KB-759A

C1 Staging Codex R3 — P1 Plan P2 Review

1 min read Revision 1
c1stagingcodex-r3read-only2026-06-23

05 — P1 / PLAN / P2 CLEANUP REVIEW

Valid fixes

  • P1 owns partial-create compensation; cleanup failure forces 70.
  • plan gate requires CODEX_R3_PASS.
  • strict mode/pipefail preserve stage failures.
  • exit matrix produces nonzero for cleanup failure.
  • DRY_RUN_OK is emitted only after P2 return zero and global staging DB count zero.
  • R3-SELF-1 delayed arming closes the same-minute foreign-drop race.
  • P2 records attempt before DROP and success after gone-readback.

Evidence hardening still required

P2 returns zero for an already-absent DB without a drop_success stamp. In the plan's owned-sandbox path, an unexpected disappearance can therefore be treated as cleanup success if global count is zero. Require the owned cleanup path to prove RETIRED_OK/drop_success, or use a distinct strict P2 mode. This is secondary to the upstream-stamp blocker but belongs in the same evidence repair.

Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/c1-staging-codex-r3-final-review-before-dry-run/05-p1-plan-p2-cleanup-review.md