F0 Source / Authority / Evidence — Read-only Execution Report — 2026-06-16
F0 Source / Authority / Evidence — Read-only Execution Report
Ngày: 2026-06-16 · Soạn: Claude Code CLI (read-only AgentData KB + read-only local filesystem) · Track: knowledge/dev/laws-new/
Program basis: f0-source-authority-evidence-program-package.md rev3 (Codex PASS_WITH_COSMETIC_NOTES, accepted by GPT/Owner) · Control basis: technical-slice-framework.md rev56.
Run authorization: GPT/Owner authorized F0 read-only execution only (this run). No Phase-1, no live DB/runtime, no implementation, no authority-order resolution, no baseline freeze.
0. STATUS (one line at top)
STATUS: PARTIAL — F0 read-only execution is complete and honest; all 12 pinnable mandatory sources (S1–S11 + R1) and the F0 package are pinned current-pass (PROVEN) at revisions matching the EXPECTED list exactly. PARTIAL (not PASS) for two non-blocking reasons only: (R2) the framework-rev56 Codex review artifact is NOT_FOUND in KB current-pass and stays PRIOR_SESSION_EVIDENCED (Owner relay), carried as an obligation; and (env) the checkout existence check is environment-limited to /Users/nmhuyen and must not be generalized. Neither blocks the next Owner gate. No forbidden action performed.
1. Owner View — 3 câu hỏi reuse-first (control surface, simple)
Đọc riêng mục này là đủ để Owner/GPT biết F0 đã làm gì / không làm gì. Chi tiết kỹ thuật ở §3 trở xuống. Mục này KHÔNG ủy quyền bất cứ điều gì. Documentary ≠ live proof · Prior-session ≠ current proof · Engineering PASS ≠ Authority PASS.
| Owner question | Answered? | Summary (from current-pass evidence) |
|---|---|---|
| Q1 — Hiện có gì dùng lại được ngay? (reuse now) | ✅ Yes | AgentData KB là nơi giữ nguồn thực tế hiện hành cho laws-new — tất cả 12 nguồn bắt buộc đọc được, revision khớp đúng EXPECTED, đã pin rev+length+sha256 current-pass. Tái dùng được ngay cho việc lập kế hoạch/thực thi F0: bộ document governed (constitution rev44, OR rev51, framework rev56, de-bai rev33, catalog rev82, required-stamps rev6, checker-spec rev11, addendum rev14, quick-rules rev8, plan rev5, roadmap rev1, codex catalog review rev1); cách inline-evidence (không manifest); bộ từ vựng evidence (PROVEN/DOCUMENTARY_ONLY/UNKNOWN/CONFLICT/BLOCKED/DEFER/PRIOR_SESSION); mẫu freeze-candidate; completion-contract + stop-conditions + adversarial-checks. Trung thực: "reuse-now" = dùng lại được cho F0, KHÔNG có nghĩa "đã chứng minh live/runtime". Đọc 1 KB revision chỉ chứng minh KB revision đó. |
| Q2 — Có gì phải sửa/kiểm chứng mới dùng lại được? (repair / verify before reuse) | ✅ Yes | 7 mục (xem §10): (1) Thứ tự authority KB-vs-checkout-vs-runtime chưa ban hành → CONS-004 OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED; (2) Baseline freeze mới ở mức candidate → CONS-005 Owner-only; (3) Codex review rev56 (R2) không tìm thấy file KB riêng → còn PRIOR_SESSION_EVIDENCED, cần Owner xác nhận relay là bản ghi chính thức; (4) Catalog rev82 vs header self-label = CONFLICT cosmetic, không chặn; (5) Checkout absence chỉ kiểm theo môi trường này, không tổng quát hóa; (6) required-stamps KB→runtime delivery = UNKNOWN, phải Owner-gated runtime read; (7) current-pass vs prior-session phải verify trước khi mark PROVEN. Không mục nào chặn chấp nhận report; (1)(2)(6) chặn pha sau cho tới khi Owner quyết. |
| Q3 — Cần làm thêm gì nữa? (add later — chỉ khi reuse không đủ) | ✅ Yes | 6 mục, không làm ở đây, không được run này ủy quyền, chỉ future Owner-gated (xem §11): Owner quyết CONS-004; Owner quyết CONS-005; runtime config-delivery check (SRC-009/010); Phase-1 substrate survey (HOLD-1, iu_staging_*); package F1/F2; (và KHÔNG dựng source-manifest system trừ khi Owner ra exception). Mỗi "add-new" KHÔNG tự biến thành authorization. |
2. F0 SCOPE CONFIRMATION (§16)
- read-only only: yes (KB read + local filesystem existence checks only)
- no live DB / Postgres / Directus / runtime / production touched: yes
- no manifest / schema / registry / table / DOT / index / checker / scanner / pilot created: yes
- authority order NOT resolved (CONS-004 carried as obligation): yes
- baseline NOT frozen (CONS-005 freeze-candidate proposal only): yes
- exactly one report document created (this file): yes
- enacted laws under
knowledge/dev/laws/not patched; no code/migration/DDL/DML written: yes
3. Source pin table — freeze-CANDIDATE baseline (inline, no manifest)
Method. content_length = KB-reported character length (matches get_document metadata exactly where cross-checked). content_sha256 = SHA-256 over the UTF-8 encoding of the exact content retrieved this pass from AgentData KB (batch_read full=true). For multi-byte (Vietnamese/em-dash) docs the byte length exceeds char length (e.g., F0 package: 37427 chars / 38849 bytes; framework: 117459 chars / 128591 bytes); the hash anchors the exact retrieved content for tamper/drift detection. This is a freeze-CANDIDATE proposal for Owner (CONS-005), NOT an enacted/frozen baseline.
| # | Source | KB rev (current-pass) | EXPECTED rev (§2 pkg) | Match | content_length | content_sha256 | Read status | Currency |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1 | knowledge/dev/laws/constitution.md |
44 | 44 | ✅ | 19132 | 579c8fb1a92762708f275a76a5c858bebee0172a356fbe8eb3d8a999df87d2c6 |
PROVEN | current-pass |
| S2 | knowledge/dev/ssot/operating-rules.md |
51 | 51 | ✅ | 5400 | d7e6230e03305591966cb0b0ad8404ae520a7aa3c678067811fa950c21cef4f4 |
PROVEN | current-pass |
| S3 | knowledge/dev/laws-new/technical-slice-framework.md |
56 | 56 | ✅ | 117459 | a2ab35827956b9b7a16e46e4f66d6edae28e2651a73b01a9cc249a86894ff889 |
PROVEN | current-pass |
| S4 | knowledge/dev/laws-new/de-bai-cai-tien.md |
33 | 33 | ✅ | 29088 | 6e921f0a9026bc66bc24f147610064cf6f7de61b289c9a6a1a6a072d56411704 |
PROVEN | current-pass |
| S5 | knowledge/dev/laws-new/cau-hoi-khi-tai-cau-truc.md |
82 | 82 | ✅ | 145449 | 2da1a823a2a0305bb06491f3a83efbb7cddc1c2c241d0c03bcef9b962cf1e342 |
PROVEN | current-pass |
| S6 | knowledge/dev/laws-new/required-stamps.v0.1.json |
6 | 6 | ✅ | 3111 | ed6edf20f2c4bd21fdd191860638c1ace6bd449c8133bc24147a9cf2f085f48c |
PROVEN (valid JSON) | current-pass |
| S7 | knowledge/dev/laws-new/promote-checker-v0.1-spec.md |
11 | 11 | ✅ | 6028 | 3e7bb498ced58db8b549cc62897a3a8eea95dae4028d07b5670f8653ad94b579 |
PROVEN | current-pass |
| S8 | knowledge/dev/laws-new/matrix-stamp-governance-addendum.md |
14 | 14 | ✅ | 26474 | 0cbff3db696de5ef66d8e63efd288930783133ba3dbb90a0c4f3c084cef8974f |
PROVEN | current-pass |
| S9 | knowledge/dev/laws-new/matrix-refactor-quick-rules.md |
8 | 8 | ✅ | 6057 | 85a1be76f3054e162be95a8d0a47d50ebbbc59000781bfbff58513545b08e15c |
PROVEN | current-pass |
| S10 | knowledge/dev/laws-new/matrix-refactor-implementation-plan.md |
5 | 5 | ✅ | 27905 | d17c0dac3da0e9bc273b143b76ad504077b0811b010e2e400efee14e35dd4046 |
PROVEN | current-pass |
| S11 | knowledge/dev/laws-new/roadmap-cai-tien.md |
1 | 1 | ✅ | 15107 | e4ef1bcfeb70e3f68c652173a2acdf7bead64d6f025c417b0b8280b04f62787c |
PROVEN | current-pass |
| R1 | knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/codex/codex-final-question-catalog-approval-review-2026-06-15.md |
1 | 1 | ✅ | 7880 | 73be6ecdf65a8f7efc7a41a6ebb381825facf2c5b560df1ac320cd1b4e59b4b6 |
PROVEN | current-pass |
| R2 | Codex review of framework rev56 | — | PRIOR_SESSION_EVIDENCED | — | — | — | NOT_FOUND in KB (current-pass search + listing) | prior-session (relay) |
| pkg | knowledge/dev/laws-new/f0-source-authority-evidence-program-package.md |
3 | 3 | ✅ | 37427 | edb3de83b895d238e131285d88a2e2f42762750f46078294b762a44b500fa0d7 |
PROVEN | current-pass |
Cross-validation (independent corroboration): R1 (the Codex catalog review) records in its own body "AgentData KB revision 82; content length 145449" for the catalog — which matches the S5 current-pass read exactly (rev 82, len 145449). This independently corroborates the S5 pin.
Anchor facts re-verified current-pass inside the retrieved bodies (so downstream claims are evidence-grounded, not relayed): constitution = "v4.6.3 BAN HÀNH", NT10 (PG vs text), NT13 (PG First / PG Native / PG-driven), NT14 "THỰC THI ĐƯỢC NGAY" present; operating-rules §0.3 "VPS = SSOT code/runtime", §0.4 "PG/Directus là đường dữ liệu chuẩn", "Assembly First" present; catalog rev82 contains CONS-004 (×3), CONS-005 (×1), SRC-001/007/009/010, "Nhóm S (source/runtime gates)"; required-stamps.v0.1.json is valid JSON (config-as-metadata; keys _meta/core_stamps/lifecycle/…); de-bai carries "quan hệ/relationship completion"; roadmap rev1 is DRAFT — KHÔNG PHẢI BAN HÀNH.
Honest note: the package §6.1 quotes NT10 verbatim as "Text = documentation. PG = truth." In rev44 the principle is present and labelled "NT10 (PG vs text)" plus NT13 "PG First/PG Native/PG-driven"; treat the exact package wording as a documentary paraphrase of the present-and-confirmed PG-over-text principle.
4. Checkout existence table (read-only, per-environment — NOT generalized)
Environment id: host=Nguyens-MacBook-Air.local · cwd=/Users/nmhuyen · git: NOT a repository (fatal: not a git repository). A partial local knowledge/ tree exists (667 files under dev/{design,lark,planning,reports,requirements}) but contains no dev/laws, dev/laws-new, or dev/ssot subtree.
| Path / group | checkout_present? | Environment | Notes (current-pass) |
|---|---|---|---|
dev/laws/ dir |
No | /Users/nmhuyen | dir absent |
dev/laws-new/ dir |
No | /Users/nmhuyen | dir absent |
dev/ssot/ dir |
No | /Users/nmhuyen | dir absent |
| S1 constitution.md (canonical path) | No | /Users/nmhuyen | absent at knowledge/dev/laws/constitution.md |
| S2 operating-rules.md (canonical path) | No | /Users/nmhuyen | absent at knowledge/dev/ssot/operating-rules.md |
S3–S11, R1, F0 pkg (canonical laws-new/* paths) |
No (all 12) | /Users/nmhuyen | every file absent at canonical path |
any local constitution.md at all |
Different doc only | /Users/nmhuyen | only copies found are stale cursor backups .cursor-environment-backup/**/memory_log/constitution.md = "Hiến Pháp Hạ Tầng Agent Data v1.11e" (Dec 2 2025) — a different, older document, NOT the enacted v4.6.3 rev44 |
Current-pass conclusion (this environment only): the laws-new/* track, the enacted laws (dev/laws), and dev/ssot are absent from any working checkout here; AgentData KB is the de-facto sole holder for the laws-new governance track. This re-verifies current-pass the framework §1 / package §6.1 observation that was previously PRIOR_SESSION_EVIDENCED. Do NOT generalize: absence here ≠ absence in other environments (e.g., the VPS or a CI checkout were not inspected and are out of F0 scope).
5. Evidence currency table (§7)
| Fact | Currency class | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| KB revisions + length + sha256 of S1–S11, R1, F0 pkg | current-pass | PROVEN | read this run; proves the KB revision only — not checkout/runtime |
Checkout absence of laws-new/* + enacted laws @ /Users/nmhuyen |
current-pass | PROVEN (per-env) | test -f/find this run; not generalized (§15 #3) |
| All EXPECTED revisions match observed | current-pass | PROVEN | 12/12 pinnable sources match §2 EXPECTED exactly |
| Framework-rev56 Codex verdict = PASS_WITH_COSMETIC_NOTES | prior-session (relay) | PRIOR_SESSION_EVIDENCED | relayed by GPT/Owner; no distinct KB artifact found current-pass (R2 obligation) |
laws-new/* exist only in KB (cross-environment) |
prior-session | re-verified only for /Users/nmhuyen |
other environments not inspected |
required-stamps KB→runtime delivery |
documentary | DOCUMENTARY_ONLY / UNKNOWN | runtime read out of F0 scope (obligation SRC-009/010) |
| Any "live/GOVERNED/row-count/substrate" assertion | documentary | DOCUMENTARY_ONLY | never promoted to live proof (hostile case "row13") |
| KB-vs-checkout-vs-runtime authority order | documentary | CONFLICT / OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED | CONS-004; not resolved here |
6. F0 evidence table (framework §13 columns + provenance)
| Claim / Area | What would prove it | Evidence currently present | Evidence still missing | Provenance | Status | Blocks next phase? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| KB rev/len/hash of each mandatory source | Read KB current-pass | §3 table, 12/12 pinned, match EXPECTED | — | current-pass | PROVEN | No |
laws-new/* + enacted laws present in checkout |
test -f current-pass per env |
§4 table: all absent @ /Users/nmhuyen | per-env re-check elsewhere (VPS/CI) | current-pass (this env) + prior-session (others) | CONFLICT/UNKNOWN until other envs checked | Yes if a sync/export is required |
| KB→checkout sync/export process (SRC-003) | Evidence of a sync pipeline | none located current-pass | sync-process evidence | documentary | UNKNOWN → obligation | Possibly (if checkout must mirror KB) |
| Authority order KB vs checkout vs runtime | Owner ratifies an order | §7 observed facts + conflict | Owner CONS-004 decision | documentary | OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED (CONS-004) | Yes |
required-stamps KB→runtime delivery |
Owner-authorized runtime read | KB config rev6 only (valid JSON) | runtime delivery check (SRC-009/010) | documentary | DOCUMENTARY_ONLY → obligation | Yes if checker (downstream) |
| Codex rev56 review artifact (R2) | Locate KB file OR Owner confirms relay | task/Owner relay = PASS_WITH_COSMETIC_NOTES | distinct KB report file (not found) | prior-session/relay | PRIOR_SESSION_EVIDENCED | No |
| Catalog rev vs header self-label | Compare index vs header | KB index rev82; header self-labels rev3/rev4 (per Codex cosmetic note) | — | current-pass + documentary | CONFLICT (cosmetic, non-blocking) | No |
| Freeze baseline | Owner freeze (CONS-005) | §3 freeze-candidate (proposal) | Owner freeze decision | current-pass (candidate) | proposal — not enacted | Yes |
7. CONS-004 evidence bundle (authority order — NOT resolved)
F0 gathers evidence only. The Owner resolves CONS-004. No winner is picked here.
Observed facts (current-pass where marked; provenance explicit):
laws-new/*, enacted laws, anddev/ssotare absent from the checkout at/Users/nmhuyen(current-pass, this env) → KB is the de-facto sole holder for thelaws-newtrack. (Not generalized to other environments.)- Operating-rules §0.3 (enacted, rev51, current-pass): "VPS = SSOT code/runtime nếu đụng hệ thống đang chạy."
- Operating-rules §0.4 (enacted, rev51, current-pass): "PG/Directus là đường dữ liệu chuẩn."
- Constitution (enacted, rev44, current-pass): NT10 (PG vs text — PG = truth over documentation); NT13 (PG First / PG Native / PG-driven).
The conflict (why CONS-004 is real): the enacted authority statements cover code/runtime (VPS=SSOT) and machine-enforced data (PG=truth), but do not cover governance documents that live only in KB and exist in neither checkout nor runtime. There is no enacted single KB-vs-checkout-vs-runtime order → CONFLICT / UNKNOWN.
Non-binding candidate framing (DOCUMENTARY_ONLY · OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED · NOT enacted by F0):
Candidate (pending CONS-004): for the
laws-new/*governance track, KB is de-facto authoritative pending Owner ratification; for code/runtime, VPS = SSOT (OR §0.3); for machine-enforced data, PG = truth (NT10/NT13). Cross-class precedence when these overlap remains an Owner decision.
Disposition: CONS-004 = OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED. F0 stops at evidence.
8. CONS-005 freeze-candidate baseline (proposal — NOT frozen)
The freeze-CANDIDATE baseline is the §3 source pin table (path + kb_revision + content_length + content_sha256 + checkout_present + currency + status), held inline (no manifest, SRC-005 NO-BY-DESIGN). It is a proposal for Owner. F0 does not declare a frozen/enacted baseline. CONS-005 = OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED (accept / adjust the candidate, then freeze).
9. Authority questions (§4) — answered with evidence or carried as obligation
| Q | Catalog id | F0 answer (current-pass) / obligation | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| A1 single authoritative source per file | SRC-001 | KB is de-facto sole holder (checkout absent here); order not enacted | partial → CONS-004 obligation |
| A2 do files exist in checkout | SRC-002 | No — all 12 absent @ /Users/nmhuyen (per-env) | PROVEN (per-env) |
| A3 KB→checkout sync process | SRC-003 | no sync process evidenced current-pass | UNKNOWN → obligation |
| A4 canonical rev/hash baseline | SRC-004 | §3 table inline (rev+len+sha256) | PROVEN |
| A5 manifest of file+rev+location? | SRC-005 | NO BY DESIGN — inline evidence only; manifest not created | answered (NO) |
| A6 are Codex/Claude/Agent reading same rev | SRC-006 | R1 (Codex) cites catalog rev82/len145449 = matches current KB; Claude(this run)=same revs; other consumers documentary | partial — PROVEN for R1 consistency; drift elsewhere = documentary |
| A7 if KB and checkout disagree, who wins | SRC-007 / CONS-004 | not resolved — evidence gathered (§7) | OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED |
| A8 source-sync preflight required? | SRC-008 | Yes — this F0 run IS that read-only preflight | answered (YES, done) |
| A9 config KB→runtime delivery | SRC-009 | not read (runtime out of scope) | DOCUMENTARY_ONLY → obligation |
| A10 fail-closed if config stale | SRC-010 | downstream checker design obligation | obligation (BLOCKER-if-checker) |
| A11 authority order if docs conflict | CONS-004 | not resolved (§7) | OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED |
| A12 Owner freeze needed before slice survey? | CONS-005 | Yes — §8 candidate proposed; Owner freezes | answered (YES) |
| A13 stamps carry rule_version/config_hash? | RISK-STL-001 | documentary/design only (catalog Nhóm R/STL) | obligation (source-currency relevance only) |
F0 answered A2/A4/A5/A8/A12 with current-pass evidence; carries A1/A3/A7/A9/A10/A11/A13 as Owner-decision / runtime / downstream obligations. No F0 answer authorizes a phase transition.
10. Repair / verify-before-reuse list (Q2 detail)
| # | Cái đang có | Sai/không chắc | Phải verify/repair | Chặn chấp nhận report? | Chặn pha sau? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Authority order KB-vs-checkout-vs-runtime | chưa ban hành | Owner ratify (CONS-004) | No | Yes |
| 2 | Baseline freeze | mới ở mức candidate | Owner freeze (CONS-005) | No | Yes |
| 3 | Codex rev56 review (R2) | không có file KB riêng (NOT_FOUND current-pass) | Owner confirm relay là bản ghi chính thức, hoặc định vị artifact | No | No (currency obligation) |
| 4 | Catalog rev82 vs header self-label rev3/rev4 | lệch cosmetic | ghi CONFLICT, Owner awareness |
No | No |
| 5 | Checkout absence | chỉ đúng cho /Users/nmhuyen |
re-check per environment khác (VPS/CI) khi cần | No | Yes (per-env / if sync required) |
| 6 | required-stamps KB→runtime delivery | UNKNOWN |
Owner-gated runtime read (SRC-009/010) | No | Yes (downstream/runtime) |
| 7 | current-pass vs prior-session | dễ nhầm | verify current-pass trước khi PROVEN (đã áp dụng run này) | No | Yes |
11. Add-later-only-if-needed list (Q3 detail)
| # | Cần làm thêm | Trạng thái trong run này |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Owner quyết CONS-004 (authority order) | not done · not authorized here · Owner-only |
| 2 | Owner quyết CONS-005 (freeze baseline) | not done · not authorized here · Owner-only |
| 3 | Runtime config-delivery check (SRC-009/010) | not done · future Owner-gated runtime read |
| 4 | Phase-1 substrate survey (HOLD-1, iu_staging_*) |
not done · future Owner-gated |
| 5 | Package F1 / F2 | not done · future Owner-gated |
| 6 | Source manifest system | NOT to be built unless Owner issues an exception proving inline-evidence insufficient |
Every Q3 item: not executed, not authorized by this run, future Owner-gated. An "add-new" never self-converts into authorization.
12. Obligations carried forward (§16)
| id | Obligation | Needs |
|---|---|---|
| OBL-R2 | Locate the framework-rev56 Codex review KB artifact, OR Owner confirms the GPT/Owner relay is the authoritative record | Owner confirmation / artifact location (NOT_FOUND in KB current-pass) |
| OBL-SRC-003 | Determine/record the KB→checkout sync/export process (or confirm none) | read-only discovery; out of this run's located evidence |
| OBL-SRC-009/010 | required-stamps.v0.1.json KB→runtime delivery + fail-closed-on-stale behavior |
Owner-authorized runtime read (downstream, NOT F0) |
| OBL-CONS-004 | Resolve KB-vs-checkout-vs-runtime authority order | Owner decision (evidence bundle §7 ready) |
| OBL-CONS-005 | Freeze (accept/adjust) the source authority/revision/hash baseline | Owner decision (candidate §3/§8 ready) |
| OBL-ENV | Re-run checkout existence in other environments (VPS/CI) before treating absence as global | per-environment read-only checks when an environment becomes in-scope |
| OBL-RISK-STL-001 | Verify stamps/verdicts carry rule_version/config_hash (staleness detectable) |
downstream design (catalog Nhóm R) |
13. STOP / blocker log (§14)
| item | status | reason |
|---|---|---|
| Live DB / Postgres / Directus query | STOPPED (not performed) | Phase-1/runtime, Owner-gated; F0 ≠ Phase-1 |
| Runtime config-delivery read (SRC-009/010) | STOPPED (not performed) | touching runtime needs Owner authorization → obligation |
| Resolve CONS-004 authority order | STOPPED (not resolved) | Owner-only; evidence gathered, no winner picked |
| Freeze CONS-005 baseline | STOPPED (candidate only) | Owner-only; proposal emitted, not enacted |
| Create source manifest system | STOPPED (not created) | SRC-005 NO-BY-DESIGN; inline evidence only |
| Create schema/table/registry/index/DOT/checker/scanner/pilot | STOPPED (none created) | forbidden (§10); STOP-before-schema-change |
Patch enacted laws knowledge/dev/laws/ |
STOPPED (untouched) | forbidden |
| R2 rev56 review artifact | BLOCKED (NOT_FOUND in KB) | no distinct KB file; carried as OBL-R2 (non-blocking) |
| Checkout check in other environments | DEFERRED | per-env; only /Users/nmhuyen in scope this run (OBL-ENV) |
No blocker prevents producing an honest report; the run proceeds as PARTIAL.
14. Adversarial check result (§15)
| # | Bad assumption | Rejected? | Evidence in this run |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Last-session KB rev is still current." | ✅ Rejected | re-read all revs current-pass this run; 12/12 match EXPECTED, marked PROVEN only after current-pass read |
| 2 | "Documentary row-counts / 'LIVE/GOVERNED' labels prove substrate." | ✅ Rejected | no substrate touched; all live/runtime assertions kept DOCUMENTARY_ONLY |
| 3 | "Checkout absent here ⇒ absent everywhere." | ✅ Rejected | env id recorded (/Users/nmhuyen); absence NOT generalized; OBL-ENV carried |
| 4 | "When KB/checkout/runtime disagree, use the convenient one." | ✅ Rejected | CONS-004 marked OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED; no winner picked (§7) |
| 5 | "F0 should build a source-manifest file/system." | ✅ Rejected | inline evidence only; no manifest created (SRC-005) |
| 6 | "Reading runtime config is read-only so it's fine." | ✅ Rejected | runtime not read; carried as OBL-SRC-009/010 |
| 7 | "Codex/Owner PASS on framework = authority to run/freeze." | ✅ Rejected | Engineering PASS ≠ Authority PASS; freeze + phase = Owner-only |
| 8 | "A source I couldn't read can be assumed unchanged/PROVEN." | ✅ Rejected | R2 NOT_FOUND → BLOCKED/obligation, never silently PROVEN |
| 9 | "F0 can pin AND freeze the baseline itself." | ✅ Rejected | §8 candidate only; CONS-005 Owner-only |
| 10 | "F0 resolves authority order so downstream can proceed." | ✅ Rejected | evidence only; CONS-004 unresolved |
| 11 | "F0 can query live DB (iu_staging_*) to verify a source." |
✅ Rejected | no DB; Phase-1 HOLD-1 untouched |
| 12 | "Revision alone is enough; hash/length is overkill." | ✅ Rejected | recorded rev + content_length + sha256 inline for every readable source |
| 13 | "F0 is small, so it can peek at one substrate table." | ✅ Rejected | scope = KB + checkout existence only; zero substrate |
Conclusion: no bad assumption led to a PASS-to-act or a forbidden action → F0 execution is not fail-open.
15. Self-check (§7 of task / §18 pkg)
- Answered the 3 Owner questions at the top: yes (§1).
- Pinned current-pass KB revisions + content_length + sha256: yes (§3, 12/12 readable sources).
- Distinguished current-pass / prior-session / documentary: yes (§5).
- Did not turn EXPECTED revisions into PROVEN without a current-pass read: yes (all PROVEN rows were read this run).
- Avoided live DB / runtime: yes.
- Avoided creating a source manifest: yes.
- Avoided resolving authority order / freezing baseline: yes (CONS-004 obligation; CONS-005 candidate).
- Rejected all bad inputs (§14): yes — incl. "last-session rev is current", "documentary proves live", "checkout absent here ⇒ everywhere", "convenient source wins", "runtime read OK because read-only", "Q1 reusable means live-proven", "Q3 add-later means authorized".
Engineering PASS (report self-verifying complete & honest): achievable — this report meets the §12 quality bar except the two explicitly-flagged non-blocking PARTIAL conditions (R2 + per-env checkout). Authority PASS (permission to move to F1 / Phase-1): NOT granted — Owner-only.
16. Non-authorization confirmation
- F0 execution only: yes — this run executed the read-only F0 survey and nothing more.
- no Phase-1: yes — no substrate survey,
iu_staging_*untouched. - no DB/runtime: yes — no live DB / Postgres / Directus / runtime / production read or write.
- no source manifest: yes — inline evidence only.
- no implementation: yes — no code / migration / DDL / DML / schema / table / registry / index / DOT / checker / scanner / pilot.
- no authority resolution: yes — CONS-004 = OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED.
- no baseline freeze: yes — CONS-005 = freeze-candidate proposal only.
- Documentary ≠ live proof · Prior-session ≠ current proof · Freeze-candidate ≠ frozen baseline · Engineering PASS ≠ Authority PASS.
17. Next-gate recommendation (§17)
- This F0 execution report → GPT/Owner. Owner reviews the §3 freeze-candidate baseline + §7 CONS-004 evidence bundle + §12 obligations.
- Codex checkpoint (recommended). Owner may route this report to Codex for an independent control review (as with rev56 / the catalog).
- Owner decisions unlocked by F0 (framework §14.4/§14.5): accept/adjust + freeze the source baseline (CONS-005); resolve/record the authority order (CONS-004); confirm OBL-R2 (rev56 review relay) is the authoritative record.
- Only after Owner freezes the baseline and resolves/records CONS-004 may the program move toward F1 (Birth/Identity root + registries/matrix classification) and/or a separately-authorized scoped read-only Phase-1 substrate survey (HOLD-1).
- Nothing downstream is authorized by F0. Default HOLD for everything touching canonical / production / runtime / schema. A clean F0 (or a Codex PASS on it) confirms evidence quality only — it does not open the next phase. Only Owner opens phases.
F0 Source / Authority / Evidence — Read-only Execution Report | 2026-06-16 | STATUS: PARTIAL (honest; non-blocking R2 + per-env checkout). READ-ONLY, NON-AUTHORIZING. Freeze-candidate ≠ frozen baseline. CONS-004 / CONS-005 = OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED. Engineering PASS ≠ Authority PASS.