C1-DRYRUN-EXECUTION — Index — 2026-06-22

Mission (macro C1_DRYRUN_EXECUTED_AND_SELF_PROVEN_READY_FOR_CODEX_CONFIRMATION): under the user's C1-only / test-sandbox-only build-prep authorization, actually create the C1 executable contract, run a C1 dry-run, run bad-input/adversarial tests, run rollback/dismantle, and produce before/after/readback evidence — or stop at the precise HOLD if the required write channel / runtime is missing.

VERDICT: C1_DRYRUN_HOLD_TEST_SANDBOX_AUTH_OR_RUNTIME_MISSING (not forced). STOP STATE: the test/sandbox write channel + execution runtime required to create-and-dry-run the C1 contract do not exist in this environment. No C1 executable contract could be created; therefore no C1 dry-run could be executed. Ready for Codex confirmation of an executed dry-run: NO (no dry-run executed). Ready for production: NO. REGISTRATION_HOLD: ACTIVE · REGISTRATION_CAN_PROCEED: NO · P2 / named lane: CLOSED · 0 runtime mutations · DO NOT IMPLEMENT.

---

Why HOLD (one line)

The user authorized the intent (create/register + dry-run C1 in test/sandbox). But every write/execution channel available is closed: query_pg runs as a read-only role; MCP CRUD → 403 for governed/schema writes (Directus Operating Rules SSOT v1.2); raw SQL DDL/DML is forbidden by this macro as an authority path; the only governed schema-creation primitive that could build the C1 table (DOT_C1_SCHEMA_ENSURE) does not exist; the dispatcher raises on REAL_RUN; and no C1 contract exists to dispatch even a dry-run against. The missing thing is not user authorization — it is the governed build-prep registration channel (Gate-B), which has no executable surface here. Macro §0/§5: "If real credentials, runtime access, or required write channel are missing, do not ask the user. Stop with the precise HOLD state."

Files

File	Subject	Result
01	Source register + authority/scope proof	C1-only/test-sandbox authorization recorded; capability ≠ authorization
02	Live environment + test/sandbox inventory (read-only)	Runtime reachable; no C1 contract/table/view/handler; no C1 sandbox lane; no write channel
03	C1 executable contract registration or HOLD	Option C — cannot create: no governed creation primitive, MCP 403, raw SQL forbidden, no write tool
04	C1 manifest/resolver + hash proof	Resolver R_C1 deterministic (PATCH2); join still 0; cannot freeze without contract → residual
05	C1 authorization verifier + consume proof	Verifier exact (status='active', set-equality); 0 grants live; consume handler absent
06	C1 dry-run command log + output	NOT EXECUTED — nothing to dispatch; honest non-execution record
07	C1 adversarial bad-input results	Design-fixtures enumerated; none executable (no surface); no input can yield PASS/digest/seal because no surface emits any
08	C1 rollback / dismantle / clean-state	No test/sandbox state was created → nothing to roll back; clean-state trivially proven (0 writes)
09	Before/after/readback evidence	Before == After (read-only); diff = ∅; readback confirms 0 mutations
10	Internal Codex negative review (A1–A15)	Attacks applied; HOLD upheld (A1/A2 succeed → cannot be READY)
11	Final decision	C1_DRYRUN_HOLD_TEST_SANDBOX_AUTH_OR_RUNTIME_MISSING
codex-review-packet	One-page reproduction + HOLD basis for Codex confirmation	—

Rollup: knowledge/dev/laws-new/reports/macro-c1-dryrun-execution-2026-06-22.md.

Closure summary

• Cannot create C1 contract (file 03): no governed creation channel → root blocker.
• Cannot dry-run (file 06): no contract to dispatch + dispatcher cannot REAL_RUN.
• Bad-input / rollback (files 07/08): no executable surface; 0 state created; no fail-open and no executed test.
• Authority/resolver (files 04/05): exact designs carried from PATCH2; authority/runtime residual unchanged.
• Evidence (file 09): before==after, 0 mutations, fully read-back.

Carry-forward

Carried blockers from PATCH1/PATCH2 remain UNCHANGED; this package adds no new runtime blocker or reject-code (all codes herein are design labels / classifier states). NEXT = GPT → Codex confirmation that (a) the live HOLD is real and (b) the next gate is a governed Gate-B build-prep registration capability (a write channel + the DOT_C1_SCHEMA_ENSURE creation primitive) — only after the C1 executable contracts exist and are read-back-verifiable can a dry-run be dispatched, bad-input executed against a live surface, and rollback exercised. Residual ⇒ a future C1_DRYRUN re-attempt once that channel exists.