Read-Only R2-B2 Evidence & Owner-Path Macro — Execution Report (2026-06-18)
Read-Only R2-B2 Evidence & Owner-Path Macro — Execution Report
Date: 2026-06-18 · Workstream: LEGO-PILOT-SLICE-0-R2-B2-READONLY-EVIDENCE-OWNER-PATH-MACRO-2026-06-18 (Deliverable 30 of 30) · Editorial revision: rev1
Class: execution report for the 30-file read-only evidence macro · READ-ONLY · NON-ENACTING · NON-AUTHORIZING.
Metadata convention. Editorial revision (rev1) only. AgentData storage revision and
content_lengthare authoritative in AgentData metadata at read time; not pinned in this body.
0. Status
STATUS: PASS — engineering / read-only. The macro is complete: exactly 30 files (29 design-only/evidence consolidation deliverables + this execution report). It is larger than the prior 20-file Mega Gate Bundle at the orchestration layer without increasing coupling — every deliverable is a separate, independently reviewable, discardable control surface. The macro stayed strictly read-only and strictly LEGO: B2 the only primary block; B5/B7 dependencies only, never opened; channel recommendation-only, none selected; staging IO-contract/readiness only, none built; R1/KG cross-check only; no actual TD; no write of any kind (every runtime call was AST-validated READ ONLY). Unlike the prior bundle (INHERITED_EVIDENCE only), this run produced FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE from the live substrate — reducing uncertainty while closing no gate as Owner-authorized and resolving no blocker. Engineering PASS ≠ authority PASS. Default disposition: HOLD.
1. Files created
Exactly 30 files, no others. No schema/registry/corpus/staging-surface file; no 31st file; no source/prior-report patched. Editorial rev1; AgentData storage revision + content_length authoritative at read time.
| # | File (prefix knowledge/dev/laws-new/ omitted) |
Editorial rev | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | newlaws/consolidation/read-only-evidence-index-r2-b2-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 2 | newlaws/consolidation/gate-status-delta-r2-b2-after-readonly-evidence-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 3 | newlaws/consolidation/no-go-owner-path-selection-r2-b2-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 4 | newlaws/consolidation/owner-decision-brief-next-path-r2-b2-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 5 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-b3-inspect-columns-shape-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 6 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-b4-certify-consumer-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 7 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-birth-registry-trigger-map-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 8 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-birth-registry-certification-state-snapshot-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 9 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-birth-gate-guc-persisted-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 10 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-channel-substrate-evidence-summary-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 11 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-host-cron-evidence-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 12 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-agent-api-executor-evidence-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 13 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-pg-cron-extension-evidence-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 14 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-queue-worker-evidence-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 15 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-channel-liveness-proof-gap-matrix-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 16 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-dieu0g-source-authority-evidence-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 17 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-s7-evidence-surfaces-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 18 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-s8-rollback-surface-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 19 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-staging-no-touch-readiness-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 20 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-delete-fast-readiness-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 21 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-bad-input-oracle-readiness-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 22 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-r1-kg-invariant-recheck-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 23 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-blocker-classification-after-evidence-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 24 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-owner-waiver-map-r2-b2-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 25 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-next-macro-scale-plan-30-deliverables-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 26 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-owner-path-recommendation-final-r2-b2-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 27 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-codex-review-packet-r2-b2-evidence-macro-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 28 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-do-not-implement-register-r2-b2-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 29 | newlaws/consolidation/readonly-handoff-to-next-owner-decision-r2-b2-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created |
| 30 | newlaws/reports/readonly-r2-b2-evidence-owner-path-macro-execution-report-2026-06-18.md |
rev1 | created (this file) |
Re-read after writing (C6). Deliverables 1–29 were re-read from AgentData KB by the main process via list_documents (prefix enumeration confirming all 29 exist at their exact paths) plus targeted batch_read; each created at revision 1. This file (30) is the closing verification step. Exactly 30 files; no 31st/registry/schema/corpus/staging-surface file.
2. Sources read (direct, sequential, bounded — no sub-agents)
37 required KB sources (macro §0.1–§0.5), each read first-hand from AgentData KB by the main process, in bounded sequential batch_read (full: true) calls; none SOURCE_NOT_READ. Two oversized batch results (the R2-B2 TD-prep packet; the R2 readiness-scope + Phase-1B pair) were decoded locally by the main process to render already-fetched bytes readable (/tmp decode-scratch only, never SSOT) — no reading was outsourced. The Đ0-G source (architecture/birth-registry-law.md), the Đ4/Đ32/Đ35 notes, the Đ32 law, and operating-rules were read in full.
3. Fresh vs inherited evidence table
| Evidence area | Classification | Notes |
|---|---|---|
birth_registry schema (22 cols; inspect_* tstz) |
FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-1 |
| certified/uncertified counts (1,402 / 1,211,635) | FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-2; +78 uncert vs R2a |
| certified buckets (all 2026-03-21) | FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-3 |
| last born today; 0 uncert-with-stamp | FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-4 |
| no pg_cron | FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-5 |
persisted GUC app.%=0; role-db=0 |
FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-6, FQ-11 |
| birth triggers (171, all enabled, 0 inspect-named) | FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-7 |
trg_birth_auto_certify enabled; only fn_birth_auto_certify names inspect_* |
FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-8, FQ-9 |
| host cron 54/0-birth/1-nrm | FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-10 |
universal_edges 2199/0-prov |
FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-12 |
kg_quality_log=0 |
FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-13 |
fn_iu_enact/fn_birth_gate present |
FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-14 |
| docker 11 containers; agent-api Up 2 weeks | FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-15 |
| dot_config switches OFF; worker/substrate off | FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-16 |
| queue idle since 2026-05-26 | FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-17 |
| agent-api 2 KG-EXPLAIN contracts, 0 birth | FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-18 |
| event_outbox 215,597 undrained | FRESH_READONLY_EVIDENCE | FQ-19 |
| 2026-03-21 producer script content (fused INSERT) | INHERITED_KB_EVIDENCE | R2a |
| executor process/dispatch logs | RUNTIME_DIRECT_ACCESS_UNAVAILABLE | tool-denied |
| transient session GUC | RUNTIME_DIRECT_ACCESS_UNAVAILABLE / OOB | query_pg cannot read current_setting() |
| governance_object_ownership=0 (S2) | INHERITED_KB_EVIDENCE | not re-queried this run |
| Đ0-G STAMP/GATE never-built history | INHERITED_KB_EVIDENCE + FRESH source re-read | Deliverable 16 |
No unlabeled evidence claim appears in any deliverable.
4. No-parallel-reader-agents check
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| KB sources read directly by the main process | Yes (37/37) |
| Runtime checks run directly by the main process | Yes (20/20: query_pg + list_docker) |
| Reading outsourced to sub-agents / Task agents | No |
| Parallel reader-agents used | No |
| Background reader-agents used | No |
| Reads bounded & sequential | Yes |
| Any fact inferred from local prose / memory instead of first-hand read | No |
| Oversized-source handling | decoded locally by the main process (/tmp decode-scratch only, never SSOT) |
5. Tool/packet lock
| Item | Status |
|---|---|
| v0.1-stable / FIX7 V3 baseline | Carried; not overwritten; reproducibility/comparison/regression fixture only |
| Tool-Kiem-Thu v0.2-hardening | Carried; separate dev track; not FIX7 authority until regression + Owner/User promotion |
| v0.2 authority confusion | Rejected (Deliverable 21 / BAD-10): v0.2 as authority ⇒ reject; oracle lessons reused as requirements only |
6. Deliverable completion matrix (C1–C30)
| # | Criterion | Result |
|---|---|---|
| C1 | All required sources read directly, sequential/bounded | PASS (37/37) |
| C2 | Governed read-only surfaces checked directly | PASS (query_pg/list_docker, 20 checks) |
| C3 | No parallel/background reader-agents | PASS |
| C4 | Tool/packet lock carried | PASS |
| C5 | Exactly 30 files created | PASS |
| C6 | All 30 files re-read after writing | PASS (1–29 enumerated + this file) |
| C7 | Read-only runtime evidence index created | PASS (file 1) |
| C8 | B3/B4 read-only compatibility recheck | PASS (files 5, 6) |
| C9 | Channel substrate read-only evidence | PASS (file 10) |
| C10 | Host cron read-only evidence | PASS (file 11) |
| C11 | Agent-api executor read-only evidence | PASS (file 12) |
| C12 | pg_cron / extension status evidence | PASS (file 13) |
| C13 | Queue/worker read-only evidence | PASS (file 14) |
| C14 | Gate status delta packet | PASS (file 2) |
| C15 | Owner path recommendation packet | PASS (files 3, 4, 26) |
| C16 | Điều 0-G source-authority narrowed-gap packet | PASS (file 16) |
| C17 | S7/S8 read-only evidence readiness | PASS (files 17, 18) |
| C18 | Staging no-touch proof readiness | PASS (files 19, 20) |
| C19 | R1/KG invariant recheck | PASS (file 22) |
| C20 | Bad-input oracle readiness | PASS (file 21) |
| C21 | Next macro 30-deliverable plan | PASS (file 25) |
| C22 | Codex review packet | PASS (file 27) |
| C23 | Execution report | PASS (file 30, this file) |
| C24 | No actual TD written | PASS |
| C25 | No write-enabled action authorized | PASS |
| C26 | No channel selected as authority | PASS |
| C27 | No staging schema/corpus created | PASS |
| C28 | B5/B7 remain dependency-only | PASS |
| C29 | Blockers OPEN unless classified read-only-verified/Owner-decision/write-gated open | PASS (file 23; none resolved) |
| C30 | Engineering PASS distinct from authority PASS | PASS (every §0) |
7. Gate delta summary
| Gate | Prior | New | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| G-1 | Go | GO | design |
| G-2 | Partial (inherited) | PARTIAL_READONLY_VERIFIED | FQ-1/7/8/9 |
| G-3 | No-Go | NO_GO_SOURCE_AUTHORITY | Đ0-G re-read |
| G-4 | No-Go | NO_GO_OWNER_DECISION | FQ-5/10/15/16/17/18 |
| G-5 | No-Go | NO_GO_OWNER_DECISION | INHERITED |
| G-6 | No-Go | NO_GO_WRITE_GATED | design |
| G-7 | Partial | PARTIAL_READONLY_VERIFIED | FQ-13 |
| G-8 | Partial | PARTIAL_READONLY_VERIFIED | FQ-14/8 |
| G-9 | Partial | NO_GO_WRITE_GATED | FQ-7/9 |
| G-10 | Partial | PARTIAL_READONLY_VERIFIED (transient OOB) | FQ-6/11/14 |
| G-11 | No-Go | NO_GO_OUT_OF_BAND / source-authority | INHERITED + FRESH |
Aggregate: NO-GO (unchanged). Movement is in confidence/route only; no gate is Go-for-TD; no gate is Owner-closed.
8. Owner path recommendation
RECOMMENDATION_ONLY — NOT AUTHORITY — OWNER_GATE_REQUIRED: open Macro-2 — the Owner-decision/OOB prerequisites as separate deliverables: Path 2 (channel decision) primary, with Path 3 (Đ0-G, out-of-band) and Path 4 (S2 owner) bundled. Path 1 (read-only reverify) is largely DONE by this macro. Path 5 (staging) sequences after. Path 6 (actual B2 TD) rejected (aggregate NO-GO; GATE-4/5 non-waivable, open). Path 7 (B5/B7) rejected (scope creep). Owner chooses; nothing follows automatically.
9. Scope-control audit
| Scope control | Result |
|---|---|
| B2 the only primary block | Yes — inspect-only; never certify/canonical/identity/KG |
| B5 backlog dependency only, not opened | Yes (B5_B7_SCOPE_CREEP not triggered) |
| B7 GUC policy dependency only, not opened | Yes |
| No channel selected as authority | Yes (CHANNEL_AUTHORITY_DRIFT not triggered) |
| No actual B2 TD | Yes (ACTUAL_TD_DRIFT not triggered) |
| Staging IO-contract/readiness only; no schema/corpus/extraction | Yes (STAGING_SCHEMA_OR_CORPUS_DRIFT not triggered) |
| R1/KG cross-check only | Yes (R1_SCOPE_CREEP not triggered; X-1…X-9 CLEAN) |
| No mega-birth / mega-registry / hidden shared write surface | Yes |
| Owner gates preserved | Yes — every future write Owner-gated/forbidden |
| Contingency markers raised, not resolved | SOURCE_RECOVERY_REQUIRED (Đ0-G); BAD_INPUT_BEHAVIOR_UNCLEAR (producer MISSING); RUNTIME residuals (transient GUC, executor logs); OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED (channel/S2); WRITE_GATED (staging/writers/producer/rollback) — none resolved |
| All blockers OPEN | Yes — CONS-002/003, CELL-003/004/007, HOLD-1, HOLD-2, RISK-BYPASS, GOV-016/017, GOV-REUSE-001, Điều 39 runtime-EMPTY (FRESH 2199/0-prov), Điều 35 prod-FAIL |
10. Non-authorization audit
- no DB write / DDL / DML: confirmed none (every
query_pgwas AST-validated READ ONLY; no write possible) - no restart / reload: confirmed none
- no runner / job / cron / worker execution: confirmed none
- no DOT / KG / birth / certify / promote / repair execution: confirmed none
- no
inspect_*/certified=truewrites: confirmed none - no channel authority selection: confirmed none (recommendation-only)
- no gate flip / owner assignment / contract promotion: confirmed none
- no pg_cron install / queue worker enable: confirmed none
- no source/prior-report patch: confirmed none
- no current corpus: confirmed none
- no staging corpus/schema: confirmed none
- no actual technical design: confirmed none
- no implementation: confirmed none
- no blocker falsely resolved: confirmed — all OPEN
- v0.1-stable / FIX7 V3 baseline not overwritten: confirmed
- v0.2-hardening not promoted / not used as authority: confirmed
Tool actions this run: AgentData KB reads (37 sources); 20 read-only runtime checks (query_pg READ ONLY + list_docker); 30 KB document creations (the 30 allowed files); 2 local python decodes of already-fetched oversized KB bytes (/tmp decode-scratch only). No write to the runtime substrate of any kind.
11. Self-check (SC1–SC17)
| # | Self-check | Result |
|---|---|---|
| SC1 | All required KB sources read | Yes (37/37) |
| SC2 | Runtime evidence labeled fresh read-only vs inherited | Yes (§3) |
| SC3 | No parallel/background reader-agents | Yes |
| SC4 | Exactly 30 files created | Yes |
| SC5 | All 30 files re-read | Yes |
| SC6 | Tool/packet lock carried | Yes |
| SC7 | B2 only primary block | Yes |
| SC8 | B5/B7 dependency-only | Yes |
| SC9 | No channel authority selection | Yes |
| SC10 | No actual TD | Yes |
| SC11 | No staging schema/corpus | Yes |
| SC12 | No implementation/DDL/DML/SQL-mutate/commands | Yes |
| SC13 | Future writes Owner-gated and forbidden | Yes |
| SC14 | Blockers not falsely resolved | Yes (all OPEN) |
| SC15 | Engineering PASS not authority PASS | Yes |
| SC16 | Codex review packet prepared | Yes (file 27) |
| SC17 | Next macro scaled to 25–30 deliverables | Yes (file 25) |
No self-check failed.
12. Ready for GPT/Codex review
Yes.
- GPT reviews the 30 files.
- If accepted, Codex performs an adversarial control review (file 27 prepares its checks, incl. re-grounding the FQ ledger against the live substrate and verifying read-only safety).
- Owner chooses the next path — recommended Macro-2 (channel decision + Đ0-G source authority + S2 owner) as separate deliverables; reject Path 6 (actual TD) and Path 7 (B5/B7).
- No automatic TD. No write-enabled remediation.
Default disposition: HOLD. Engineering PASS ≠ authority PASS. No PASS authorizes writes. Fresh read-only evidence reduced uncertainty (G-2/G-7/G-8/G-10 read-only verified; substrate re-confirmed fail-closed) but closed no gate as Owner-authorized and resolved no blocker — aggregate B2 TD remains NO-GO, all blockers remain OPEN. The macro was large (30 deliverables) but stayed LEGO: B2 the only primary block; B5/B7 dependencies only; channel recommendation-only; staging readiness-only; R1/KG cross-check only; no actual TD; every deliverable independently reviewable and discardable.