13 — FINAL DECISION — 2026-06-22

Verdict

C1_DRYRUN_HOLD_NO_GOVERNED_WRITE_CHANNEL (not forced).

Downstream-true consequences (all subsumed by the root): …_CONTRACTS_ABSENT, …_DIRECTUS_DOT_WIRING_INCOMPLETE, …_PREFLIGHT_NOT_READY, …_DRYRUN_NOT_DISPATCHABLE, …_BAD_INPUT_HARNESS_INCOMPLETE. Not a REJECT: no fail-open, no scope drift, no production/C2 mutation, no overclaim.

Macro completion criteria (READY allowed only if all 18 true)

1 gap map complete ✅ · 2 no unknown prerequisite ✅ · 3 write channel exists/created ❌ · 4 C1 contracts exist ❌ · 5 wiring exists ❌ · 6 manifest frozen+registered ❌ · 7 verifier rejects bad auth ❌ (not implemented) · 8 preflight ready ❌ · 9 dry-run dispatchable ❌ · 10 bad-input tests executable ❌ · 11 invalid input cannot PASS ✅ (nothing emits) · 12 rollback/no-state valid ✅ · 13 before/after/readback ✅ · 14 internal Codex review passes ✅ (HOLD upheld) · 15 no production mutation ✅ · 16 no registration/activation/corpus ✅ · 17 no C2/C3 mutation ✅ · 18 no mega pipeline ✅.

Items 3–10 are FALSE ⇒ final verdict must be HOLD, not READY (macro §2.1).

20-point self-check (macro §7)

1 complete gap map before closing? Yes. 2 avoided stopping at first missing item? Yes — all 18 prereqs + all write routes. 3 surveyed every governed write/test/sandbox route? Yes (file 02). 4 created/verified C1 contracts? Verified ABSENT; creation blocked. 5 created/verified wiring? Verified ABSENT; blocked. 6 created/verified manifest/hash? Design-only; not registered. 7 created/verified verifier/grant? Spec only; uncreatable. 8 preflight returned ready? No — none exists. 9 dry-run dispatchable by real command? No. 10 bad-input tests executable? No. 11 invalid input rejected fail-closed? Only real-run (live); rest not executable. 12 any invalid input produced PASS/digest/seal? No. 13 if yes, REJECT? N/A. 14 rollback/clean state proven? Yes (no state). 15 before/after/readback proven? Yes. 16 avoided production/corpus/activation? Yes. 17 avoided C2/C3? Yes. 18 avoided mega pipelines? Yes. 19 internal Codex review passed? Yes (HOLD upheld). 20 prerequisite still missing ⇒ HOLD not READY? Yes.

Final report fields

• verdict: C1_DRYRUN_HOLD_NO_GOVERNED_WRITE_CHANNEL
• stop state: full gap map complete; closure externally blocked (macro outcome B)
• full gap map summary: 18 prerequisites; 14 blocking; 0 closable this session
• items found missing: C1 contracts, schema-ensure/vocab-build/verify/preflight/harness/evidence/rollback DOTs, C1 collection, C1 table_registry row, C1 manifest/resolver (registered), verifier handler, grant, C1 preflight, dispatch route, sandbox lane, DDL channel
• items created: none governed (1 inert disclosed docs file)
• items verified existing: table_registry (generic), governance_build_authorization (0 rows, structurally complete), dispatcher (validation-only), DOT_KG_EXPLAIN pair, 54-cmd catalog
• write channel proof: governed directus_create DENIED for C1 + contract registry; no sandbox; write_file docs-only; query_pg read-only; no DDL/exec tool (files 02/11)
• C1 contract proof: absent & uncreatable (file 03)
• wiring proof: absent & uncreatable (file 04)
• manifest/hash proof: design-only, not registered (file 05)
• auth verifier proof: spec-complete, unimplemented; no grant possible (file 06)
• preflight result: none; 8/9 checks would fail (file 07)
• dry-run dispatchability: NOT dispatchable (file 08)
• bad-input result: defined, not executable; no fail-open (file 09)
• rollback/dismantle: vacuous; clean by absence (file 10)
• before/after/readback: governed diff ∅ (file 11)
• internal Codex review: HOLD upheld, READY withheld, not REJECT (file 12)
• ready for Codex review: YES (HOLD evidence complete)
• ready for dry-run: NO
• ready for production: NO
• remaining blockers: governed DDL/registration write path + isolated sandbox lane + sovereign grant authority (all external to this session)
• REGISTRATION_HOLD: ACTIVE
• REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED: NO
• P2 / named lane: CLOSED / NOT OPENED / NOT AUTHORIZED
• DO NOT IMPLEMENT: confirmed