KB-3E03

C1 Staging Codex R3 — R2 and Self-Gate Review

1 min read Revision 1
c1stagingcodex-r3read-only2026-06-23

02 — R2 AND SELF-GATE FINDINGS REVIEW

Finding R3 result
P1 partial-create orphan fixed: own EXIT compensating trap
plan P2 failure swallowed fixed: four-way exit matrix
P6 digest omitted harness fixed: vocab+harness combined digest under SHARE locks
P1 --force blind drop fixed: --force exits 4
remote temp subshell tracker fixed: shared host tracking file
R3-SELF-1 foreign cleanup target fixed: precheck + SBX armed after P1 success
injection/P5/TTL R1 fixes retained

Finding missed by self-gate

P3 inserts c1_vocab_build and COMMITs before its exact-set fatal DO block. P4 and P5 follow the same ledger-before-gate pattern. P6 equates these rows with upstream DONE. Thus a ledger row proves the stage started and committed mutations, not that its fatal gate passed.

The self-gate checked strict plan sequencing, but R3 requires P6 itself to block partial upstream success.

Back to Knowledge Hub knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/c1-staging-codex-r3-final-review-before-dry-run/02-r2-and-self-gate-findings-review.md