06 — Final decision

VERDICT

C1_W7_PATCH_OPS_CODE_APR_PROPOSED_AWAITING_QUORUM

The real W7 patch_ops_code APR APR-0415 (status=pending) exists, carrying the bash -n-verified additive execute_authorize_build_step handler patch. It is not approved, not executed, not deployed. Quorum is 0/3 (quorum_passed=false).

Why this verdict (not the others)

• Not …_QUORUM_READY_FOR_EXECUTION: 0 legitimate approvals exist.
• Not HOLD_PREPROPOSAL_SURFACE_UNSAFE: apply surface CLEAN, baseline matched.
• Not HOLD_PROPOSAL_NOT_SAFE / HOLD_PAYLOAD_RECONSTRUCTION_FAILED: payload faithfully rebuilt, bash -n PASS on target shell, additive/W7-only, proposed cleanly (APR-0415, exit 0).
• Not HOLD_KB_READBACK_FAILED: all 7 files read back from AgentData KB (see 00-index + readback).
• Not any GOVERNED_C1_DRYRUN_REJECT_*: no approval fabrication, no scope drift (W7-only), no readiness overclaim (every readiness flag below = NO).

Self-check

1. Avoided execution? YES 2. Avoided approval fabrication? YES
2. Avoided handler_ref binding? YES 4. Avoided grant insertion? YES
3. Avoided dot-c1-grant-issue registration? YES 6. Kept payload W7-only? YES
4. Proposed through dot-apr-propose? YES (APR-0415) 8. Recorded APR code + payload hash? YES
5. Produced approval packet? YES (file 04) 10. Read back quorum status? YES (file 05)
6. Avoided Codex/dry-run/W1–W9? YES

Writes made this turn

• 1 governed write: APR-0415 created via dot-apr-propose (Cấp A proposer role). approval_requests 230→231.
• VPS /tmp scratch files (payload/runner) used to build the proposal — removed.
• AgentData KB evidence package (this 7-file set).
• 0 executions / approvals / binds / grants / DOT registrations / migrations / dry-runs.

Next exact owner/council action

1. Real human president casts apr_approvals(apr_id=415, approver_type='human', approver ILIKE '%president%', decision='approve', rationale=…) via their own identity/channel.
2. Two real ai_council seats each cast apr_approvals(apr_id=415, approver_type='ai_council', decision='approve', …) via their own identities.
3. Confirm quorum_passed('APR-0415')='t' and 0 rejects.
4. THEN (separate, owner-authorized, NOT this macro): execute APR-0415 via dot-apr-execute (self-patch: flock/backup/bash -n/atomic mv) → STEP 4 bind handler_ref (governed migration) → STEP 5 register dot-c1-grant-issue → re-run W7 → re-run W1→W9 prewrite gate.

Readiness flags

• ready for execution: NO (quorum 0/3)
• ready for Claude re-verification: NO unless executed
• ready for Codex final confirmation: NO
• ready for governed dry-run: NO
• ready for production: NO