen-candidate source baseline (12 nguồn đã Owner-accept) = dùng lại ngay làm authority/evidence basis. Khái niệm cell_id (tầng×loài×kho×miền, mô hình thuộc tính, read-only) = dùng lại làm giả thuyết. Các substrate birth_registry / fn_birth_register / meta_catalog / collection_registry / universal_edges = ứng viên documentary (framework §4: ~1.21M / dry_run / ~169 / ~168 / ~2,199 rows, tất cả DOCUMENTARY_ONLY). Trung thực: "reuse-now" ở đây = ứng viên tài liệu để mang sang F2 — KHÔNG có nghĩa đã chứng minh live; đọc 1 KB revision chỉ chứng minh KB revision đó. |
| Q2 — Cái gì cần sửa/kiểm chứng mới dùng lại được? (repair / verify-before-reuse) | ✅ Yes | fn_birth_gate (mode=warning + kill-switch app.bypass_birth_gate = RISK-BYPASS) — không tin làm "cổng chặn" tới khi bypass được kiểm soát + audit. dot_tools thiếu cột dot_role/cell_id — chỉ reuse qua wrapper, gắn cột = schema change Owner-gated. Live state của mọi substrate (schema/row/gate behavior) — chỉ documentary, cần Phase-1 read-only verify (Owner-gated, không làm ở F1). Nguồn chiều cell_id chưa chốt (CELL-003/004/007). 6-vs-7 tầng (CONS-003) = CONFLICT chặn survey cell. Checkout/runtime sync chưa chứng minh (CONS-005 caveat: baseline chỉ phủ KB). |
| Q3 — Cái gì thật sự phải làm thêm (chỉ khi reuse không đủ)? (add-later — future Owner-gated) | ✅ Yes | Chỉ future Owner-gated, NO by default: detailed F1 execution design; cell_id mapping design (nhẹ, không ontology); birth identity wrapper nhẹ; metadata/schema changes; KHÔNG sổ birth/matrix registry mới; KHÔNG canonical birth write (đó là output tại promote = F4). Mỗi "add-new" KHÔNG tự biến thành authorization; phải chứng minh đủ 5 điều kiện no-new (catalog §2c) trước. |
2. F1 scope / boundary confirmation (§3 packet)
- read-only only (KB read; no live DB/runtime): yes
- no live DB / Postgres / Directus / runtime / production touched: yes (Phase-1 untouched;
iu_staging_*untouched;birth_registrylive untouched) - F1 scope kept to TEMP_ID / candidate identity (identity root tối thiểu) only: yes
- canonical birth /
BIRTH_STAMPNOT written / NOT closed (deferred to F4 promote boundary, D10): yes - no governance stuffed into birth P0: yes (held as safety lock; §18 ca 23 rejected)
- no schema / table / registry / index / DOT / checker / scanner / source-manifest created: yes
cell_id/dot_roleNOT materialized as a column: yes- CONS-003 / CONS-004 / CONS-005 / CELL-003/004/007 NOT resolved (carried; CONS-004/005 already Owner-decided at F0 and reused, not re-opened): yes
- exactly one report document created (this file): yes
In-scope performed: pinned the documentary state of each F1 candidate from KB sources (framework §4 / §6c, de-bai §V via framework §6.2/§6.3, catalog reuse rows), classified each into Q1/Q2/Q3 with an evidence pin and a documentary-vs-live label, restated the F1 identity-root boundary, and surfaced the gating conflicts as carried obligations.
3. Reuse-now classification — Q1 detail (filled)
Mọi dòng dưới là ứng viên documentary (framework rev56 §4 — "Status dùng
DOCUMENTARY_ONLYcho mọi asset được báo cáo LIVE/GOVERNED"). Reuse verdict ở đây = được mang sang F2 như giả thuyết tài liệu, không = live-proven. Evidence pin = nguồn KB current-pass.
| Asset | Documentary status (rev56 §4, current-pass) | [GR] documentary count | Reuse-now verdict (F1) | Evidence pin (F1, current-pass) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| F0 source baseline (12 nguồn) | accepted freeze-candidate (Owner decision) | 12 + pkg | REUSE-NOW (accepted) — authority/evidence basis for F1 | F0 decision record rev1 §4; F0 exec report rev1 §3 (S1–S11+R1+pkg pinned rev+len+sha256) |
birth_registry |
DOCUMENTARY_ONLY (reported LIVE/GOVERNED; Phase-1 verify required) | ~1,212,803 rows, 22 cột (inspect_pen/stamp/gate+certified) |
Q1 documentary candidate → Q2 to trust live; relevant as BIRTH_STAMP post-promote substrate (F4-leaning), NOT the F1 TEMP_ID root | framework §4 row + §6c D10; catalog REG-S01 (✅1,212,803), BIRTH-001 ANSWERED (old survey 22 cột) |
fn_birth_register |
DOCUMENTARY_ONLY (gated, dry_run default true) | — | Q1 documentary candidate → Q2 verify; reuse via wrapper hypothesis, but writes canonical birth ⇒ belongs to F4 promote, not F1 | framework §4 (dry_run default true); catalog BIRTH-003 ANSWERED (fn_birth_register(…dry_run DEFAULT true)) |
fn_birth_gate |
DOCUMENTARY_ONLY (gated, mode=warning + kill-switch) | — | → Q2 (repair/verify) — warning ⇒ "đếm được, chưa chặn được"; bypass = RISK-BYPASS; không tin làm cổng chặn | framework §4 + §6c D10 (mode=warning, app.bypass_birth_gate); catalog BIRTH-004 ANSWERED (WARNING + kill-switch) |
meta_catalog |
DOCUMENTARY_ONLY | ~169 rows, cột layer |
Q1 documentary candidate → Q2 verify; "Tầng" source for cell_id (read-only attribute hypothesis) |
framework §4 (cột layer, ~169); catalog REG-S03 (✅169), CELL-003 PARTIAL/BLOCKER |
collection_registry |
DOCUMENTARY_ONLY | ~168 rows | Q1 documentary candidate → Q2 verify; "Kho" dimension for cell_id |
framework §4 (~168); catalog REG-S02 (✅168), COL-REUSE-001 |
dot_tools |
DOCUMENTARY_ONLY (no dot_role/cell_id col reported) |
~309 rows | → Q2 (verify, via wrapper) / Q3 (if columns needed) — classification candidate via wrapper, no schema patch; attaching dot_role/cell_id = schema change Owner-gated |
framework §4 ("chưa có cột dot_role/cell_id"); catalog REG-S04 (✅309), REG-REUSE-004, REUSE-013 |
universal_edges |
DOCUMENTARY_ONLY | ~2,199 rows | Q1 documentary candidate → Q2 verify; relationship/graph reuse (governance) — explicitly NOT a matrix dimension | framework §4 ("graph riêng — KHÔNG phải chiều ma trận"); catalog REG-S05 (✅2,199), GOV-REUSE-001 BLOCKER |
cell_id concept |
conceptual attribute model (read-only hypothesis) | n/a | Q1 (concept reuse-now) → Q2 (resolve dimensions) → Q3 (materialization design) — tầng×loài×kho×miền light mapping hypothesis only |
framework §5 (Matrix cell row) + §6.2; catalog CELL-REUSE-001/002 |
TEMP_ID / candidate identity |
conceptual identity root (F1 in-scope deliverable) | n/a | Q1 (in-scope F1 identity root) — TEMP_ID_STAMP at kho tạm; its live home (iu_staging_*) is HOLD-1 ⇒ Q2 |
framework §6c D10 ("TEMP_ID_STAMP (kho tạm) vs BIRTH_STAMP (tại promote)"); §6.2 lifecycle |
Reuse-first gate (catalog §2c) — recorded, not executed: before proposing anything new, F1/F2 must answer Decision Rule 1→7 and prove all 5 no-new-creation conditions (existing registry/metadata insufficient · iu_staging_* insufficient · IO Contract 5-field insufficient · scanner/report insufficient · reuse slower than new). Nhóm 0 baseline REUSE-001..015 (catalog §2d) applies, scoped to the F1 slice only. No new-creation proposed by this report.
4. Repair / verify-before-reuse — Q2 detail (Owner-gated; not performed)
| # | Item | Why not reuse-now | Verification needed (Owner-gated; NOT done at F1) | Conflict/HOLD ref |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | birth_registry live schema/row/use |
Only documentary (DOCUMENTARY_ONLY); live unproven | Phase-1 read-only survey (separate Owner gate) — not at F1 | framework §4; OBL-Phase1 |
| 2 | fn_birth_gate warning + bypass |
mode=warning ⇒ counts, doesn't block; kill-switch = BYPASS surface |
Confirm gate behavior + bypass control + audit before trust; BLOCK pilot until controlled | RISK-BYPASS-001/003/004; framework §18 ca 6 |
| 3 | dot_tools lacks dot_role/cell_id |
columns reported absent | Attaching = schema change ⇒ Owner-gated detailed design; reuse only via wrapper meanwhile | framework §19 STOP-before-schema; catalog REG-REUSE-004 |
| 4 | cell_id dimension sources |
concept only; layer/species source not chosen |
Resolve dimension sources read-only (no schema change); blocked by Owner decision | CELL-003 (PARTIAL/BLOCKER), CELL-004 (CONFLICT/BLOCKER), CELL-007 (PARTIAL/BLOCKER) |
| 5 | 6-vs-7 tầng composition | drafts 6 tầng vs constitution rev44 (7 composition levels / "33 species, 7 dimensions") | Owner decision before any cell/matrix survey | CONS-003 (CONFLICT, BLOCKER) |
| 6 | iu_staging_* (TEMP_ID live home / F2 temp-store) |
UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE CONFLICT; "HOLD FOR SYSTEM CHECK" | Phase-1 read-only verify schema/lifecycle/TTL/candidate_id/blob_ref |
HOLD-1 (framework §4/§6c) |
| 7 | checkout/runtime sync | baseline covers KB only | not provable without runtime read (Owner-gated) | CONS-005 caveat (F0 decision §4) |
| 8 | governance NOT in birth P0 | anti-pattern the frame must block | keep governance/canonical-birth at promote boundary (D9/D10) | framework §6c D2 / §18 ca 23 |
Currency note: the catalog marks several birth/staging rows "ANSWERED" from an old survey (e.g. BIRTH-001 22 cột, STG-001 26 cột). Per framework §18 ca 13 these remain documentary and are not promoted to live proof by F1; they re-enter as Phase-1 obligations.
5. Add-later-only-if-needed — Q3 detail (nothing authorized)
Each is future Owner-gated, and only if the reuse survey proves reuse is insufficient. Default for all = NO.
| Possible future item | Precondition to even propose | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Detailed F1 execution design | This report reviewed + F1 detailed design separately authorized | not yet started |
cell_id mapping design (light, no ontology) |
CONS-003 + CELL-003/004/007 resolved; reuse of existing dimension sources proven insufficient | NO by default |
| Birth identity wrapper (light) | Existing fn/registry reuse proven insufficient | NO by default |
Metadata / schema change (incl. dot_role/cell_id on dot_tools) |
Reuse-insufficiency proof + Owner-gated detailed design (§19 STOP) | NO by default |
| New birth registry / matrix registry | All 5 no-new conditions proven (catalog §2c) | NO (no new sổ) |
Canonical birth write / BIRTH_STAMP close |
n/a — belongs to F4 (promote boundary, D10) | NEVER at F1 |
6. F1 asset classification table (consolidated — required format)
| Asset | Evidence source | Currency | Classification | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| F0 source baseline (12 sources) | F0 decision record §4; F0 exec report §3 | current-pass (KB rev) | Q1 (accepted reuse-now) | Owner-accepted freeze-candidate; authority/evidence basis. Covers KB only, not runtime. |
birth_registry |
framework §4 / §6c D10; catalog REG-S01, BIRTH-001 | documentary | Q1 doc-candidate → Q2 (live) → F4-leaning | DOCUMENTARY_ONLY ~1.21M/22col; post-promote BIRTH_STAMP substrate ≠ F1 TEMP_ID root; live needs Phase-1. |
fn_birth_register |
framework §4; catalog BIRTH-003 | documentary | Q1 doc-candidate → Q2 / F4 | dry_run default true; writes canonical birth ⇒ promote (F4), reuse via wrapper hypothesis only. |
fn_birth_gate |
framework §4 / §6c D10; catalog BIRTH-004 | documentary | Q2 (repair/verify) | mode=warning + bypass kill-switch (RISK-BYPASS); not trustworthy as a block until controlled+audited. |
meta_catalog |
framework §4; catalog REG-S03, CELL-003 | documentary | Q1 doc-candidate → Q2 (live + dimension) | "Tầng" source for cell_id (~169/layer); dimension-source choice blocked by CELL-003. |
collection_registry |
framework §4; catalog REG-S02, COL-REUSE-001 | documentary | Q1 doc-candidate → Q2 (live) | "Kho" dimension (~168); live + scope/domain fields need verify. |
dot_tools |
framework §4 / §19; catalog REG-S04, REG-REUSE-004 | documentary | Q2 (wrapper) / Q3 (columns) | ~309 rows; dot_role/cell_id columns absent; attaching = schema change Owner-gated; reuse via wrapper only. |
universal_edges |
framework §4; catalog REG-S05, GOV-REUSE-001 | documentary | Q1 doc-candidate → Q2 (live) | ~2,199 rows relationship graph; NOT a matrix dimension; governance-relationship reuse. |
cell_id concept |
framework §5 / §6.2; catalog CELL-REUSE-001/002 | documentary (concept) | Q1 (concept) / Q2 (dimensions) / Q3 (materialize) | attribute model only; resolve read-only; materialization = Owner-gated schema. |
TEMP_ID / candidate identity |
framework §6c D10 / §6.2 | documentary (concept) | Q1 (F1 in-scope root) → Q2 (live home) | the F1 identity root (TEMP_ID_STAMP); live home iu_staging_* = HOLD-1. |
BIRTH_STAMP boundary |
framework §6c D10 / §6.2/§6.3 | documentary (boundary) | Not F1 (F4 output) | closes at promote, not in kho tạm; carried as boundary, not an F1 asset. |
| F0 source baseline currency | F0 decision §4 (CONS-005 caveat) | current-pass (KB only) | Q1 + Q2 caveat | baseline accepted but proves no runtime/checkout sync. |
| CONS-003 (6-vs-7 tầng) | catalog CONS table; constitution rev44 | current-pass (CONFLICT) | Carried gating conflict (Q2-gating) | blocks cell/matrix survey; Owner-only; not resolved here. |
| CELL-003/004/007 | catalog Nhóm F | current-pass (PARTIAL/CONFLICT) | Carried gating conflict (Q2-gating) | cell_id dimension sources unresolved; all BLOCKER. |
HOLD-1 (iu_staging_*) |
framework §4/§6c; catalog STG-020 | documentary/CONFLICT | Carried Phase-1 obligation (Q2) | TEMP_ID live home / F2 temp-store candidate; verify-gated. |
| HOLD-2 (atomic promote) | framework §4/§6c; catalog Nhóm K | documentary/BLOCKED | Carried F4 obligation | reason canonical birth stays F4, not F1. |
7. Birth boundary analysis: TEMP_ID vs BIRTH_STAMP (required)
| Item | Verdict | Evidence (current-pass) |
|---|---|---|
| TEMP_ID / candidate identity | IN-SCOPE for F1 — minimal identity root only; TEMP_ID_STAMP lives at workspace/candidate (kho tạm); its live home iu_staging_* is HOLD-1 (Phase-1, not F1) |
framework §6c build-order note ("Ở F1, 'Birth' chỉ là identity root tối thiểu (vd TEMP_ID), KHÔNG phải canonical birth"); §6.2 lifecycle (workspace/candidate (TEMP_ID_STAMP, iu_staging_* ⟳)); §6c D10 |
| BIRTH_STAMP | NOT F1 — closes at promote, after PROMOTE_OK + Atomic Promote Contract; pre-promote ≠ output | framework §6.2 (→ BIRTH_STAMP + PROMOTE_STAMP (post-promote store)…); §6.3 ("BIRTH_STAMP đóng tại promote, không trong kho tạm"); §6c D8 ("precondition ≠ output") |
| canonical birth | NEVER at F1 — OUTPUT at the promote boundary = F4 (D10 "canonical-output của D10"); HOLD-2 (no real atomic transaction yet) is exactly why it stays at F4 | framework §6c F4 row ("canonical birth CHỈ tại promote"), D10; §4 summary (HOLD-2) |
| governance in birth P0 | REJECT (anti-pattern / safety lock) — birth P0 = minimal identity; governance evidence + canonical birth at promote boundary (D9/D10); not front-loaded | framework §6c D2 sub-note + D2 Forbidden col; §18 ca 23 (REJECT); de-bai §IV/§V (via framework) |
8. Registry / matrix classification analysis
- Registries are reuse-first SSOTs, not to be duplicated.
birth_registry/collection_registry/meta_catalog/dot_tools/universal_edgesare the existing per-sổ SSOTs (catalog REG-S01..S05, all "✅" documentary). F1 reuses them as documentary classification sources; it does not create a matrix registry (REG-REUSE-001 BLOCKER; COL-REUSE-001 "0 collection mới" by default). meta_catalog.layer= "Tầng" source;collection_registry= "Kho" dimension for thecell_idattribute model — both documentary, both gated by CELL-003 (whichlayersource wins:composition_levelvsmeta_catalog.layer) and CONS-003 (6 vs 7 tiers).universal_edgesis explicitly NOT a matrix dimension (framework §4: "graph riêng — KHÔNG phải chiều ma trận"). It is a relationship/governance graph (GOV-REUSE-001). F1 records this so F2 does not mistake it for a classification axis.dot_toolscannot carry classification metadata today —dot_role/cell_idcolumns are reported absent. F1 records reuse-via-wrapper as a hypothesis only; materializing the columns is a schema change → Owner-gated (§19 STOP), Q3.- Forbidden held: no ALTER/ADD COLUMN on
meta_catalog/collection_registry/dot_tools; no new registry;canonical_fieldscorrectly treated as ABSENT (not a table), not referenced as a registry;governance_candidate_statetreated as DESIGN-ONLY / 0-writer, not live.
9. cell_id concept analysis
- What it is (read-only):
cell_id = tầng × loài × kho × miền— a conceptual attribute model (framework §5 Matrix-cell row; §6.2CELL_STAMP), not a column/metadata on any table today. UNKNOWN/PENDING values exist only in kho tạm. - Reuse hypothesis (Q1 concept): chốt
cell_idv0.1 by a light mapping over existing dimension sources, not a large taxonomy/ontology (catalog CELL-REUSE-002 "Mapping nhẹ + UNKNOWN; không dựng ontology mới"). - Blocked before it can be resolved (Q2): CELL-003 (
layersource:composition_levelvsmeta_catalog.layer, PARTIAL/BLOCKER), CELL-004 (speciessource: 2 namespaces, CONFLICT/BLOCKER), CELL-007 (chuẩn 6-tầng catalog, PARTIAL/BLOCKER), all gated upstream by CONS-003 (6-vs-7 tầng). - Materialization (Q3, Owner-gated, NO by default): turning
cell_idinto a column/metadata is a schema change — stop at concept/mapping obligation; framework §19 STOP-before-schema-change applies. - F1 action taken: recorded the concept + the unresolved dimension conflicts as carried obligations. No materialization, no schema, no dimension decision made.
10. F1 evidence table — sources · evidence · authority · conflict · runtime · provenance · safety lock (§7 packet obligations)
| Obligation | F1 discharge (current-pass) | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Sources | Each F1 asset pinned to its KB source (framework §4/§5/§6c rows, catalog REG-S/REUSE/CELL rows, de-bai §V via framework §6.2/§6.3). Framework rev56 read this run (S3 a2ab3582…889, len 117459); catalog rev82 read this run (S5 2da1a82…342, len 145449); constitution rev44 (S1 579c8fb1…2c6); operating-rules rev51 (S2 d7e6230…f4). |
PROVEN (KB-rev currency only) |
| Evidence | Per-asset documentary-vs-live label applied (every substrate row = DOCUMENTARY_ONLY); row counts marked [GR] documentary; reported-LIVE labels not promoted to live (framework §18 ca 13). |
Discharged |
| Authority | Applied F0-decided CONS-004 working precedence: KB = practical authority for laws-new/* docs; enacted constitution/OR higher for enacted principles; VPS=SSOT runtime; PG/Directus=truth data; cross-class overlap = Owner gate. No cross-class conflict newly triggered by F1. |
Carried (CONS-004 already decided at F0) |
| Conflict | CONS-003 (6-vs-7 tầng), CELL-003/004/007, HOLD-1 (iu_staging_*), HOLD-2 (atomic promote) carried as unresolved obligations (see §11). |
Carried, not resolved |
| Runtime | Recorded what is NOT proven without Phase-1: live schema/rows/gate behavior of every substrate; checkout/runtime sync (CONS-005 caveat). No runtime inferred from documentary. | Discharged (recorded as gap) |
| Provenance | current-pass (this run KB reads) vs prior-session (catalog "old survey" ANSWERED rows kept documentary) distinguished; OBL-R2 disposition (Codex-rev56 relay accepted) carried from F0 decision §5. | Discharged |
| Safety lock | F1 boundary restated (TEMP_ID only; no canonical birth; no governance in P0; no schema/registry); stop points named (§13 below mirrors packet §8 stop conditions). | Discharged |
11. Conflict / HOLD log (carried forward)
| Item | Status | Blocks what | Carried to |
|---|---|---|---|
| CONS-003 (6 tầng vs 7 composition levels) | CONFLICT / BLOCKER (TODO) — confirmed: constitution rev44 (Đ0-B "7 Lớp Cấu tạo (33 species)", Đ29 "33 species, 7 dimensions") vs drafts (6 tầng) | cell/matrix survey; cell_id dimension resolution |
Owner decision (then F2) — NOT resolved at F1 |
CELL-003 (layer source) |
PARTIAL / BLOCKER | cell_id "Tầng" dimension |
Owner + Phase-1 read-only verify |
CELL-004 (species source) |
CONFLICT / BLOCKER | cell_id "Loài" dimension (2 namespaces) |
Owner + Phase-1 read-only verify |
| CELL-007 (chuẩn 6-tầng catalog) | PARTIAL / BLOCKER | cell_id tier catalog (composition_level chưa enacted) |
Owner (tied to CONS-003) |
HOLD-1 (iu_staging_record/iu_staging_payload) |
UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE / CONFLICT ("HOLD FOR SYSTEM CHECK") | TEMP_ID live home; F2 temp-store/candidate reuse | Phase-1 read-only survey (separate Owner gate) |
| HOLD-2 (atomic promote) | BLOCKED (no real transaction yet) | canonical birth / promote write | F4 (reason canonical birth stays F4, not F1) |
RISK-BYPASS (fn_birth_gate warning + app.bypass_birth_gate) |
OPEN / BLOCKER before pilot | trusting the gate as a block; pilot | Phase-1 verify + pilot gate (controlled+audited) |
| CONS-004 (authority order) | DECIDED at F0 (working precedence) — applied, not re-opened | — (no longer blocks F1 prep) | reused as authority basis |
| CONS-005 (freeze baseline) | DECIDED at F0 (accepted, KB-only) — reused | — (caveat: no runtime/checkout sync proof) | carried caveat |
| OBL-R2 (Codex-rev56 artifact) | Closed by decision at F0 (relay accepted) | — | carried for completeness |
12. Evidence currency table
| Fact | Currency class | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| KB rev/len/hash of framework rev56, catalog rev82, constitution rev44, OR rev51, F1 packet rev1, F0 decision rev1, F0 exec rev1 | current-pass | PROVEN (KB rev only) | read this run; proves the KB revision, not runtime/checkout |
| F1 candidate substrate state (birth_registry/fn_*/meta_catalog/collection_registry/dot_tools/universal_edges) | documentary | DOCUMENTARY_ONLY | framework §4 downgraded all reported-LIVE; not live-proven |
| Catalog "ANSWERED" birth/staging rows (BIRTH-001/003/004, STG-001/002) | prior-session ("old survey") | DOCUMENTARY | kept documentary (framework §18 ca 13); Phase-1 re-verify obligation |
iu_staging_* live schema/lifecycle |
documentary/CONFLICT | HOLD-1 (UNKNOWN→likely-LIVE) | Phase-1 only; untouched here |
| atomic promote transaction | documentary | HOLD-2 (BLOCKED) | no real transaction; canonical birth stays F4 |
fn_birth_gate enforcement |
documentary | DOCUMENTARY_ONLY (warning) | RISK-BYPASS; verify before trust |
checkout/runtime sync of laws-new/* |
documentary | UNKNOWN (CONS-005 caveat) | baseline KB-only; not generalized |
cell_id as a column/metadata |
documentary | NOT MATERIALIZED (concept only) | schema change Owner-gated |
| CONS-004 / CONS-005 | decided (F0) | DECIDED — reused | working precedence + accepted KB-only baseline |
13. Adversarial check result (§9 packet — fail-closed)
| # | Bad assumption | Rejected? | Basis in this run |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Documentary row counts / reported-LIVE labels prove the substrate is live." | ✅ Rejected | every substrate kept DOCUMENTARY_ONLY; framework §18 ca 13 |
| 2 | "F1 may write canonical birth because it's the 'birth' layer." | ✅ Rejected | canonical birth = F4 output at promote (§6c F4/D10); §7 boundary |
| 3 | "Identity root needs governance, so put governance into birth P0." | ✅ Rejected | §6c D2 + §18 ca 23; safety lock §7 |
| 4 | "cell_id exists, so add the column to make it real." |
✅ Rejected | concept only; materialization Q3 Owner-gated; §9 |
| 5 | "dot_tools should get dot_role/cell_id now." |
✅ Rejected | schema change §19 STOP; Q2/Q3 only; §8 |
| 6 | "birth_gate blocks, so reuse it as the canonical guard." |
✅ Rejected | mode=warning + bypass kill-switch ⇒ Q2/RISK-BYPASS; §4 #2 |
| 7 | "TEMP_ID is the same as canonical birth." |
✅ Rejected | TEMP_ID_STAMP (kho tạm) ≠ BIRTH_STAMP (promote); §7 |
| 8 | "Baseline accepted ⇒ runtime/checkout is in sync." | ✅ Rejected | CONS-005 caveat: KB only; §12 |
| 9 | "Reading runtime config is fine because it's read-only." | ✅ Rejected | Phase-1 separately Owner-gated; no DB/runtime touched; §2 |
| 10 | "Create a new registry/manifest to organize F1." | ✅ Rejected | no new sổ; 5 no-new conditions unmet/unproven; §3/§5 |
| 11 | "CONS-003/004/005 can be resolved inside F1." | ✅ Rejected | CONS-003 carried (BLOCKER); CONS-004/005 only as F0-decided, not re-opened; §11 |
| 12 | "An unreadable/absent source can be assumed PROVEN." | ✅ Rejected | canonical_fields = ABSENT (not a table); governance_candidate_state = DESIGN-ONLY/0-writer; §8 |
Conclusion: no bad assumption led to a PASS-to-act or a forbidden action → F1 execution is not fail-open.
14. Self-check (§7 task / §12 packet)
- Answered the 3 Owner questions at the top: yes (§1).
- Kept F1 to TEMP_ID / candidate identity only: yes (§2, §7).
- Avoided canonical birth /
BIRTH_STAMP: yes (deferred to F4; §7). - Avoided live DB / runtime / Phase-1: yes (
iu_staging_*,birth_registrylive untouched). - Avoided schema / table / registry creation: yes (§2, §8).
- Kept documentary evidence separate from live proof: yes (§3, §12; all
DOCUMENTARY_ONLY). - Rejected all anti-patterns: yes (§13 — F1-can-write-canonical-birth; TEMP_ID=BIRTH_STAMP; row-count=live; birth_gate-trusted; materialize-cell_id-now; patch-dot_tools-now; governance-in-birth-P0; baseline=runtime-synced; new-registry-because-cleaner — all rejected).
Engineering PASS (report self-verifying complete & honest): achieved, with the explicitly-flagged PARTIAL condition (all candidates documentary-only; four conflicts carried). Authority PASS (permission to move to F2 / Phase-1 / detailed design): NOT granted — Owner-only.
15. Non-authorization confirmation
- F1 read-only execution only: yes — this run executed the read-only F1 survey and nothing more.
- no Phase-1: yes — no substrate survey;
iu_staging_*untouched (HOLD-1). - no DB/runtime: yes — no live DB / Postgres / Directus / runtime / production read or write.
- no canonical birth: yes — not written; remains F4 output at promote (D10).
- no
BIRTH_STAMP: yes — not closed; closes at promote, not F1. - no schema/table/registry: yes — nothing created or altered;
canonical_fieldsABSENT respected. - no
cell_id/dot_rolematerialization: yes — concept/mapping obligation only. - no governance in birth P0: yes — held as safety lock (§7, §18 ca 23).
- no implementation: yes — no code / migration / DDL / DML / DOT / checker / scanner / pilot.
- no CONS-003 resolution: yes — carried as BLOCKER; CONS-004/005 only reused as F0-decided.
- Documentary ≠ live proof · Prior-session ≠ current proof · Reuse-now ≠ live-proven · Engineering PASS ≠ Authority PASS.
16. Next-gate recommendation (feeds F2)
- This F1 execution report → GPT/Owner. Owner reviews the Q1/Q2/Q3 classification, the birth boundary (§7), the registry/matrix analysis (§8), the
cell_idanalysis (§9), and the carried conflict/HOLD log (§11). - Codex checkpoint (recommended). Owner may route this report to Codex for an independent control review (same 3-question Owner structure; deep layer = sources/evidence/authority/conflict/runtime/provenance/safety-lock).
- Owner decisions that F1 surfaces but does not make: resolve CONS-003 (6-vs-7 tầng) and CELL-003/004/007 before any cell/matrix survey; authorize (or not) a scoped read-only Phase-1 substrate survey (HOLD-1:
iu_staging_*; plus live verify ofbirth_registry/fn_birth_gatebehavior + RISK-BYPASS). - F2 handoff. F2 (§6c) = Information Unit / Smart Brick + Temp Store / Candidate. F1 hands F2: a confirmed minimal identity root (
TEMP_ID/ candidate identity, no canonical birth); the classification-registries reuse map (meta_catalog"Tầng",collection_registry"Kho",dot_toolsclassification candidate via wrapper); thecell_id-as-attribute hypothesis (read-only) with its unresolved dimension conflicts (CONS-003, CELL-003/004/007) as obligations F2 must respect, not inherit as solved; and the carried HOLD-1 (iu_staging_*) note as the natural F2 temp-store candidate, pinned as a Phase-1 obligation, not a reuse decision. F2 preparation must again preserve the 3 reuse-first Owner questions and remain non-authorizing until its own GPT → Codex → Owner gate. The packet notes F2 may use a Program Macro (package + execution in one larger task) — that bundling is an Owner choice, not authorized here. - Nothing downstream is authorized by F1. Default HOLD for everything touching canonical / production / runtime / schema /
cell_idmaterialization. A clean F1 (or a Codex PASS on it) confirms classification quality only — it does not open F2, Phase-1, or any design/implementation. Only Owner opens phases.
F1 Birth / Identity Root + Registries / Matrix Classification — Read-only Execution Report | 2026-06-16 | STATUS: PARTIAL (honest; all candidates documentary-only; CONS-003 / CELL-003/004/007 / HOLD-1 / HOLD-2 carried). READ-ONLY, NON-AUTHORIZING. TEMP_ID ≠ BIRTH_STAMP ≠ canonical birth (F4). Documentary ≠ live proof. Engineering PASS ≠ Authority PASS.