KB-5E6D

C1-W7 APR-0415 Approval Round — 01 Before-Approval Readback

3 min read Revision 1

01 — APR-0415 before-approval readback (live, read-only)

All values below were read this turn via the governed read-only query_pg (READ ONLY txn, read-only role, statement_timeout 5s). No writes were issued.

APR-0415 row (approval_requests)

field value
id / code 415 / APR-0415
status pending
request_type_code fix_repair_dot
proposed_action_code patch_ops_code
target_collection dot_tools
priority high
source (proposer label) dot-c1-w7-authorize-build-step-handler-proposal
source_context proposer / created_by NULL / NULL
proposed_action.file_path /opt/incomex/dot/bin/dot-apr-execute
proposed_action.patch_mode full_replace
payload new_content_base64 md5 / len 3aa36821a66127ca9e3d93e6c2f3d987 / 46672

Payload hash + length match the proposal packet (…/c1-w7-apr-proposal-and-quorum-packet/03-apr-proposal-proof.md) → APR-0415 still carries exactly the bash -n-clean additive patch; nothing has mutated it.

Approvals (apr_approvals where apr_id=415)

rowcount = 0   (no rows)
metric value
total approvals 0
approve / reject 0 / 0
human president approvals (approver_type='human' AND approver ILIKE '%president%') 0 (need ≥1)
ai_council approvals (approver_type='ai_council') 0 (need ≥2)
rejects 0

Quorum + action risk

query result
quorum_passed('APR-0415') false
apr_action_types patch_ops_code risk_level / handler_ref high / dot-apr-execute:patch_ops
apr_action_types authorize_build_step risk_level / handler_ref high / unimplemented

authorize_build_step remaining unimplemented independently confirms no execution of APR-0415 has occurred (execution would deploy the new handler; it is still absent).

Proposer / self-exclusion note

source_context carries no proposer/created_by key, so quorum_passed computes v_proposer = NULL and excludes no one by name. This is benign: the proposer is the agent (source dot-c1-w7-authorize-build-step-handler-proposal), which holds no approver seat. The 3 required approvals must each come from a distinct real president/council identity — which is exactly what is not present this turn.

Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/c1-w7-apr-0415-approval-round/01-apr-0415-before-approval-readback.md