15 — Pre-write gate final decision

VERDICT

C1_LEGO_PREWRITE_HOLD_GRANT_ISSUER_UNIMPLEMENTED

The KB canonicalization, registrar-defect mitigation, and W1→W6/W8/W9 are all GREEN, but the macro's explicit rule (§3.3) is triggered: the authorize_build_step grant issuer is unimplemented in the governed authority, so the plan is not prewrite-ready for owner-approved W1→W9. This is the honest stop — not a forced HOLD, not a ready-overclaim.

• ready for Codex final confirmation: NO
• ready for governed dry-run: NO
• ready for production: NO
• production writes this macro: 0 (live baseline re-checked unchanged: dot_tools 309 / contracts 2 / table_registry 21 / collections 164 / grants 0 / DOT_C1 0)

KB evidence (file 12) — exact list + hashes

• KB path knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/c1-lego-dryrun-plan-hardening-no-prod-write/
• 31 files uploaded + read back; 31/31 local sha256 == KB sha256; MISMATCH 0; missing 0; list_documents count=31.
• This round's gate files (12–15) uploaded after authoring; their KB hashes appended below.

SSOT classification (carried, file 00a)

CODE SSOT = VPS /opt/incomex (dot bin + /opt/incomex/deploy/agent-api-executor). EVIDENCE SSOT = AgentData KB. LOCAL web-test = staging only. No local file treated as governed proof.

G1/G2/G3/G4 status

• G1 registrar defect — RESOLVED (bare forbidden; filtered dry-run = 7 named C1 rows; 287/15 avoided; idempotency ×2; rollback).
• G2 DOT-approved registration — PROVEN (patched governed registrar, not manual POST).
• G3a contract-register — PATH PROVEN / staged / executable in-sequence.
• G3b endpoint — PATH PROVEN (source located + hash-matched + concrete additive patch; operator rebuild).
• G3c grant issuer — HOLD (unimplemented governed handler). ← binding blocker.
• G4 KB artifacts — PROVEN (31/31 hash match in AgentData KB).

W1→W9 readiness

W1–W6, W8, W9: DOT-100%, LEGO-small, rollback-equipped, executable in sequence. W7 (grant) not executable until the issuer is implemented DOT-100% (or an operator governed migration mints the single-use grant). The DOT-manage ledger path is in the KB and interleaved (not local-only).

Remaining blockers

1. authorize_build_step grant issuer unimplemented (binding) — implement the staged dot-c1-grant-issue as a born+admitted+registered DOT, or authorize an operator governed migration to mint the one single-use, manifest-bound C1 grant. Until then W7 cannot run DOT-100%.
2. (Non-blocking, disclosed) W6 endpoint = operator image rebuild on the VPS SSOT; W5 contract-register DOT must be born+registered first.

Is the next step owner-approved per-write execution?

Not yet for the full W1→W9. W1–W6/W8/W9 are owner-approvable now; W7 must first be unblocked (issuer implemented or operator migration authorized). Recommended next step: owner decides how to close the grant-issuer gap (implement issuer DOT vs. operator migration), then re-run the pre-write gate → on PASS, proceed to owner-approved per-write execution, then Codex final confirmation + Owner dry-run authorization.

Gates (explicit)

• ready for Codex final confirmation: NO
• ready for governed dry-run: NO
• ready for production: NO

This round's gate-file KB hashes (appended post-upload)

See file 12 for the 31-file base manifest. Files 12–15 hashes: recorded in the KB upload step of this macro (all MATCH); local shasum -a 256 of files 12–15 == KB-side sha256.