Commercial Verify Report — M-001 + M-002

Date: 2026-03-03 | Agent: claude_code (Opus 4.6) Mission: COMMERCIAL-VERIFY — Close remaining 3 gaps

T4: L2 Locked Logic — PASS

Code Review

File: components/modules/comment-module/partials/CheckpointPanel.vue

Logic chain:

1. l1Complete = computed(() => layers.value.find(l => l.layer === 'L1')?.complete || false) (line 24-27)
2. isLayerLocked(layer) = layer === 'L2' && !l1Complete.value (line 49-51)
3. buildLayerProgress() in useCheckpoints.ts: complete = total > 0 && passed === total (line 72)

UI Enforcement (4 layers):

• Visual: opacity-50 on L2 section when locked (line 99)
• Label: "Locked (L1 incomplete)" text displayed (line 107-109)
• Cursor: cursor-not-allowed on checkpoint items (line 134)
• Click: blocked via !isLayerLocked(lp.layer) && toggleCheckpoint(...) (line 136)

Live Data Test

Step 1 — L1 incomplete (baseline):

• L1 checkpoints: #6 passed, #7 failed, #8 pending
• L1 passed=1, total=3 → complete=false
• L2 locked = TRUE

Step 2 — PATCH L1 #7 and #8 to passed:

• L1 passed=3, total=3 → complete=true
• L2 locked = FALSE (unlocked)

Step 3 — Reverted to original state:

• #7 reverted to failed, #8 reverted to pending

Note: Enforcement is CLIENT-SIDE only. No server-side validation prevents L2 checkpoint updates via direct API call. This is acceptable for current use case (UI-driven workflow) but should be noted for future hardening.

T11: Standalone Mount — PASS

Search Results

Searched ALL files in:

• components/modules/comment-module/ (5 files)
• components/modules/workflow-module/ (2 files)
• composables/useTasks.ts, useWorkflows.ts, useCheckpoints.ts

ZERO occurrences of useRoute, $route, route.params, or route.query.

Architecture Pattern

Both modules use prop-driven architecture:

• CommentModule: taskId prop → computed(() => props.taskId) → useComments(taskIdRef)
• WorkflowViewer: workflowId prop → computed(() => props.workflowId) → useWorkflow(workflowIdRef)
• WorkflowModeler: same pattern as Viewer
• CheckpointPanel: taskId prop → useCheckpoints(taskIdRef)

Verdict: Modules can be mounted on ANY page, modal, or sidebar. No router dependency. Props are the SOLE input contract.

T2: Filter Agent Type — PASS

Query

GET /items/task_comments?filter[agent_type][_eq]=claude_code&fields=id,agent_type,tab_scope,content

Result

5 records returned, ALL with agent_type: "claude_code":

• #130 (checklist) — Phase 0 permission test
• #140 (planning) — Phase 3 test
• #143 (planning) — S86 Verify
• #160 (general) — CONN-ENFORCE verify
• #213 (planning) — T1-TEST commercial grade

No cross-contamination. Filter works correctly.

Summary

Item	Status	Evidence
T4: L2 Locked Logic	PASS	Code: lines 24-51, Live: PATCH L1→passed unlocked L2
T11: Standalone Mount	PASS	0 useRoute() in 7 module files + 3 composables
T2: Agent Type Filter	PASS	5/5 results match filter, 0 cross-contamination

Final Verdict: COMMERCIAL CONFIRMED

All 3 remaining gaps verified. Combined with 21/21 items from PR #420/#421, total score: 24/24 items PASS.

M-001 (CommentModule) and M-002 (WorkflowModule) are certified COMMERCIAL GRADE.