06 — Final decision

VERDICT

APR_0415_APPROVAL_HOLD_NO_REAL_PRESIDENT_CHANNEL

Co-hold: APR_0415_APPROVAL_HOLD_NO_REAL_AI_COUNCIL_CHANNEL Net effect: APR_0415_APPROVAL_HOLD_QUORUM_FALSE

APR-0415 (id 415) remains pending — not approved, not executed, not deployed. 0 approvals were recorded. quorum_passed('APR-0415') = false. The only actor in this session is the proposing agent, which holds no president seat and no ai_council seat; no real president and no real council member acted through their own authenticated channel. Recording any vote would be fabrication / self-approval — forbidden — so none was recorded.

Why this verdict (not the others)

• Not APR_0415_QUORUM_READY_FOR_EXECUTION: 0 legitimate approvals; quorum false.
• Not APR_0415_APPROVALS_RECORDED_AWAITING_QUORUM: that requires ≥1 real approval to have been recorded this round. None was — no real approver channel was available.
• Not APR_0415_APPROVAL_HOLD_KB_READBACK_FAILED: all 7 files read back from AgentData KB.
• Not GOVERNED_C1_DRYRUN_REJECT_APPROVAL_FABRICATION / …_SELF_APPROVAL: nothing was fabricated and no self-approval was attempted — the agent declined to write any vote (this is a HOLD on absent real approvers, not a REJECT of an attempted bad act).
• Not GOVERNED_C1_DRYRUN_REJECT_SCOPE_DRIFT / …_READY_OVERCLAIM: scope stayed APR-0415-only; every readiness flag = NO.

Self-check (macro §8)

1. Avoided executing APR-0415? YES
2. Avoided deploy/bind/register? YES
3. Avoided W1→W9 / dry-run / Codex? YES
4. Did each approval come from a real approver/channel? N/A — 0 approvals; no real channel was available
5. Avoided self-approval? YES
6. Avoided approval fabrication? YES
7. Did approval rationale stay scoped to APR-0415 only? YES (template only; no vote cast)
8. Did quorum_passed read back true/false? YES — false
9. Did KB evidence read back? YES — 7/7

Writes made this turn

• 0 governed writes · 0 approvals · 0 executions · 0 deploys / binds / grants / DOT registrations.
• Only writes = this 7-file AgentData KB evidence package.

Next exact action (real approvers only — NOT this macro, NOT the agent)

1. Real human president casts apr_approvals(apr_id=415, approver_type='human', approver ILIKE '%president%', decision='approve', rationale=<scoped text in file 02>) via their own authenticated identity/channel.
2. Two real ai_council seats each cast apr_approvals(apr_id=415, approver_type='ai_council', decision='approve', …) via their own identities.
3. Confirm quorum_passed('APR-0415')='t' with 0 rejects ⇒ then (separate, owner-authorized macro) execute APR-0415 via dot-apr-execute.

Readiness flags

• ready for execution: NO (quorum 0/3)
• ready for Claude re-verification: NO unless executed
• ready for Codex final confirmation: NO
• ready for governed dry-run: NO
• ready for production: NO